On Saturday, the group that worked out included five men and three women (including each member of the relay team and their crew chief, Theo Schmeeckle), six of them on the backside of 40 years old, and all with serious swims on their résumé, including crossings of 12 to 21 miles from California’s Channel Islands to the mainland.
Aside from Ball, a music teacher and martial arts instructor, and Chung, a dentist, the group included an engineer, a schoolteacher and a lifeguard: McConica.
Muscular and slim at 6 feet 3 inches and 180 pounds, McConica 12 years ago became the oldest lifeguard to graduate from rookie school in Southern California, earning a spot in his class by blitzing his classmates — almost all of whom were collegiate-level swimmers in their 20s — in the grueling, run-swim tryout when he was 52 years old.
With waves thrashing the shoreline on Saturday, the Deep Enders jogged into the surf and swam through the breakers. McConica, the fastest of them all, towed a Gatorade bottle filled with a bit of seawater to create drag, so he would not swim too fast for the others. The group swam shoulder to shoulder because in open water races athletes are not allowed to draft. They carved through the water effortlessly, their green and red lights bobbing above a black sea, against a brightening sky.
The crown jewel in what is known as open water swimming’s Triple Crown is the 21-mile crossing of the English Channel from England to France. The crossing from Catalina, the most famous of Southern California’s offshore islands, to the mainland, is considered the second hardest, though the circumnavigation of Manhattan receives more attention. In such sanctioned, open water swims, the athlete must have at least one kayaker by his side and a support boat with an independent observer on board approved by whichever record-keeping organization manages that particular channel, in this case the Santa Barbara Channel Swimming Association.
The Deep Enders, who are not sponsored, paid a combined $12,000 out of their own pocket to attempt the San Nicolas crossing, and recruited family members to spot them by kayak.
No matter the swim, the rules do not vary much. Swimmers are forbidden to wear wet suits or fins, and they are not to be purposefully touched by their support team. When food or drinks are offered, they must be presented on a tray while the swimmer treads water.
The easiest of the Channel Island swims is the 12-mile crossing from Anacapa to Ventura. All of the Deep Enders have made that crossing. McConica swam it in 4 hours 38 minutes three years ago, beating a record set three weeks earlier by a college swimmer. He also holds the record for the 19-mile Santa Cruz Island crossing, 8:59, set in 2013. But McConica had a swim career long before he was an open water god.
At the University of Southern California in the early 1970s, he won six NCAA gold medals and once beat Mark Spitz by a body length in the opening leg of a 4x200-meter freestyle relay. His team, however, twice finished second to Spitz’s Indiana team and never won a national title. That’s one of two major disappointments that haunt and drive him still. The other is missing a berth on the 1972 Olympic team by a tenth of a second (though he was part of a 1971 world-record relay team).
After college, McConica left the pool and the sport behind. He received an MBA and bought his father out of the family’s car dealership, but in 1981, with his two young daughters getting a bit older, he found himself watching the television sports program “ABC’s Wide World of Sports” and feeling, he said, like a bump on a log who never fully realized his athletic potential. He knew he had to do something. Ten days later, he swam the Catalina Channel.
At the time, he had only recently begun swimming with the Buenaventura Swim Club, and he was still a sprinter who had never trained for distance. He finished the crossing in just over 9 hours and could not lift his arms over his head, he said, for two weeks. A month later, he started training for distance in earnest, and the next year he set the Catalina Channel record when he swam it in 8:27. Five years later, at 37, he swam the English Channel.
In recent years, he has had as much fun training with and helping coach the Deep Enders as he has had accomplishing individual goals. The group’s seminal moment came in 2010 when McConica led a relay of six swimmers, the so-called Deep Six, which included Chung and Ball, on a 202-mile open water course that departed from Ventura and wandered north to Santa Barbara before turning back south to San Diego’s La Jolla Cove.
For four days and nights the six athletes traded off, swimming an hour at a time, to bridge the distance. It was the longest relay of its kind in history. The previous record was 78 miles.
