From flop to Rocky Top: Tennessee’s wild win

In the biggest game here since Phillip Fulmer was given the gate, the Volunteers trailed 21-0 after 25 minutes. They trailed Florida, the opponent Tennessee hadn’t beaten since 2005, which was Year 1 of the Urban Meyer Era, which was 11 seasons, three Florida and four Tennessee coaches ago. The Vols fell behind a team working without its No. 1 quarterback. They fell behind with Uncle Verne and “College GameDay” on hand.

After 25 minutes, Tennessee wasn’t just a team having a rotten day. It was a touted aggregation about to be revealed as an abject fraud. In the press box at halftime, a chastened man in an orange-checked shirt said, “The half is over. Didn’t say it was good. Just saying it’s over.”

The second half began. It was, shall we say, different.

Over 22 ½ minutes, Tennessee outscored the Gators 35-0, outgained them 319 yards to 11. The Fraud Squad stood down. The Vols of Butch Jones hadn’t just proved they could win a Big Game. They won this one 38-28 after getting everything wrong. They flirted with embarrassment. They walked away with what can, at least for one week, be deemed vindication.

Said Jones: “That first half, that wasn’t us. Every man knew that. When we came out the second half, I knew this football team was not to be denied.”

Yes, this is all subject to change. Tennessee visits Sanford Stadium next week, and Georgia has reason to feel abashed. But Florida had become the Vols’ bogeyman: With that run of failure put to rest, who knows what Tennessee might up and do?

Nobody doubts that Tennessee has talent, but every game under Jones against an opponent of similar caliber save one had ended in a loss. The exception was against Georgia last year on a day when Nick Chubb was hurt on the first play. This season had seen the Vols need overtime to outlast Appalachian State, then fall behind Virginia Tech 14-0, then struggle with Ohio of the Mid-American Conference. Tennessee entered Saturday’s game having not lost but having impressed nobody.

In 22 ½ minutes, everything changed. Joshua Dobbs of Alpharetta delivered four touchdown passes in 10 minutes and 41 seconds. The receivers who couldn’t catch a cold started snagging everything. A defense that made a bumped-up backup quarterback look good for a half – behind Austin Appleby, Florida had 300 yards in two quarters – couldn’t be breached for a first down.

“We came into the locker room saying, ‘Don’t panic,’ ” Dobbs said, but the moment for panicking had already gone. Whatever the Vols did in the second half had to be an improvement, did it not?

Had they lost to Florida by any margin, it would have thrown the entire Jones rebuild – the “brick by brick” stuff” – into serious question. Tennessee was the pick to win the SEC East, as opposed to defending champ Florida, which was slotted behind Georgia. This was widely seen as a must-win for Jones, who afterward bristled at the characterization.

“The local media has to understand,” he said. “We’ve got something special here with character and competitiveness … (My players) responded like you’d want, and I’m exceptionally proud of that.”

When it was 21-0, not many folks would have traded places with Butch Jones. At the end of this careening day, the denizens of Big Orange Country were ready to hoist him on high. After nearly a decade in the wilderness, a proud program had been served a fresh helping of pride.

Support real journalism. Support local journalism. Subscribe to The Atlanta Journal-Constitution today. See offers.

Your subscription to the Atlanta Journal-Constitution funds in-depth reporting and investigations that keep you informed. Thank you for supporting real journalism.