Deputies said Goins shot Natalia Roberts, a 30-year-old single mother of three, in the back of the head. They said Goins claimed Natalia Roberts was an intruder in the home, even though Roberts brought her 3-year-old along with her 3-week-old baby.
Investigators said they figured out that Goins, 37, faked a pregnancy and planned to pretend that the little girl was her own.
“It was like a made-for-TV movie,” Benny Roberts told Channel 2. Natalia Roberts’ children are currently with family members.
Catherine Goins, 37, remains in the Catoosa County Jail in northwest Georgia with no bond.