Election integrity advocates say the bright, 21.5-inch touchscreens display voters’ choices for people within 30 feet to see.
In its vote Tuesday, the board cited a provision of the Georgia Constitution that requires a secret ballot and state laws that allow for paper ballots when use of voting equipment is “impossible or impracticable.”
Another law mandates that every county use a uniform statewide voting system.
Elections Board Chairman Jesse Evans said the new voting system can’t comply with state and federal requirements for voters to be able to vote in private.
“The Athens-Clarke County Board of Elections is not legally permitted to use an electronic ballot marker that does not permit voting in absolute secrecy so that no person can see or know any other elector’s votes, except when he or she has assisted the elector in voting,” Evans said in a statement.
State election officials didn’t comment on the Athens vote.
The secretary of state’s office has recommended that county election officials protect ballot secrecy by turning touchscreens so they face the wall instead of voters waiting in line.
But repositioning the touchscreens, printers and ballot scanners can be difficult, especially in cramped voting locations.
Georgia has required the same voting system across the state since 2002, when the state converted to electronic voting. Before then, each county decided whether to use hand-marked paper ballots, punch cards or lever machines.
The new voting touchscreens are similar to the old ones, but they’re larger and display text more clearly. They’re partially surrounded by blue privacy screens, which leave the voting touchscreens exposed from some angles.
The Athens election will use hand-marked paper ballots with the same voting process that was tested in Cobb County in November.
Under an order from a federal judge, Cobb tested hand-marked paper ballots as a contingency plan in case the state's touchscreen-and-printer voting system wasn't ready in time for this month's presidential primary.
Athens voters will bubble in their choices for president on a paper ballot, then feed it into the new voting system’s optical scanners, which can read both hand-marked and computer-printed ballots.
Across the state in South Georgia, an election integrity organization recently sued over ballot secrecy.
A Sumter County Superior Court judge last week denied an emergency motion to switch to hand-marked paper ballots.
He ruled that the Coalition for Good Governance hadn’t proven that it would be “impossible or impracticable” for voting machines to be arranged in a way that provides for a secret ballot.