Crime scene photos from the Atlanta Police Department show a brick that landed in Elvin “E.R.” Mitchell Jr.’s home in southwest Atlanta in September 2015. Mitchell is a key figure in a federal criminal probe of city of Atlanta contracting.

Charges dropped in case of alleged threats to Atlanta bribery figure

State charges against the man accused of trying to intimidate a key witness in the Atlanta City Hall bribery scandal have been dropped because the U.S. Attorney’s Office won’t turn over evidence against him.

Fulton County District Attorney Paul Howard’s office on Thursday dropped charges against Shandarrick Barnes, who was accused of throwing a brick through the home window of Atlanta contractor Elvin “E.R.” Mitchell Jr., and planting dead rats around his property.


The man may have violated his parole when he threatened Atlanta City Contractor E.R. Mitchell, who previously pleaded guilty to bribery.

Mitchell in January pled guilty of federal charges of conspiracy to commit bribery and launder money in the scandal that has shocked City Hall and tainted the final year of Mayor Kasim Reed’s tenure. Mitchell has agreed to cooperate with the ongoing federal investigation and testify in future court proceedings as part of his plea.

Howard told The Atlanta Journal-Constitution in a statement on Friday that his office can’t proceed with the case because “we will not have access to critical evidence collected by the FBI needed to prosecute Barnes” on the state charges.

Barnes was arrested in November and charged with felony counts of making terroristic threats and criminal damage to property in the second degree. The 2015 incident included a brick throw through Mitchell’s window with the words “Shut Up” and “ER Keep Your Mouth Shut” written on it.

Shandarrick Barnes
Photo: The Atlanta Journal-Constitution

Bob Page, a spokesman for the U.S. Attorney’s Office in Atlanta, declined to comment or answer any of the AJC’s questions on Friday.

Ted Salter, Barnes’ attorney in the state case, said it is unusual for U.S. Attorney’s Office to not share evidence with local prosecutors. He said no federal agents have contacted him about Barnes, who is still incarcerated in for a parole violation stemming from the state charges. Barnes has not been charged in the federal investigation.

Salter said he has petitioned the Georgia Board of Pardons and Parole for Barnes’ release since the charges have been dropped, and is awaiting a response.

Earlier this month, Salter asked the court to suppress evidence in the case, including a purported taped confession. During that hearing and in exhibits attached to a court filing, Salter said that prosecutors have admitted “a significant portion of its file is missing” and that the confession may have been lost.

“They‘re talking about a recording,” Salter said in a Friday interview with the AJC. “First they said it’s been lost, then they turn around and say it’s part of the federal investigation and they’re not going to give it to the DA’s office.

“That leaves the state with no evidence.”

Now Salter said he is working to get Barnes released from prison.

Barnes’ parole for a prior conviction was revoked and he is currently incarcerated in Jackson. Salter speculated that federal agents may want Barnes to remain in prison as a way to gain his cooperation.

Salter said he has not been contacted by anyone at the FBI or the U.S. Attorney’s Office.

“There is no justification for him remaining in prison” now that the state charges have been dropped, Salter said. “It doesn’t make sense to me why the feds are so interested in my client, because it’s my belief that his testimony is not going to help their star witness, E.R. Mitchell, at all.”

Elvin “E.R.” Mitchell Jr., pleaded guilty to conspiracy to commit bribery and launder money in January. He has admitted to paying more than $1 million for city contracts. A brick was thrown through Mitchell’s window with the words “Shut Up” and “ER Keep Your Mouth Shut” scrawled on it.
Photo: The Atlanta Journal-Constitution

The bribery case involving Mitchell is a federal matter, but the alleged act of vandalism was brought in Fulton County Superior Court. Mitchell told police officers at the time of the brick incident he was working with federal authorities on a case.

Barnes once worked for a former executive at one of Mitchell’s companies. That executive, Mitzi Bickers, is a reverend and political consultant who played a key role in Mayor Kasim Reed’s 2009 election and served in Reed’s administration from 2010 to 2013.

Federal prosecutors have subpoenaed records related to her from the city of Atlanta and Clayton County, where she now works as a chaplain for Clayton Sheriff Victor Hill.

Police records from Barnes’ arrest said he confessed to the brick incident and that the confession was recorded by the FBI. As part of his attempt to suppress evidence, Salter included emails he sent to Fulton prosecutors seeking the purported confession and other evidence, including victim statements, cellphone records and recorded conversations between Barnes and Mitchell.

But Salter said he never received the purported confession tape.

Support real journalism. Support local journalism. Subscribe to The Atlanta Journal-Constitution today. See offers.

Your subscription to the Atlanta Journal-Constitution funds in-depth reporting and investigations that keep you informed. Thank you for supporting real journalism.