Police say Wade had been telling people for months she was pregnant, even posting a baby registry and due date online. But police say she was never pregnant.

Wade was reportedly friends with Sutton back in elementary school, and the two had reconnected before Wade invited Sutton to her apartment. That's where police found Sutton's body and Wade. (Video via WABC)

When police first arrived, Wade claimed the baby was hers but later changed her story and said she stabbed Sutton in self-defense. Wade also told police she cut out Sutton's unborn child to save the baby.

Neighbors told News 12 that Sutton would have been a great mother.

"She would have been the best possible mother to that baby. Devoted to that baby, making sure that baby had everything it needs," neighbor Monica Keller told News 12.

Sutton's child survived the attack and is reportedly in good health.