There’s no denying that ice cream weather is in full effect. The summer months are an ideal time to cool off with a scoop. So, why not enjoy one of the best in the country?

Luckily, you don’t have to travel far outside Atlanta to enjoy one.

New York City lifestyle website Gotham has unveiled a list of the 20 best ice cream shops in the country. One from the Big Peach made the list.

“We asked our editors to tell us where to get the best ice cream in their city,” the website said. “Now, we’re giving you the national scoop.”

Of all the spots to grab a scoop of sweet, creamy decadence in Atlanta, Butter & Cream was considered the best.

“Locally crafted in small batches with real cream and fresh ingredients, the brilliant minds at Butter & Cream take classic flavors and reinvent them with unique, modern twists. Offering up to 20 different flavors at any given time, you can expect seasonal rotations of quirky concoctions, including milkshakes, slushies and ice cream floats. Every inclusion, from brownies and cookies to toffee and sauces, are made in-house and guaranteed fresh. Be sure to stop by the Beltline location with your pooch and treat them to a pup cup.”

One of the shop’s concoctions paid tribute to an Atlanta legend. Butter & Cream honored the late U.S. Rep. John Lewis in September. The limited-edition flavor, Good Trouble, was chocolate ice cream mixed with brown sugar cake chunks, coconut pecan crunch and salted caramel swirl.

All proceeds supported Fair Fight, a Georgia-based national voting rights organization.

Butter & Cream has two locations: one in downtown Decatur and another in the historic Old Fourth Ward neighborhood. Neither location is open for dine-in, but they are open for pick-up.

About the Author

Keep Reading

Fireworks will be set off at dusk at Alpharetta’s Independence Day event at Wills Park. The photo shows a view of a previous year’s fireworks from the nearby Walk of Memories at American Legion Post 201. (Courtesy of Alpharetta Convention & Visitors Bureau/Jack Tuszynski)

Credit: Jack Tuszynski/PhotoJack.net

Featured

The city of Brookhaven's mayor and City Council last week decided to remove the colored panes of glass from the dome of Brookhaven's new City Centre after residents objected to the brightness of the colors, seen here Friday, June 27, 2025. (Reed Williams/AJC)

Credit: Reed Williams/AJC