Saving Southern Recipes: This show-stopping, fudgy layer cake is a labor of love that is totally worth it

Little Layer Fudge Cake / Photo by Ramona King

caption arrowCaption
Little Layer Fudge Cake / Photo by Ramona King

In Saving Southern Recipes, Southern Kitchen’s Kate Williams explores the deep heritage of Southern cooking through the lens of passed-down, old family recipes.

It isn't a Southern celebration without some kind of cake. Depending on where you're from, a celebratory cake could mean coconut layer, or hummingbird or Lane cake — all cakes are good cakes, as long as they've got plenty of frosting and the right number of layers. If you're from southern Georgia, like our Visual Content Producer Ramona King, that number of layers can reach sky high.

Below the so-called "Gnat Line," which stretches across the state from Columbus to Savannah, and in much of southeastern Alabama, the celebration cake of choice is a towering cake, most often called a "little layer cake," made of countless thin cake layers separated by a smear of boiled fudgy frosting. King's grandmother, Ramona Mercer, used to make the cake for countless occasions, including every year for her mother's birthday.

"I hardly ever remember a time when I would walk into my grandmother's dining room [in Metter, Georgia] and this cake wouldn't be sitting on her antique buffet in a glass cake stand," King said. "This cake was her go-to show-stopping cake and the most requested of her desserts. ... As the wife of a former Senator and the acting County Commissioner, she made this cake for almost everyone in Candler County at some point during her retirement from teaching."

The little layer cake is likely descended from the Hungarian Dobos torte, a cake made of thin sponge layers, chocolate buttercream and caramel. Named for its inventor, József C. Dobos, it first made an appearance in 1885 at the National General Exhibition of Budapest. Other comparable cakes cropped up across Europe and European colonies around the same time, and inspired bakers in the United States to do the same. One such cake, still popular today in New Orleans, is the Doberge cake, which substituted pudding for the buttercream filling and fondant for the caramel topping. In Maryland, the Smith Island Cake is another famed variation made with yellow cake layers, cooked chocolate icing and, often crushed candy bars. In Appalachia, bakers fashion stack cakes that soar to similar heights with apple butter sandwiched between crepe-like layers.

Little layer cakes have an air of austerity, like the stack cake, with a bit of sweet flair from the chocolate frosting. Mercer's recipe calls for a classic yellow butter cake batter, studded with pecans, and streched with a bit of Crisco. The thick, fudgy frosting gets its color from a touch of cocoa — just enough so that you know its there. "It is moist, but not in a fluffy way," said King. It's moist "in a decadent, true Southern (and deliciously) grainy fudgy way."

Over the holidays, King tried her hand at making her grandmother's cake, following the recipe hand-written in a notebook decades ago. "The cake was just my mom and I remembered it," she said. "It was one of those visceral, close-your-eyes-and-taste-the-nostalgia moments."

However, the process was not without its challenges. "I gained tremendous respect for my grandmother during the process of making this cake," said King. "It really is a labor of love." King found it challenging to remove the thin cake layers from the pan, as well as to keep the frosting warm enough to spread throughout the process. "This cake was actually much more work than I was expecting," she said. "She is even more of a kitchen magician in my mind now."

Despite the challenges, King plans to tackle the cake again. She'd like to try it with older pans — she said her brand-new ones clung too tightly to the cake, causing her to lose a few layers — and will double the fudge frosting recipe next time. King said it also helps to plan ahead. She told me she realized why her grandmother always had the cake ready to go, on its cake stand, when she'd show up to her house: "It is a mess! A happy mess. We never had any idea how much work had gone into her perfect masterpiece. You definitely want to let this rest for at least a few hours before serving. This allows the fudge to cool and settle and the preparer to wash dishes and take a nap!"

Like many baking projects, practice certainly makes for a more perfect cake. However, even with little mistakes here and there, King said, the flavor and texture was spot-on: "I'm hoping with time and practice I can achieve what she did so many times! She was so well known for this cake in her town. As her namesake, I'm proud to carry on the tradition."