Georgia teacher fired for reading controversial book appeals state verdict
A Cobb County teacher who was fired for reading a book that challenges gender norms to fifth graders is appealing the Georgia Board of Education’s decision to uphold her termination.
Katie Rinderle filed an appeal last week asking the Cobb County Superior Court to reverse her termination and to expunge her employment and disciplinary records.
She was removed from her Due West Elementary classroom in March 2023 after reading students a book called “My Shadow is Purple” by Scott Stuart. Some parents complained to the school’s principal that they were not informed about the content of the book ahead of time. Rinderle maintained throughout a two-day hearing and afterward that the book was about inclusivity. She was fired in August, and filed an appeal the next month.
Rinderle, another Cobb teacher and the Georgia Association of Educators filed a lawsuit in February accusing the state’s second-largest school district of discrimination. The complaint stated that the teachers fear discipline under Cobb’s policies for “actively and openly supporting their LGBTQ students.”
Rinderle is believed to be the first public school teacher in Georgia to face consequences under state laws passed in 2022 that limit what teachers are allowed to discuss in the classroom. The discrimination lawsuit is the first federal challenge to the Georgia policies, her attorneys said in a news release from the Southern Poverty Law Center last month.
In the most recent appeal, Rinderle and her attorneys maintain what they’ve said since she was fired: The district’s decision to fire her was “arbitrary, capricious, an error of law, lacking sufficient evidence and a gross abuse of discretion.”
The Georgia Board of Education unanimously affirmed the firing in February. In its 21-page review, it found that Cobb’s policies are not “unconstitutionally vague,” as Rinderle and her attorneys alleged, and that her firing was not a “predetermined outcome.”
Controversial books: Here’s what you should know
- Cobb tribunal does not recommend firing of teacher over controversial book
- Cobb school board votes to fire teacher who read controversial book
- Firing of Cobb teacher over book doesn’t end controversy
- OPINION: The divisive concepts law was never meant for this
- Georgia teacher asks state board to reverse firing over controversial book
- Marietta school district to review books for inappropriate material
- Cobb schools searching libraries for 23 books pulled from Marietta High
- From books to religion, Georgia conservatives renew focus on school culture
- Fired Cobb teacher files lawsuit challenging classroom censorship laws
How to follow AJC updates
Journalists from The Atlanta Journal-Constitution are covering this issue with stories and images on all of our platforms, including the AJC app and AJC.com and continuing in our print and ePaper editions.
On social media: Follow updates on X from Cassidy Alexander, @bycassidy. Follow AJC Get Schooled on Facebook.



