Being ghosted while dating? Don’t try a resurrection

I have a former male client who has what I’ll call “a ghosting pattern.” He will text someone after a date that he thinks went well to ask her out again. (So far, so good!) She doesn’t answer. (Annoying.) He writes to her again. She doesn’t answer again. He writes again (maybe this time on Facebook and LinkedIn, also) … you get it.

While most of us can plainly see she’s not interested, some people just can’t (or don’t want to) see it. No response means “maybe” to them. But no response actually means no.

For the woman in this scenario, I can’t encourage her strongly enough to use a tactful yet firm form of this: “I’m no longer interested, but I wish you all the best,” or “Thanks for a nice time, but unfortunately, I just didn’t feel the connection I’m looking for. Best of luck.” But she’s not my client; he is.

I have tried (unsuccessfully) to get this client to stop sending messages after a nonresponse or two. I have also suggested he send her a “closure text,” saying something like, “Hey (person’s name who ghosted), I had really enjoyed our time together and was hoping to do it again, so I’m disappointed I didn’t hear back from you. Just wanted to close the loop. Wish you the best.”

I told him to picture this: She got the message and made a deliberate choice not to reply. She looked at her phone, saw the text and decided, “No, I don’t want to reply.” Then she probably blocked you because now you’re being creepy with all the texts.

But it still wasn’t getting through. He thought he still had a chance with her since she never directly said “no.” And he didn’t want to send my closure text idea because he thought it would close the door. I tried to explain the door was already closed.

Below is the advice I gave to the client to try to come at things from a bit of a different angle:

I’ve never disagreed with you that the best way to reject someone is to actually reject someone. None of this no-response business. For that part, I am 100% in agreement with you.

However, not everyone is capable or comfortable (they lack courage, communication skills, whatever you want to call it) to do that. Do I tell all of my clients to send a kind rejection text in order to provide closure? Yes, I do. But if someone doesn’t give you the courtesy of doing that, you have to take her nonresponse as a proxy for rejection. While it doesn’t give you the closure you need, it’s still a “no.”

I want you to try going through this thought process instead:

Why would you ever want to be with someone who can’t express herself? Someone who can’t write a simple “I’m not interested” to you? Who can’t be both confident and courteous enough to say “stop writing to me”? They don’t want to “hurt your feelings.” Baloney. They are too uncomfortable with confrontation to do it. Is that someone you’d ever want to be with?

So, I’m asking you to stop writing to women who don’t get back to you. They’ve made it abundantly clear they don’t want to communicate. The only communication I’d like you to use after a nonresponse is a “closure” type of message from you to them (as I mentioned above).

And that will have to be the same for you as her saying it outright. I’ve used messages like that before with men who have ghosted me (and there have been plenty — you’re not unique in that way). It’s just something that allows me (and, in this case, you) to be the bigger person and have the last word, essentially saying, I’m better than being ignored. Please notice the difference between this note and the ones you’re sending. In yours, you keep trying for something you know is off the table. In this one, you’re confident and expressive and know how to end something. She has already closed the door. You just need to lock it. And deadbolt it. And throw away the key.

Rather than defending your patterns of behavior that are clearly not working, or sharing with me why you do what you do, it’s time to change that pattern, and this is the perfect opportunity to do it.

Yes, ghosting is bad. And I teach all of my clients not to do it. But to not accept someone’s continued silence as anything other than rejection is also bad in its own way. We need to accept that not everyone lives up to the communication standards we may want and move on.

Erika Ettin is the founder of A Little Nudge, where she helps others navigate the often intimidating world of online dating.