Local News

Georgia schools should review danger of carbon monoxide, report says

By Mark Niesse
Sept 11, 2013

Carbon monoxide safety tips

Source: Office of Georgia Insurance Commissioner Ralph Hudgens

All public schools in Georgia should evaluate whether carbon monoxide poses a danger in their facilities, but the state shouldn’t require schools to install detection systems for the toxic gas, according to a task force’s report released Wednesday.

The report is the result of a review ordered by Gov. Nathan Deal after carbon monoxide buildup sickened about 40 students and staff members at Atlanta’s Finch Elementary School on Dec. 3, 2012. The school was evacuated, and those affected by headaches, dizziness and drowsiness were treated at area hospitals.

A state requirement for carbon monoxide detectors would be costly and unnecessary at some schools, said Georgia Department of Community Affairs Commissioner Gretchen Corbin.

Schools that use fuel-fired water heaters, furnaces, generators and cooking equipment are more likely to produce carbon monoxide, while newer schools with electric heating systems and appliances have a lower risk.

“A school-by-school assessment of the need for carbon monoxide detectors by local officials combined with good training for schools staff is more beneficial than a state mandate,” Corbin said.

Few school systems in Georgia routinely measure and monitor carbon monoxide, but educators became more aware of the hazard after the incident at Finch Elementary, said Mike Rowland, director of facilities services for the Georgia Department of Education.

“The advice of the task force is that every school district do some kind of assessment and make their own determination about whether detection and monitoring devices are required,” said Rowland, a member of the carbon monoxide task force.

After school systems identify potential carbon monoxide problems, they should develop a plan to replace old equipment or install detectors, according to the task force’s report.

Two states, Connecticut and Maryland, have passed laws requiring carbon monoxide detection in schools, the report said. Two bills and one resolution pending before the Georgia General Assembly call for requiring for carbon monoxide detectors in schools.

The primary danger of carbon monoxide occurs in buildings where people sleep, the report said.

The cost of installing stand-alone carbon monoxide detectors in existing school buildings would be $168 per unit, or $375 per unit if they were connected to a fire alarm control panel, according to the report. There are more than 8,000 schools in the state, but the task force didn’t estimate a total cost for installing detectors statewide because each school is designed differently.

At Finch Elementary, carbon monoxide accumulated when maintenance workers neglected to reopen a valve on the school furnace, Atlanta Public Schools officials said at the time. The incident was caused by “human error,” not equipment failure, the report said.

“These voluntary guidelines will assist all school districts across the state in preventing future related incidents,” said APS spokeswoman Kimberly Willis Green.

About the Author

Mark Niesse is an enterprise reporter and covers elections and Georgia government for The Atlanta Journal-Constitution and is considered an expert on elections and voting. Before joining the AJC, he worked for The Associated Press in Atlanta, Honolulu and Montgomery, Alabama. He also reported for The Daily Report and The Santiago Times in Chile.

More Stories