The Deep Six swim was not easy. The Pacific was unseasonably cold that year, with temperatures as low as 54 degrees. Wet suits were not allowed. Besides, McConica considers the desire for warmth a form of weakness, so he would not wear one anyway. Also, there was a stiff current, and the swim stretched a day longer than they had hoped, which meant they ran out of food and energy drinks to sustain them.
“The group was really positive,” Chung said. “We knew that there would be challenges, but we made an agreement that we would get through this together, and nobody wanted to let their teammates down.”
Ball, a former college swimmer who started swimming again in his late 40s after his body weight hit 270 pounds and he received a diagnosis of Type 2 diabetes, remembers one particular bit of McConica wisdom that helped on that swim.
“Get your mind right,” he said. “It’s a simple statement, but profoundly true. We’ve endured some pretty unreal conditions when the water is 50-something degrees and you’re miles from shore and it’s pitch black, but to accomplish these things you need to have the mindset that I will get this done.”
Zach Jirkovsky, 34, said: “He’s like Yoda sometimes. I can hear him in my head.”
The swimmers listen, not just because of McConica’s accomplishments, but because they have often seen him push himself to the point of vomiting, and persevere anyway. In August, he attempted to become the oldest person to swim the Catalina Channel, and it was a miserable swim almost from the start.
Chung was swimming with him that night (takeoff was after 10 p.m.), and so was Tamie Stewart, 42, a teacher, single mother and the newest Deep Ender. Three hours after departing Catalina, McConica hit the wall.
“Then came the diarrhea and the nausea,” he said. “I couldn’t eat, so there were no breaks. When the sun came out and I could finally see, I kept looking and hoping for a great white to come and put me out of my misery.”
No such luck. Instead he turned to either side and saw his teammates swimming alongside him, shoulder to shoulder, and knew he could not let them down.
“Mental strength was absolutely critical,” he said.
He made it, of course.
Beloved by divers, surfers, spear fishermen, hikers and birders, Southern California’s eight Channel Islands run from as far south as Long Beach to Point Conception, north of Santa Barbara. Five of them comprise a national park and all are home to endemic plant and animal life and are sanctuaries by official designation or by nature for marine mammals.
San Nicolas is the farthest from shore and most shrouded in mystery. The rugged 23-square-mile island is featured in a children’s novel, “Island of the Blue Dolphins,” based on the true story of a 19th-century indigenous woman left stranded there for 18 years. According to Jirkovsky and Stewart, the book is commonly taught in Ventura primary schools.
These days the island’s rolling hills, virgin coves and sheer cliffs are the domain of both the U.S. Navy and elephant seals, which are not known for their hospitality and typically grow to 16 feet and over 6,000 pounds.
Aside from those seals, hazards the team might encounter include a recent uptick in shark sightings and attacks. On Saturday morning, Ball showed off the T-shirt he designed and had printed commemorating their attempt. It included an image of a hammerhead.
“Hammerheads are really in right now,” he said. “I mean they are really in. A friend of mine was bit by one two weeks ago.”
But the real obstacle in a channel crossing of this kind tends to be the ocean itself, which can and often does deliver unpredictable swell and currents at any time. On Sunday night, when the group gathered for dinner at a seafood restaurant at the San Pedro marina before they shoved off, they heard news of a swimmer who had begun a first attempt at a crossing from San Nicolas to Santa Barbara Island the day before. He quit after three hours, physically and mentally spent, and violently ill. The swell and current were stiffer than he had anticipated and more than he could bear.
The swimmers understand how capricious the ocean can be. It can deliver spectacular beauty, whether it is midnight phosphorescence, breaching gray whales or playful dolphins at sunrise. But there is often a dose of pain and a stiff challenge to overcome, too.
“The ocean is different every day, and you have to be prepared to be able to deal with whatever it throws at you,” McConica said. “It’s a way different situation out there beyond Catalina, where you aren’t protected by the other Channel Islands. That’s the real open ocean.”