Ask yourself this: Do the Atlanta Falcons have a particularly robust roster? One of the league’s 16-best rosters? (The NFL has 32 teams, as you know.) If your answer is “yes,” you’re either Arthur Blank or Thomas Dimitroff. If your answer is “no” – and I suggest that most everybody besides Blank and Dimitroff would answer that way – don’t you then have to ask: Who compiled this roster? Who has had eight years as general manager to build a talent base that goes beyond Julio Jones, Matt Ryan and Desmond Trufant?

The answer is Dimitroff, who was again given a vote of … well, I’m not sure we can call it confidence. Maybe a vote of hope against hope. Blank has had two chances to fire this GM, and he has twice declined. He has re-aligned Dimitroff’s duties – that should have told the owner something, should it not? – but he has kept him as general manager. I have no idea why. Guessing you don’t, either.

Dimitroff has done some very good things here. Ryan was the most important draft pick in franchise history, and the then-rookie GM aced it. I will argue forever that trading up for Jones was a bold move executed to perfection. Michael Turner is the best free-agent hire the Falcons have ever made. Trufant? Very good player. Vic Beasley Jr.? Could be a very good player. Ryan Schrader? Nice off-the-grid find. But the intent here isn’t to sing TD the GM’s greatest hits. It’s to examine the totality of his work over eight seasons, and here’s what we see:

A team that had five consecutive winnings seasons in its first five under Dimitroff has had three consecutive non-winning seasons. Perhaps you’re one who views 8-8 in Year 1 in Dan Quinn’s first year of coaching as a bold step forward. I do not. I think a team that starts 6-1 against what would wind up as the league’s second-softest schedule had to fall apart to finish .500, and a team that falls apart is never a recommendation of anyone – the GM, the coach, the owner, the quarterback, the offensive coordinator. (Wes Durham and David Archer get a pass.)

Blank is free to keep/hire whom he chooses, but this lingering affection for his GM stumps the band. I regard Dimitroff as one of the smartest men I’ve ever met (and not just in sports), but I don’t know how Blank or anyone can reconcile three non-playoff seasons on the trot as a sign of brighter tomorrows.

Truth to tell, the way the Falcons collapsed – with Ryan clearly confused, with an offensive line still in flux, with a defense that hasn’t manifested a pass rush since Claude Humphrey – doesn’t augur better for next year. The schedule will be tougher, and the Falcons will apparently still have Kyle Shanahan calling plays.

But enough. I’ve made myself clear. But I do note that the Falcons just folded in a way they never quite did under the previous coach, and Mike Smith – who hasn’t coached in a year but might again soon – is still the only principal Blank has fired over the past decade. Guess it’s still all Smitty’s fault.

About the Author

Featured

In 2020, ministers and seminary students were sent to polling locations throughout the state to monitor, offer encouragement and diffuse tense situations as a part of the New Georgia Project’s Faith Initiative. (Christina Matacotta for the AJC)

Credit: Christina Matacotta for the AJC