If you’re among those astonished by the cheers and applause of folks elated at the suggestion that NFL players who take a knee during the national anthem be fired, if you could never quite understand why they saw that as somehow unpatriotic, let’s talk about that.
With the Fourth of July this week, the time just seems right.
The argument has been made over and over that the protests were never about patriotism but rather systemic racial inequality in our criminal justice system, starting with how communities of color are policed.
Those cheering, however, either didn’t understand that or didn’t care.
Although most Americans view themselves as patriotic, few agree on what that looks like. Some say it’s being proud of the men and women who serve in our military and the charitable nature of Americans. Some point to living in a strong democracy and our nation being a beacon of hope to people worldwide. And some say it’s our “can do” spirit, faith in capitalism and President Donald Trump.
Hence, we don’t seem to have much common ground on what makes one patriotic, said Frank Orlando, the director of the Saint Leo University Polling Institute and author of the study.
Overall, according to the poll, 85.5 percent of Americans report being patriotic, compared to 10 percent who consider themselves less patriotic or not at all patriotic.
The most frequently stated reason for that: Trump, according to 62.4 percent.
Other reasons cited included the idea that the nation is going in the wrong direction (45.5 percent); the nation is too divided (45.5 percent); having little or no faith in democracy today (40.6 percent); just not proud of the country (40.6 percent); don’t agree with U.S. foreign policy (29.7 percent); nation is becoming too conservative (17.8 percent); and the nation is becoming too liberal (8.9 percent).
Orlando suspects, too, that those bedrock American institutions like, for example, organized religion that once served as unifying forces have been on the decline at least since the 1970s.
“Without things we hold in common across party lines, there is less tethering us to the idea that we are more alike than different,” he said. “We can think of those we disagree with politically as the other, which dehumanizes them and leads to even more polarization.”
So what is patriotism?
Orlando defines it this way: having an emotional connection to the country and manifesting that connection by acting as a good citizen.
Mary A. Evins, an associate professor of history and director of the American Democracy Project for Civic Learning at Middle Tennessee State University, said that how we express patriotism is a manifestation of our core American values.
“The divide about patriotism clearly parallels the divide we have throughout the entire country today in terms of our thinking,” she said. “Rule-bound, hidebound, fear-based, intractable, jingoistic authoritarianism is peaking in this country.”
The problem is authoritarianism apparently seeks to “own” patriotism.
“The utter irony, however, is that the revolutionary spirit that brought our nation into being in 1776 — the Declaration of Independence against such authority — is what July Fourth celebrates and honors,” Evins said.
She said that the Founding Fathers sought redress from tyranny and restraints. An “originalist” could argue that true patriotism is the very act of defying norms at personal risk in order to support and uphold the highest principles of America’s truest, finest values: welcome for the poor and needy, equality, diversity, free speech, liberty of conscience, to name just a few.
“Thomas Jefferson understood that true patriots will continually defy tyranny,” she said. “In a parallel universe, intriguingly, in a ‘Christian nation’ as the right sees it, Christ similarly threw the Pharisees out of the temple for their rigid adherence to hard rules that did not carry the spirit of love he advocated.”
I mentioned the NFL protests.
The Saint Leo poll shows that most of us support the NFL’s new policy of fining teams when their players on the field kneel or fail to show respect for the U.S. flag during the playing of the national anthem.
Specifically, 77.5 percent who say they are conservative support the new rule while 51.5 percent who say they are moderate offer support, and 39.7 percent who identify as liberal say they support the new NFL policy. Race and party affiliation do come into play in the poll results, but not to a great degree.
“It’s remarkable how consistently popular the decision by NFL owners is,” said Orlando, the Saint Leo political scientist. “Majorities of basically every demographic and political group approve of the rule. Across age, education levels and income, there is consistent support. Blacks, liberals and Democrats disapprove on the whole, but around 40 percent of those groups agree with the policy. This isn’t exactly a slam-dunk.”
As for Evins, she said that this Fourth of July, she and her family celebrated the American spirit of refreshing our commitment to enlightenment thinking and our national heritage built by the thinkers who decried oppression to establish a nation of justice, personal voice, and human dignity.
“There is nothing more patriotic than Americans willing to stand up, march, sit in, or kneel down for what they believe,” she said. “Is kneeling not a position of supplication, humbly asking for wrongs to be righted?”
Support real journalism. Support local journalism. Subscribe to The Atlanta Journal-Constitution today. See offers.
Your subscription to the Atlanta Journal-Constitution funds in-depth reporting and investigations that keep you informed. Thank you for supporting real journalism.