But prosecutor Stephen Bradley said the board also heard from relatives, investigators and others whose “lives were shattered” when Tharpe murdered Freeman exactly 27 years ago.
MORE: How lethal injection works
RELATED: The faces of Death Row
Tharpe was convicted of killing Freeman, 29, moments after she and her sister-in-law, Tharpe’s wife, started their drive from Jones County to their jobs in Macon.
If Tharpe is put to death, he will be the second man Georgia has executed this year. Last year, the state executed a record nine murderers.
By Monday morning, Tharpe had legal appeals pending before the U.S. Supreme Court and the Superior Court in Butts County, which is where Georgia's death row is located.
In the clemency petition before the state parole board, advocates argued that Tharpe is not the same man who shot Freeman three times with a shotgun.
Also expected were two religious advisors and a lawyer who heard juror Barney Gattie, who is now deceased, refer to Tharpe using a racial slur.
According to court filings, when Tharpe’s lawyers interviewed Gattie in 1998, the former juror told them he believed there were “two kinds of black people.” He told them that if the vicitm had been in the same category as Tharpe he would not have voted to punish him with death. But Freeman, Gattie said, came from a “good black family,” according to court filings.
In his clemency petition, Tharpe's friends and family described him as a good man, not at all like the violent, angry man who killed his sister-in-law and then kidnapped and sexually assaulted his estranged wife. They said he regrets the crime and is now religious.
The day before Freeman was killed, Tharpe threatened his wife in a phone call.
She had moved in with her mother almost a month earlier, escaping their violent marriage. On Sept. 24, 1990, Tharpe told her if she wanted to “play dirty,” he would show her “what dirty was.”
The next day, Tharpe borrowed a pickup truck and drove to intercept his estranged wife and her sister. He blocked their car, dragged Freeman from the vehicle and shot her, reloading the shotgun after each trigger pull. He left Freeman in a ditch for her husband, an EMT, to discover her moments later when he passed the spot driving their children to school.