A college football team in town is having a season in which seemingly everything is going right. A pro football team in town is having a season in which seemingly everything lately is going wrong
Georgia is 9-0 and ranked No. 1. The Falcons are 4-4 and spiraling toward irrelevancy.
They play in different leagues, on different levels, with players from different age and income brackets. But their contrasting stories illustrate the fragile nature of a football season, where factors stretch well beyond talent, injuries and easy, lazy narratives like, “The coach stinks.”
Jake Fromm, a freshman, morphs into Roger Staubach. Julio Jones, a four-time Pro Bowler, stands in the end zone and drops a ball that descends from the heavens.
Some things you just don’t plan for.
“Mental things,” Dan Reeves said.
The former Falcons coach played or coached for nine teams that went to Super Bowls. He also played or coached for more than a few teams that didn’t. He’s not surprised the Falcons took a step back this season, but not just because they were forced to hire a new offensive coordinator, Steve Sarkisian, to replace Kyle Shanahan.
“When you’re coming off a Super Bowl, every other team is saying every week, ‘If we can beat them, we’re good enough to go to the Super Bowl,’” Reeves said Tuesday. “You become everybody’s biggest game. Not only that, but a lot of times things change in the offseason program. When you’re striving to make it to the Super Bowl, everybody is working hard to get there. But when you make it, sometimes it’s hard to convince players to give that same effort again. They just assume they’re going back to the Super Bowl, but it doesn’t happen that way.”
The decline of the Falcons’ offense has received the most attention, and justifiably so. They scored 540 points last season. They’re on a pace for 340 this season – a staggering 200-point drop.
It’s logical to believe Sarkisian’s play-calling is a factor. But it’s overly simplistic to think the problems start and end there. Offensive-line play has not been great. Matt Ryan’s accuracy has dropped off. Receivers have officially dropped 16 passes -- which ranks as the third most in the NFL behind San Francisco (21) and Oakland (18).
The Falcons lack it. This Georgia team has it. The Bulldogs have handled the glare of high expectations far better than their NFL counterparts.
Georgia coach Kirby Smart said the leadership of this year’s team is superior to that of a year ago. Everything has rolled off that.
“The season kind of produces the leaders, and you learn a little more about the team,” he said. “I wouldn’t say (chemistry is) fragile. I would just say it changes from year to year, and the chemistry is certainly much different this year than last year. A lot of that has to do with the senior leadership."
This season could’ve swung in the wrong direction early. Georgia lost starting quarterback Jacob Eason to a knee injury in the season opener. The next week was the Notre Dame game. Fromm understandably had some shaky moments, including an interception and a fumble. But he made a couple of key throws, wide receiver Terry Godwin made a remarkable, one-handed touchdown grab in the end zone and the Bulldogs pulled out a 20-19 win on a late field goal.
Imagine if Georgia had lost that game. Would the players’ confidence level going into SEC play be the same?
Senior defensive back Aaron Davis said he didn’t know how to gauge the significance of the Notre Dame win because he wasn’t sure about the Fighting Irish’s strength at that point.
“I’m still curious to see where we go,” he said.
But he added, “A lot of guys came back for another year because they felt we had something special together. You don’t have a lot of new pieces. But you never know how those (new) pieces will interact with each other when variables change.”
Georgia has teased us before. The 2008 team was a preseason No. 1. The offense included Matthew Stafford, Knowshon Moreno, Mohamed Massaquoi and a freshman named A.J. Green. But clearly something was missing. The Dogs were body-slammed at home by Alabama, then run over by Florida. The regular season ended with a home loss to Georgia Tech.
Kaboom. The preseason No. 1 finished a pre-bowl No. 17.
When the Dogs have played inferior opponents this season, they've stomped them. That hasn't been a regular occurrence in Athens.
“Our kids have taken ownership,” Smart said.
Good fortune doesn’t hurt either. The Falcons had a great season in 1998, but they don’t upset Minnesota in overtime in the NFC Championship game and make it to the Super Bowl if Vikings kicker Gary Andersen doesn’t miss a potential clinching 39-yard field goal in regulation.
“There was a guy who hadn’t missed a field goal all year, but he missed one in our game.” Reeves said. “So you know somebody up there is looking out for you.”
Things fell in place for the Falcons that season. Not this year. But Georgia has been a different story.
Subscribe to the, “We Never Played The Game” podcast with the AJC's Jeff Schultz and WSB’s Zach Klein on iTunes or on the new AJC sports podcasts page.
- Overreaction Monday: Fromm has golden arm, Falcons need anger
- Falcons remain stuck in mediocrity -- this might be who they are
- Dan Quinn confident 'bear isn't loose' and Falcons are trending up
- Weekend Predictions: Bulldogs avoid gravity storm, but spread is too fat
- It's Georgia, Alabama on top, and college playoff could be an SEC party
- Vince Dooley sees another championship in Georgia's future
- Vince Dooley podcast (audio): UGA has good chance to win title
- Falcons get drilled, problems far worse than Super Bowl hangover
- Steve Sarkisian knows Falcons' offense needs better production
- Weekend Predictions: Because it makes no sense, Falcons beat Pats
- Evander Holyfield to be honored with statue in Atlanta
- Budenholzer on changes: 'Coaching is most important thing I've done'
- Falcons dispute 'choker' label but late-game fizzles are a concern
- Overreaction Monday: Book therapy for 'Brotherhood,' parade for Dogs
- Georgia Tech, Johnson let another one slip away in loss to Miami, Richt
- North Carolina skates and NCAA's uselessness is confirmed (again)
- Weekend Predictions: Parlay: NCAA over Auburn, Johnson over Richt
- If Braves serious about cleaning up mess, they'll make changes at top
- Overreaction Monday: Dogs No. 4 -- they're in playoffs! (Not really)
- It's clear: Georgia (6-0) is really good and quarterback situation is settled
- Weekend Predictions: Georgia (Carrie) gets homecoming revenge
- Braves keep Snitker, because they don't need another inferno now
- John Coppolella never grew into job and damaged Braves need leadership
- John Coppolella resigns and Braves look like they're in disarray
- Overreaction Monday: Next two weeks will be telling for Georgia QBs
- Georgia has another lopsided win, and this team looks like real deal
- Arthur Blank, Falcons to have open discussion on race, protests
Support real journalism. Support local journalism. Subscribe to The Atlanta Journal-Constitution today. See offers.
Your subscription to the Atlanta Journal-Constitution funds in-depth reporting and investigations that keep you informed. Thank you for supporting real journalism.