TWO VIEWS
“The Constitution makes it clear that the president’s job is to faithfully execute the laws. And in my view the president has not faithfully executed the laws. Fighting for this is in the best interests of the Congress.”
— House Speaker John Boehner
“They’re doing nothing here and so they have to give some aura of activity. There really needs to be an adult in that room of the Republican caucus.”
— House Democratic leader Nancy Pelosi
The House will vote next month on legislation authorizing a lawsuit accusing President Barack Obama of failing to carry out the laws passed by Congress, Speaker John Boehner announced Wednesday.
In a memo distributed to House members, Boehner, R-Ohio, accused Obama of “aggressive unilateralism” and said if left unchecked, it would give the president “king-like authority at the expense of the American people and their elected legislators.”
White House press secretary Josh Earnest dismissed any suggestion that the president has failed to act within the law in issuing executive orders or taking other actions.
“We feel completely confident that the president was operating within his authority as the president of the United States to take these steps on behalf of the American people,” he told reporters.
Whatever the outcome of the suit in the courts, Boehner’s announcement guarantees yet another political struggle between Republicans and Obama and his Democratic allies in an election campaign season already full of them.
“On matters ranging from health care and energy to foreign policy and education, President Obama has repeatedly run an end-around” on the public and Congress, Boehner wrote in his memo. He accused Obama of “ignoring some statutes completely, selectively enforcing others and at times, creating laws of his own.”
At a news conference, Boehner strongly brushed aside a question of whether impeachment proceedings could result from the suit.
In his memo, he stopped short of accusing the president of violating his oath of office. Instead, he said Obama was “straining the boundaries of the solemn oath he took on Inauguration Day.”
Other Republicans have been less restrained. Rep. Lou Barletta, R-Pa., said recently the House probably has the votes to impeach Obama, although he added that he wasn’t calling for it. And a tea party-backed former House member, Allen West of Florida, has called for the House to vote to remove the president from office.
The GOP-led House has already taken symbolic steps to try to curb Obama, who in his January State of the Union address announced his intention to use executive action to carry out parts of his agenda blocked by Republicans in Congress. In March, the chamber passed a bill that would require the Justice Department to notify Congress of any instance in which a federal official decides not to enforce a specific law or policy, and another that would give either the House or Senate standing in court to challenge an executive decision to not enforce a certain law.
Boehner has long maintained that Obama’s executive actions, including deferring deportation of young immigrants brought to the U.S. illegally as children, have made it harder to build support among Republicans for more significant legislative efforts.
On Tuesday, he rejected a suggestion that the suit was a political move designed to give traditional Republican voters an added impetus for going to the polls this fall when control of Congress will be at stake.
But Rep. Steve Israel of New York, who chairs the Democratic campaign committee, accused Boehner of planning a “politically motivated lawsuit,” and predicted the voters will punish Republicans for it.
He said the suit would be a “reprehensible waste of taxpayers’ money and a desperate political stunt meant to gin up the Republican base at a time when House Republicans are historically unpopular.”
A group established to help elect Democrats, the House Majority PAC, rushed out an online request for donations that said Boehner had “sunk to a new low” and was “caving in to pressure from the right and suing President Obama.”
Disputes about the balance of power between the executive branch and the Congress are as old as the Constitution under a system in which lawmakers pass laws and the president carries them out.
Boehner said the House “must act as an institution to defend the constitutional principles at stake.”
About the Author
