We were told two other teams, the Chicago Cubs and Cincinnati Reds, could dispute the Braves’ claim. A Cubs official in their media relations office told us he used to work for the Reds and that they’re the oldest franchise. He suggested we call the Reds Hall of Fame.
Many believe the Reds are baseball’s first franchise and it appears that they are. In 1869, a former cricket player named Harry Wright organized a band of nine players that barnstormed the country playing a new game we now call baseball. The players dressed in white knickerbockers and wore flashy red hosiery.
They were really good, or their opponents were really bad. The team, which became known as the Cincinnati Red Stockings, was 57-0. Wright played center field, managed the team and likely didn’t take himself out of many games. He eventually was enshrined into the Baseball Hall of Fame.
The Red Stockings didn’t play in 1871, but four of their players relocated to Boston that year and played in the National Association, winning the pennant from 1872 through 1875, according to Baseball Hall of Fame Library research director Tim Wiles.
In 1876, a new league formed called the National League. The Boston Red Stockings, or the Red Caps, as some called them, were part of the eight-team league. Wright was on the team. The team, the Braves say, eventually became known as the Beaneaters to connect with their Boston fan base and to avoid any confusion with the Cincinnati Reds. The Cincinnati team was expelled from the league in 1880 for, among other things, serving beer during their games.
Meanwhile, the Beaneaters became a force in the National League, signing Mike “King” Kelly, the Babe Ruth of his day, for what was then a stunning $10,000. That salary, accounting for inflation, is about $250,000 today. In 1912, the Beaneaters changed their name to the Boston Braves. The franchise stayed in Beantown for another 40 years before moving to Milwaukee in 1953. The Braves then moved to Atlanta in 1966.
But let’s go back to the Cubs for a second. The franchise’s origins began in 1871 as the Chicago White Stockings. Wiles noted that the team didn’t play in 1872 and 1873 because of the great fire of 1871, which killed about 300 people. One third of the city’s 300,000 residents lost their homes in the blaze, according to the Encyclopedia of Chicago.
The two years the Cubs lost to the fire gives the Braves the advantage to the claim of the oldest continuous franchise, says Wiles.
“[The fire] makes Boston a strong historical organization,” Wiles, a Cubs fan, conceded.
The Boston Red Stockings were one of three teams to play all five seasons in the National Association, according to Baseball-Reference.com, a website that’s used by many baseball writers. The others were the New York Mutuals and the Philadelphia Athletics.
The Mutuals did not continue after 1876, according to the website. The Athletics stopped playing after 1876, began again a couple of other times and restarted for good in 1901, currently playing in Oakland.
The matter gets confusing when you examine Baseball-Reference.com’s list of when each of today’s 30 teams began play. It lists the first year for the Braves and Cubs as 1876. Sean Forman, president of Sports Reference LLC, the parent company of Baseball-Reference.com, said he does agree that the Braves franchise began in 1871.
“It’s pretty clear that they were a franchise,” Forman said.
MLB, Forman said, doesn’t officially recognize the National Association.
Why? “I’m not sure,” Forman said.
Wiles said he considers the National Association a professional sports league because the players were paid and the teams were organized.
Bob Epling, a sports historian based in Cherokee County, also sides with the Braves, for many of the same reasons that Wiles stated.
Epling doesn’t believe there’s another team in the three other major sports leagues in America that can make a claim. Football, he said, was semi-professional until the 1920s. The team now known as the Arizona Cardinals is believed to be the first pro football team. It began in Chicago in 1898 as the Morgan Athletic Club.
Pro basketball first began in Trenton, N.J., in 1896, but the oldest continuously running teams in that sport didn’t get their start until the 1940s. The Harlem Globetrotters, if you’re curious, started in 1923.
The National Hockey League began in 1917.
“I might rate [the Braves’ claim] pretty high on the Truth-o-Meter,” said Epling, an associate professor of physical education and sport studies at Reinhardt University in Waleska.
The Cincinnati Red Stockings, which many people view as a predecessor of the Reds, are apparently baseball’s first professional sports franchise. But that is not what the Braves claim. Regarding their claim to the title of “oldest continuous sports franchise in America,” it does appear that the team’s origins began with the Boston Red Stockings, who then joined what became the National League of Major League Baseball. The key word here is “continuous.” We believe the Braves slid home safely on this one and rate their claim as True.
Check our sources
Atlanta Braves website, https://www.mlb.com/braves/history/story-of-the-braves
Baseball Hall of Fame profile of Harry Wright, https://baseballhall.org/hall-of-famers/wright-harry
Baseball-Reference.com, “Complete Baseball Team and Baseball Team Encyclopedia,” http://www.baseball-reference.com/teams/
National Football League, “Chronology of professional football,” https://static.nfl.com/static/content/public/image/history/pdfs/History/2013/353-372-Chronology.pdf
Telephone interview & e-mail from Reinhardt University professor Bob Epling, Dec. 8, 2010
Telephone interviews with Baseball Hall of Fame director of research Tim Wiles, Dec. 9-10, 2010