“They’re telling us regular people and their opinions aren’t as important as public officials or former public officials,” said William Perry, founder of Georgia Ethics Watchdogs. “Just blanketly giving more time to people because they served in office is a slap in the face to the citizens of Atlanta.”
Vincent Fort, the former state senator who has been an outspoken critic of the council, including during public comment periods, called the restrictions counterproductive.
“Public comment of any variety is part of the job, and they ought to consider it as such,” he said. “These are not people who respect the First Amendment.”
In an era when most local governments stream their meetings on the internet and social media gives average citizens the ability to have their own megaphone, many still view going directly before decision-makers to sound off as a fundamental right of self government.
In a city council chambers, one can be sure that the people in charge of policy hear any concerns.
Dexter Chambers, an Atlanta spokesman, said public comment lasted for nine hours at one November City Council meeting as people lined up to share their thoughts on the controversial deal to finance development of the Gulch.
There’s no state law controlling how local governments conduct their public comment periods, or even whether they have them at all. Indeed, some local jurisdictions don’t have official policies, or have recently enacted them for the first time.
Perry said he’d like to see a state law requiring public bodies to have a comment period.
In Buford, the chairman the local commission has invited public comment at the end of meetings for more than 20 years, city manager Bryan Kerlin said, but there's no official, published policy about letting people speak.
Before Avondale Estates established a comment policy in July, it was “just a free-for-all,” city clerk Gina Hill said, with people speaking multiple times on the same item if they wanted to make sure their opinion registered.
“I think a lot of it depends on your mayor, or whoever runs the meeting,” Hill said. “They basically call the shots, and I think that’s how it should be.”
A number of local governments don’t limit the amount of time for public comment, but they have other peculiarities.
In Roswell, residents can respond to any item on the regular agenda. But if they have thoughts on something that isn’t explicitly on the agenda, they can’t address it until the fifth Monday of the month, when the city has what it calls an “open forum” meeting, for people to speak on anything that interests them.
That was the issue for a resident who was removed in August at a regular City Council meeting. He and many others were upset with Roswell's plans to approve a massive tennis center, but when he tried to outline his position it ran afoul of the rules because the tennis center wasn't on the agenda.
“I would very much appreciate it if you would learn how to behave yourselves in these chambers,” Mayor Lori Henry told the gathered crowd, who clapped for the man as he was escorted away from the podium.
In many jurisdictions, the council or commission allows three minutes per resident, but in Riverdale that time can be reduced when there are lot of people who want to talk. With only 15 minutes allotted for public comment in the city, a large crowd could severely limit the time for residents to speak.
In Cobb County, if you’re a political candidate or a county employee, you can’t speak at all.
And while plenty of jurisdictions don’t require advance sign-ups to speak, people in Sandy Springs, Fairburn, East Point and elsewhere must sign up to speak before the meeting starts, or they won’t be permitted to address their local elected officials.
David Hudson, an attorney for the Georgia Press Association, said local governments are allowed to set time limits, require advance sign-ups or enforce standards limiting disruptive or vulgar comments. But he cautioned that to not allow comment at all would be a mistake.
“While there is no requirement to allow public comment, it would seem politically unwise for a governing body not to allow it and thus be subject to criticism that it is closed minded to the views of the citizenry,” he said.
Hudson added that allowing public comment “is just a matter of representative government and whether the elected members choose to be known as closed to citizen comments and questions.”
Perry said people often have to take time off from work, find a babysitter or make other sacrifices to go to a government meeting. When they take the time, he said, they should be rewarded by being heard.
“We definitely want to encourage people to participate in their government,” he said. “Rules like Atlanta’s and others’ discourage participation. When you’re limiting people’s ability to speak, you’re telling them they’re not important.”
Here’s a quick look at the rules for five metro Atlanta county governments:
: Public comment is limited to 30 minutes at the start of the meeting, and people are limited to three minutes apiece. If they want to talk, they must sign up before 7 p.m.
: There are two comment periods, one at the beginning of the meeting and one at the end, and each lasting 30 minutes. People are limited to five minutes for their comments, and salaried county employees and political candidates can't speak at all. People must sign up to speak, but are allowed to do so until all the slots are full.
: Public comment is limited to 30 minutes at the start of the meeting, and people are limited to three minutes apiece. If they want to talk, they have to submit a speaker card; DeKalb County residents will have first priority if there are more speakers than there is time.
: Public comment is limited to 30 minutes at the start of the meeting, and people are limited to two minutes apiece. People must submit speaker cards to talk, and they will no longer be accepted once the meeting has begun.
: Public comment takes place at the end of the meeting, and there is no limit to how long it can go. People are not required to sign up in advance, and are able to talk for between three and five minutes apiece.
To see the public comment rules and requirements for cities throughout those counties, go to ajc.com/publicmeetings.