Latest News

Breaking news from the Atlanta Journal-Constitution

The spin room consensus: CNBC lost the debate

By Daniel Malloy, AJC Political Insider

BOULDER, Colo. — The first figure storming into the spin room Wednesday night was Republican National Committee chairman Reince Priebus, who sided with the candidates and the booing crowd in attacking the moderators for the third Republican debate.

Debate moderators Carl Quintanilla, left, Becky Quick, center, and John Harwood appear during the CNBC Republican presidential debate at the University of Colorado, Wednesday, Oct. 28, 2015, in Boulder, Colo. (AP Photo/Mark J. Terrill)

“I’m very disappointed in the moderators, very disappointed with CNBC,” Priebus said.

From Twitter snark to the spin room, CNBC took a beating for questioning that was awkward and fumbling at times, and at others seemed derived from an opposition research book.

Recommended for you

Recommended for you

Recommended for you

Most read

  1. 1 If Justin Fields wants to leave Georgia, then more power to him
  2. 2 Actress, director Penny Marshall dead at 75
  3. 3 Woman pleads guilty to operating large DeKalb prostitution ring

Steve Deace, a spinner for Ted Cruz and Iowa conservative radio host, pointed to moments when a tough question about Ben Carson’s readiness for the Oval Office went too far and made Carson look like a victim, and when the moderators had Donald Trump nailed on whether he called Marco Rubio “Mark Zuckerberg’s senator” but waited a half-hour before revealing the quote Trump denied came from his own website.

Said Deace:

“I thought it was a disastrous night for that entire network, honestly. … I though it was going to be hard to top the conservative anger at the Fox debate. A lot of conservatives, even people that were not supporting Trump, I mean my social media timeline, everything was overloaded with people who thought Megyn Kelly was over the top.

“But this, I think this, I hope that this is rock bottom for our industry. If we can be more unprofessional and more feckless than this, I will be very very disappointed for the human race.”

Former RNC chairman Michael Steele, now an MSNBC commentator, said the questions did not match the promise for the debate to focus on the economy.

“I thought some of the questions were not appropriate for the venue. I’m going to contrast that with how folks started the Democrat debate – solid, straight out of the box policy.

“These questions were personal, they were meant to provoke and poke, and I don’t think that was very helpful. And I think it sort of took the evening into a space it didn’t need to go to. … It’s like wh0 are you working for? Just ask a straight-up question about their jobs plan, the economy as a whole.”

The campaigns themselves were less eager to jump on the moderators. In some cases, the candidates came out looking better, such as a Rubio exchange on his finances. Said Rubio campaign manager Terry Sullivan:

“I’m not going to pick on them. Marco did great tonight. They came after him, obviously, and he got the better of them. …

“[It works for the candidate] only if you can answer the questions in a better fashion and turn it back on them. It’s better if you’re skilled and good at it like Marco. In that case, yeah. If not, you fumble around and you don’t give a good answer, it doesn’t turn in your favor.”

Jeb Bush campaign manager Danny Diaz had a sharp exchange with a CNBC producer during the debate, but he later said it was more about speaking time than bias:

“I just communicated that I thought the amount of time allotted was a little bit less than what we had hoped, but you know what? We had an opportunity to talk in front of the American people, and we’re going to continue to do that.”

Trump at one point during the debate thanked Arkansas Gov. Mike Huckabee for coming to his rescue when Huckabee was asked about Trump’s morals. Facing the press afterward, Trump did not bash the moderators too hard — like he did after the Fox debate:

“Well, when you look at the Hillary debate, that was a soft one. It was all softballs. And our debate was much tougher. I mean I loved it, I had a great time, but it was a much different debate than what the Democrats had.”



About the Author

More from AJC