After a backlash from users and health experts, Google Maps decided to remove its recent experimental iOS feature that told users how many calories they would burn on a specific walk — and how many "mini cupcakes" that number would add up to.
The experimental feature was available on iOS devices for a short time, with some users noticing the component for the first time this week.
Yo, a 59 minute walk to cross off two mini cupcakes? Idk about that google maps pic.twitter.com/gykCfbEPbz
— Alex Kantrowitz (@Kantrowitz) October 17, 2017
Google Maps now includes calorie estimates & I really don't need this kind of judgment right now pic.twitter.com/f9y3fW71ld
— Catherine Bond (@DrKateBond) October 13, 2017
According to TechCrunch, Google pulled the feature Monday night, a decision "based on strong user feedback."
Several users criticized the company for triggering painful experiences for people who have or have had an eating disorder.
👻Nuclear Summer🕸 (@sweetbabyruski) October 14, 2017Why does @googlemaps have a “Calorie Tracker” built into directions I take now? Could be triggering for ppl with past ED.At least have ‘off’ pic.twitter.com/aNEHk346jg
—
👻🎃 (@alifwst) October 17, 2017hey guys, have you seen the cool new google maps tool? just go under "walking directions" and hit "trigger a latent eating disorder" https://t.co/RPjPRV9WqR
— Ali S. Pumpkins
More than 30 million people in the U.S. have an eating disorder, according to the National Association of Anorexia Nervosa and Associated Disorders, Inc.
Stephanie Zerwas, clinical director of the Center of Excellence for Eating Disorders at the University of North Carolina, told the New York Times that while the feature was meant to encourage walking, those with eating disorders would "fixate on the number," a mindset counselors try to minimize.
“We’ve gotten into this habit of thinking about our bodies and the foods we take in and how much activity we do as this mathematical equation, and it’s really not,” she said. “The more we have technology that promotes that view, the more people who may develop eating disorders might be triggered into that pathway.”
Another expert, Claire Mysko, chief executive of the National Eating Disorders Association, told the Times that for some, calorie counting isn't much of an issue.
» RELATED: Obesity linked to 11 types of cancer as overweight population grows, study says
“But for people who are hyper-focused on numbers, that can feel very oppressive to see calorie counts everywhere when you’re trying to shift your relationship with food.”
Instead, Mysko suggested Google could promote exercise “in terms of strength and how it makes you feel.”
More from experts at NYTimes.com.
Other iOS users also said the feature reinforced an unhealthy relationship with food and noted previous research has shown exercise isn't the best way to lose weight in the first place.
Anyone else feel like the google maps mini cupcake feature reinforces the idea that all exercise must be atonement for the sin of eating?
— Megan Westgate (@sosaysm) October 16, 2017
Not to mention the fact that all the latest studies show exercise does not cause weight loss.
— Maybe: Lindsay (@lindsayism) October 17, 2017
😿 pls do better.— Sophie Chou (@mpetitchou) October 17, 2017Calories wildly unreliable unit for weight loss/health. Also triggering af... no option to turn off = worst nightmare.
» RELATED: Why exercise isn’t working for you (and what to do about it)
And some suggested the ability to turn the feature off could have eased the backlash.
the mini cupcake update thing on google maps is really triggering ... especially because you can't turn it off T_T
— nika (@vernonchoi) October 17, 2017
The eating disorder concern I totally get.The rest seems suspect, but why no toggle on/off feature? Problem solved.https://t.co/jPVZTHr0SA
— Ryan Van Loan (@RyanVanLoan) October 17, 2017
» RELATED: 12 weight-loss secrets from Atlantans who shed 100-plus pounds
Still, not everyone agreed with the criticsm. Several users lauded the company’s feature, and said Google Maps was simply promoting a healthy lifestyle.
Just noticed that @google is now showing calories you could burn if you walk instead of driving.. #motivation #digitalhealth pic.twitter.com/KYU5BysbAk
— Eugene Borukhovich (@HealthEugene) October 15, 2017
Cool: @GoogleMaps starting to show calories with walking route. That should help some make a healthy decision. Wonder if @Google can also suggest more rigorous alternate routes (esp for those who hate gyms)? #digitalhealth #healthtech #mhealth #fitness https://t.co/jmDbZ5nLJ0
— Hayman Buwan (@realHayman) October 15, 2017
» RELATED: 9 things no one tells you about weight-loss surgery
What do you think?
About the Author