Authorities plan to re-test Atlanta Child Murders evidence

Mayor Keisha Lance Bottoms wants to make sure victims are not forgotten and wants to let the world know “black lives do matter.”
Atlanta Mayor Keisha Lance Bottoms speaks at a news conference Thursday, announcing a new look at the Atlanta Child Murders evidence.

Atlanta Mayor Keisha Lance Bottoms speaks at a news conference Thursday, announcing a new look at the Atlanta Child Murders evidence.

State and local officials will take a fresh look at the Atlanta Child Murders cases that left more than 20 black children and young adults dead four decades ago, Atlanta Mayor Keisha Lance Bottoms announced Thursday.

Wayne Williams, 60, is serving life for the murders of two of the adults. Authorities closed the children’s cases after those convictions, saying they were certain Willliams was responsible for the entire string of crimes. Williams never faced charges in any of the children’s deaths, and questions among victims’ family members and some investigators have lingered over the years.

Bottoms noted that evidence does link Williams to many of the murdered children, but wants to make sure there isn't something new to be learned from re-testing evidence. She requested the new investigation months after she met Catherine Leach-Bell, whose son, 13-year-old Curtis Walker, was among the victims.

“It may be there is nothing left to be tested,” Bottoms said during a news conference. “But I do think history will judge us by our actions and we will be able to say we tried.”

Thursday's announcement came days before a new documentary about the case from famed producer Will Packer airs on Investigation Discovery.

“I want to acknowledge and thank my friend, Will Packer, who is doing a documentary on the missing and murdered children,” Bottoms said. The program airs at 9 p.m. Saturday.

Bottoms recalled living through the terrifying chapter in Atlanta’s history as a 9-year-old. The new look at evidence, she said, is meant to assure the families that “we have done all that we can do to make sure their memories are not forgotten and, in the truest sense of the word, to let the world know that black lives do matter.”

The operation will be a joint one, with authorities from the Atlanta Police Department, the Fulton County District Attorney’s Office and the Georgia Bureau of Investigation using modern technology to test stored evidence such as DNA or cloth or carpet fibers. Fulton County District Attorney Paul Howard said this will be the first project of his office’s soon-to-be formed Conviction Integrity Unit.

Williams, who has maintained his innocence, is held at Telfair State Prison in southeast Georgia. After his 1982 conviction for the murders of two young adults in Fulton County, where the vast majority of deaths occurred, authorities there announced they were convinced Williams was also guilty in the child murders and closed the cases.

Ronald Kuby, one of his former attorneys, called the renewed investigation an “overdue” step that could answer lingering questions. Williams couldn’t immediately be reached for comment.

READ: Cotton candy or meth? ‘Failure of the system’ leaves Ga. woman jailed

READ: How a mysterious disappearance nearly destroyed a woman's life

In DeKalb County, where five cases from the Atlanta Child Murders period remain open, the police department said it would cooperate with Atlanta’s efforts. Officials have disagreed over the years whether the DeKalb cases should be attributed to Williams.

Some victims’ relatives also have questioned whether officials rushed to judgment decades ago by suggesting Williams was guilty of all the murders.

Leach-Bell, whose son’s case is among the five in DeKalb, praised the mayor and other Atlanta officials for deciding to check the evidence again.

“I am so happy to hear what I heard today,” Leach-Bell said during the news conference. “It’s brought a little comfort in my heart. I have been let down for many, many, many, many, many, many, many years.”

One letdown came in 2005 after a fruitless effort by DeKalb police to re-investigate its cases. Then Police Chief Louis Graham reopened the cases and championed the idea that Williams hadn’t committed the murders. That investigation stalled a year later when Graham resigned amid an unrelated controversy.

Three of the DeKalb cases were among 10 so-called “pattern cases” that Fulton prosecutors discussed at Williams’ trial to make their case that he was the lone killer who terrorized the city. (Leach-Bell’s son’s death wasn’t considered a pattern case.)

Whether the new review of evidence produces results or not, the mayor said she is also working on another of the families’ priorities: honoring the victims. Bottoms created a task force to explore how best to do that. The mayor took a step Thursday by reading victims’ names aloud during the news conference.

Atlanta Police Chief Erika Shields said she hoped the fresh look at the cases would help the city make the dark period from 1979 to 1981 when the children, nearly all boys, were killed more than a “footnote” in Atlanta’s story. She said officials also have an “obligation” to make sure they’ve tried everything possible to bring closure.

Retired Atlanta homicide detective Danny Agan, who appears in the Investigation Discovery documentary, said he believes Williams committed most of the murders, but not necessarily all of them. Agan, who stood behind the mayor during her announcement, said he didn’t view the planned new testing as a jab at the original police work. He said the spirit of the mayor’s inquiry was the correct one: to find the truth.

“The truth won’t hurt you,” he said.

Catherine Leach-Bell's son Curtis Walker was one of five black boys found slain in DeKalb County from 1979 to 1982. Authorities have for decades suspected the killer was convicted murderer Wayne Williams.Bell want's answers to why her son's murder is still unsolved.