New York state legislators held a hearing in New York on Tuesday, Oct. 29 as they consider a law that would ban tackle football for youth under the age of 13.
Photo: Bill Wippert/AP
Photo: Bill Wippert/AP

N.Y. lawmakers consider ban on tackle football for children

State Assembly committee hears medical, legal and sports experts speak about possible effects

T.J. Abraham, who is now a doctor, testified before a state Assembly committee hearing in Manhattan about the brain damage he says has destroyed his medical practice and disrupted family life. 

"There were many days in college I remember 'seeing stars,' the sky turning purple or orange, or vomiting due to a severe headache after a head-on collision," said Abraham, 42. "At the time, I thought this was normal and was told by coaches to 'suck it up.’ "

»RELATED: Concussion PSA compares youth football dangers to smoking

Still a 6-foot, 270-pound powerhouse decades after he stopped playing for Duquesne University, Abraham was forced to stop working as a gynecologist last year because of a failing memory — he even forgot how to perform medical procedures he had done thousands of times. He would lose wallets, keys, important documents, and his way on the road while driving home to his wife and two children in Harborcreek, Pennsylvania. 

T.J. Abraham testifies during a New York state assembly hearing Tuesday, Oct. 29 in New York. The 42-year-old doctor testified about the brain damage that forced him to stop his medical practice and urged New York state legislators to pass a law banning tackle football for children under 13.
Photo: Verena Dobnik/AP

"Thank God, no one got hurt or died as a result of my condition," he said. 

Abraham said his doctors blame football, which he played starting in elementary school. 

Why it matters

The proposed ban follows a new study by the Boston University School of Medicine that found children who play tackle football may develop cognitive, behavioral and mood problems, and that the more years young athletes play, the more likely they are to succumb to the degenerative brain disease called chronic traumatic encephalopathy. 

»RELATED: Youth football called 'child abuse'

"Researchers discovered the single factor that best determined whether players would develop CTE was not how many concussions they suffered, but instead the number of years they played tackle football," said Christopher Nowinski, a former Harvard football player who co-founded The Concussion Legacy Foundation, a nonprofit that raises awareness of the dangers of head injuries. 

Attorney Michael Kaplen, who teaches a course on traumatic brain injury at George Washington University, said allowing young children to participate in organized tackle football "is the equivalent of playing Russian roulette." 

"Evidence continues to accumulate that children who engage in tackle football have a greater risk of sustaining a life-altering brain injury," Kaplen told members of the committee chaired by Assemblyman Richard N. Gottfried. 

What’s being done

Scott Hallenbeck, the executive director of USA Football, countered that his national governing body has made the sport safer than ever with protective measures. 

Since 2012, he said, more than 700,000 youth and high school coaches have been certified for strict safety standards such as limiting the number of practices per week and how many minutes are allotted to full contact. In addition, improved helmets are being used to reduce the impact of collisions and children are coached to avoid head-first tackling in favor of shoulder-first moves. 

»RELATED: Is it really time for government to tackle youth football?

"Parents do not want their government telling them when their kids can play football," Hallenbeck said. "Instead, they want to make informed decisions for themselves; parents need information and options in order to determine what is best for their child."

What’s next

Lawmakers in Albany will consider the ban when they return to work in January. 

Support real journalism. Support local journalism. Subscribe to The Atlanta Journal-Constitution today. See offers.

Your subscription to the Atlanta Journal-Constitution funds in-depth reporting and investigations that keep you informed. Thank you for supporting real journalism.