“Your comments were extremely unprofessional, disrespectful and insensitive to those around you,” Reynolds wrote in a March 29 letter. The GBI did not name the person whose remains were being examined during the autopsy, but said she had not been Muslim.
The AJC reviewed two years's worth of complaints related to the morgue and found two cases where workers were disciplined for conduct related to autopsies. In December 2018, one employee took a photo of another smiling while posing with the severed head of anelderly Clayton County murder victim. Those employees both were fired. The three other complaints were not related to autopsies. Several Georgia coroners told the AJC that all the GBI medical examiners they've dealt with are very professional and respectful of the dead.
Edward Ahmed Mitchell, a former prosecutor and executive director of the Georgia chapter of the Council on American-Islamic Relations, said he’s always been impressed by the professionalism of the GBI, but finds Thomas’ case extremely upsetting.
“A two-week suspension for playing with a dead body while mocking a faith community seems like a remarkably light punishment,” Mitchell said. “If playing with a dead body during an autopsy is not a fireable offense by itself, I do not know what is.”
The handful of employees interviewed in the internal investigation said they didn’t believe Thomas was motivated by ill will toward Muslims, but all found her actions inappropriate. One morgue worker who was offended wondered if the joke was a tone-deaf attempt at dealing with the stress of the always-busy morgue.
Thomas told the agency’s internal affairs unit that she had heard the joke years earlier when she was a medical resident in Richmond, Va., and she thought of it randomly during the autopsy. The joke wasn’t meant to disparage the Muslim faith, she told investigators.
“I made an absurd comment about a nonexistent autopsy,” Thomas told Fred Mays, director of the Office of Professional Standards, according to a transcript. “How does that degrade another person’s faith?”
“When you’re pulling the neck of a torso, and you’re making this sound,” Mays responded, “that’s poking fun and that’s degrading — you know that’s degrading.”
Thomas said: “I think it’s in the eye of the beholder.”