Saving Southern Recipes: Use 3 pantry ingredients to make Angel Berry Pie

In the Southern Kitchen series Saving Southern Recipes, Associate Editor Kate Williams explores the deep heritage of Southern cooking through the lens of passed-down family recipes.

If I was to tell you that you could make a towering, beautiful pie without pulling out sticks of butter and fiddling with dough, would you believe me? If I was to tell you that you could make said pie with little more than eggs, cream and sugar, would you scoff? Suspend your disbelief, at least for a moment, and hear me out. There is such a pie, and it goes by various names that all invoke heavenly bodies to hint at its lighter-than-air texture and (dare I say?) miraculous technique.

Called angel pie, heavenly pie or the admitedly less-seductive upside-down meringue pie, this dessert is simply a meringue base, filled with cream, fruit, curds and (occasionally) syrups. When it inevitably falls apart into a delicous jumble, it is almost an Eton Mess, or Lanton Mess, depending on what fruit is on top. What I've decided to call an angel pie is a secret weapon of bakers across the country, but especially in the South, a pantry-ingredient pie that looks like a celebration dessert and is just as good for breakfast as it is before your evening nightcap.

Recipes for meringues have been around since at least 1691, and cooks have likely been utilizing the aerating magic of whipped egg whites for longer. However, given the intensity of the beating needed to bring egg whites into a stable foam, meringues and meringue-like dishes were historically eaten by those with the resources to employ or enslave a cook to do all of that work. It wasn't until the advent of the mechanical egg beater around the turn of the 20th century that meringues really took off in home cooking. 

The popularization of pavolovas, named to the ballerina Anna Pavolova, made meringue a full-on trend, the avocado toast of the 1920s, if you will. This angel berry pie is similar to that dish, yet by using a pie dish for meringue support, is far, far more forgiving. You needn't worry that your meringue is cooked perfectly to a crisp or that you billow its sides in the most beautiful manner. You'll be covering the whole thing in whipped cream anyway.

I've eaten this style of pie once before, but it was filled with cream-lightened lemon curd and topped with whipped cream. The strawberry-filled version I made this week, however, came from reader Elizabeth Lide's grandmother Emma. Lide told me that it is one of her favorites, and it's easy to see why.

The meringue crust is just sweet enough to hold its form, with a hint of vanilla for depth. There's a soaring mound of straight-up whipped cream — no sugar — on top, followed by sliced strawberries or whatever fruit you'd like. Get a bite with all three components and it all balances out into a lighter, airier version of strawberry shortcake.

As written, Emma's recipe assumes a lot. You'd need to know already the proper texture for the meringue and how stiff to whip the cream to hold it all together. You'll need to guess at how to slice the berries, and how much of them to use. But beyond the meringue, these are fairly inconsequential issues. You can slip and slop your way to a great pie without much know-how. The only thing you do need — at least to make it easy — is an electric mixer. Yes, you can beat the egg whites and the cream by hand, but why would you?