Earlier this week, Moscow Mules were all the rage but not in a good way. Iowa officials released a report stating those copper mugs could be poisonous, but some scientists think otherwise.
The state announced it will be adhering to the FDA code that "prohibits copper from coming into direct contact with foods that have a pH below 6.0."
While a Moscow Mule has a pH below 6.0, Tisha Andrews, assistant professor of chemistry at UMass Amherst, told The Huffington Post that she finds “the press release to be chemophobic fear-mongering.”
Why is that?
Copper changes form when it’s combined with acidic solutions, she said, which means it loses it’s metallic makeup and transforms into copper(II) or copper(I).
“Copper(I) is known to be very toxic,” Andrews explained. “But humans need copper(II) in some small amount in order to survive in their regular biochemical functions. Actually we have enzymes in our body that are part of our regular biological processes that have copper(II) as part of their chemical structure.”
Therefore, the concern should not be the copper mugs, researchers said, but how long the Moscow Mule sits in them.
In order for copper to cause symptoms of poisoning, studies show there has to be a concentration of 30 milligrams of it per liter.
“You have to let the copper mug sit in straight lime juice for a few hours before you can even start to begin to worry about copper poisoning,” Andrews said. “Based on the dissolution rates, it’s just nonsensical.”
That applies even if you nurse your cocktail all night or drink a liter of Moscow Mule from a copper mug. Andrews said you’re in the clear.
Support real journalism. Support local journalism. Subscribe to The Atlanta Journal-Constitution today. See offers.
Your subscription to the Atlanta Journal-Constitution funds in-depth reporting and investigations that keep you informed. Thank you for supporting real journalism.