“What other recourse do we have as private citizens? This is our right to vote,” asked Donna Curling, a longtime election security advocate from Fulton County and a plaintiff in a lawsuit seeking hand-marked paper ballots. “There are problems all over the place. I think we’re going to have a rocky month of November.”
Legal skirmishes have the potential to delay final results in Georgia races if election officials are forced to conduct recounts or review rejected ballots. Combined with a large number of absentee ballots that are expected, results might not be known for days.
The ongoing lawsuits come with a significant cost to Georgia taxpayers, totaling $3.2 million in attorney fees and expenses, according to the attorney general’s office. The costs were spread among several outside attorneys hired to help defend the state over the past three litigious years.
The plaintiffs also have to spend either their own money or their donors' contributions. Cases are often brought by activists, voters and organizations including the American Civil Liberties Union, the Lawyers' Committee for Civil Rights Under Law, the NAACP and the New Georgia Project. At least a dozen organizations are plaintiffs in active court cases in Georgia.
Georgia Attorney General Chris Carr said the election lawsuits are often politically motivated efforts that ask judges, instead of state representatives, to set policy.
“This litigation is expensive and does indeed fall on the shoulders of the taxpayers of Georgia,” Carr said. “In addition, these suits are all too often political in nature and are better suited for the legislative process rather than the court system.”
Josh Belinfante is part of a team of lawyers representing Georgia Secretary of State Brad Raffensperger in election lawsuits. Over the past three years, $3.2 million in taxpayer money has been spent on attorney fees and other expenses as the state defended itself in court cases involving voting issues. HYOSUB SHIN / HSHIN@AJC.COM
Credit: HYOSUB SHIN / AJC
Credit: HYOSUB SHIN / AJC
A coronavirus election
The surge of litigation isn’t just affecting Georgia, said Justin Levitt, a professor at Loyola Law School who oversaw voting rights cases in the Justice Department during the Obama administration. At least 233 election cases related to COVID-19 are pending in federal courts across the country, including six in Georgia, according to Levitt’s count.
“The rules that may be applicable when we don’t have a once-in-a-century pandemic may not always be applicable when we have a once-in-a-century pandemic,” Levitt said. “This year, we should expect courts to be more active across the board because the pandemic circumstances actually create emergencies that the courts may be better at resolving than legislators.”
The list of lawsuits will only grow if voters have trouble casting their ballots — a guarantee in any election, no less one that relies heavily on absentee ballots during potential U.S. Postal Service delays and socially distanced in-person voting, where anyone could be a contagious virus carrier.
Political parties, activist groups, candidates and voters are expected to turn to the courts to try to keep polling places open late, count mismarked ballots, adjudicate unclear choices, conduct recounts, provide relief from long lines, and tally late-arriving absentee and provisional ballots.
Similar last-minute legal wrangling played out in the heated 2018 election when a series of rulings ordered election officials to review and count thousands of absentee and provisional ballots that had been rejected in the races for governor between Republican Brian Kemp and Democrat Stacey Abrams, as well as the contest for Georgia’s 7th Congressional District.
Secretary of State Brad Raffensperger is appealing the ruling on an absentee ballot deadline, escalating the dispute over whether to count ballots that were postmarked by Election Day and received within three days. His attorneys argue the change from the state’s Election Day deadline for ballots to be returned will delay results and confuse voters.
Legal action over vote counting might be inevitable in Georgia’s highly competitive, nationally watched election, said Halsey Knapp, an attorney in the absentee ballot deadline case as well as lawsuits over election security and long lines.
“I would argue we’re at the epicenter of voting rights litigation in the country,” Knapp said. “Voter suppression and cheating, so to speak, have been part of Georgia’s voting legacy.”
Nse Ufot, executive director of the New Georgia Project, says the judicial system must act when the Legislature fails to protect voters' rights. “It’s extraordinarily important that the courts play this role,” she said.
Credit: Mark Niesse
Credit: Mark Niesse
The politics of voting rights
While Georgia’s Republican-led government is on the defensive against lawsuits from Democrats and nonprofit organizations seeking to expand voting rights beyond the limits of state laws, Republicans are battling back.
The Trump campaign and the Republican Party are planning a large poll-watching operation in 15 battleground states, including Georgia, to look out for potential voting fraud. Though fraud has been rare in recent years, Raffensperger raised the prospect when he announced Tuesday that about 1,000 people were able to vote twice in Georgia’s primary.
“In yet another state, Democrats and Joe Biden are attempting to rewrite our laws and institute wholesale election changes that fit their far-left agenda,” said Savannah Viar, the Trump campaign’s Georgia spokeswoman. “It is critical that voters maintain confidence in our election process when they cast a ballot. ”
The Democratic Party of Georgia also plans to train poll watchers and encourage voters to call a hotline to report problems.
The Trump campaign and the Republican National Committee are involved in election lawsuits in 19 states, but Georgia isn’t one of them. Georgia’s Republican elected officials are defending lawsuits against the state.
A broad lawsuit filed by Fair Fight Action, the voting rights group started by Abrams after the 2018 election, could be used to seek emergency relief from the courts when problems arise, spokesman Seth Bringman said. The underlying lawsuit over voter registration cancellations, precinct closures, long lines and disqualified ballots is pending, and a trial won’t be held until next year.
The ACLU of Georgia, which is appealing a ruling that found a postage requirement for voters to mail absentee ballots isn’t a poll tax, is ready to respond to potential problems, both with mailed-in ballots and at polling places, said Andrea Young, the civil rights organization’s state executive director.
“There are so many things that can go wrong in a highly contested election like this,” Young said. “The courts have got to make sure that they are receptive to problems with the vote. The point is to say that every vote should be counted.”
Judges often decide voting cases by weighing the harm to voters against the burden on election officials, relying on U.S. Supreme Court precedent, the Constitution’s free speech and due process protections, and laws governing election processes. As Election Day draws nearer, courts will be more reluctant to inject themselves because of the risk of confusing voters at the last minute, a principle established by a 2006 Supreme Court case, Levitt said.
Where plaintiffs view the courts as a last resort to protect fundamental voting rights, others see judicial activism.
For example, Tom Fitton of Judicial Watch said the court ruling permitting late absentee ballots to be counted overrode the well-established laws set by the Georgia General Assembly.
“This judge on her own has decided that because of coronavirus, election rules should be thrown out,” said Fitton, the president of Judicial Watch, which files records requests and lawsuits to investigate government misconduct. “The left sees friendly courts as a vehicle to affect policy change. The stakes are high from their perspective.”
But without the courts, election laws don’t always protect equal rights for disenfranchised voters, said Nse Ufot, executive director of the New Georgia Project, a voter registration organization and plaintiff in the absentee ballot deadline case.
“It’s been a while since my high school government class, but from what I recall there are three branches of government. When the Legislature fails to write laws that protect voters' rights, the people have options," Ufot said. “It’s extraordinarily important that the courts play this role.”
Three ways to vote in Georgia
Absentee: All registered voters are eligible to cast an absentee ballot without having to provide an excuse. Voters can order an absentee ballot online at ballotrequest.sos.ga.gov, or they can download and mail a paper absentee ballot request form from the secretary of state’s website.
Early voting: Three weeks of in-person early voting begins Oct. 12, including at the state’s largest voting location at State Farm Arena in Atlanta.
Election Day: About 2,500 polling places will open across Georgia on Nov. 3 from 7 a.m. to 7 p.m. Some of the voting sites that closed because of the coronavirus pandemic during the primary have reopened for the general election.