Judge in APS cheating trial to remain on case as six seek retrial

VIDEO: Fulton Superior Court Judge Jerry Baxter didn't mince words about the 2015 APS test-cheating trial he presided over. Here are some of his insights from that time.

The Georgia Court of Appeals won’t remove the colorful judge who presided over the Atlanta Public Schools cheating trial from the ongoing case of six of the defendants seeking a retrial.

Six former educators convicted in the 2015 test-cheating case want a new trial and had sought the recusal of Fulton County Superior Court Judge Jerry Baxter.

Baxter handled the original trial -- the longest criminal trial in Georgia history — that resulted in the racketeering convictions of 11 Atlanta administrators and teachers. A jury found them guilty of conspiring to cheat on standardized tests by changing students' answers and receiving bonuses and raises based on the bogus scores.

Seven defendants are seeking a new Fulton County trial. Attorneys for six of them had asked the Georgia Court of Appeals to review Baxter’s participation in the ongoing case, which would include deciding whether or not to grant a new trial.

But on Thursday, the Georgia Court of Appeals announced it would not consider the request to remove Baxter.

Baxter spiced up the long-running trial with quippy remarks and zingers that some called rude and others referred to as "Baxterisms." After he retired, he took "senior status" in 2016, an appointment that allows him to hear cases when needed.


Stephen Scarborough and Nazish Ahmed, public defenders representing six of the remaining defendants, contend Baxter is ill-suited to continue to preside over the APS cheating case. In court documents, the attorneys point to several of the judge’s comments from the bench and from an interview after the trial.

They contend Baxter appeared to “aggressively” defend the correctness of the verdict, such as when he told the jury that, according to trial transcripts, whatever the outcome, he “will defend it until I die.” They also allege Baxter rushed defense attorneys during cross-examinations and made “outrageous missteps.”

Fulton County Superior Court Judge Jerry Baxter presides over the sentencing of 10 defendants convicted of racketeering and other charges in the Atlanta Public Schools test-cheating trial, in April 2015. ATLANTA JOURNAL-CONSTITUTION / FILE PHOTO
Fulton County Superior Court Judge Jerry Baxter presides over the sentencing of 10 defendants convicted of racketeering and other charges in the Atlanta Public Schools test-cheating trial, in April 2015. ATLANTA JOURNAL-CONSTITUTION / FILE PHOTO

“Judge Baxter, while a fine judge and a person of great decency, was probably not the best person to review the verdicts in this case,” said Scarborough, in an phone interview.

Baxter denied a recusal motion. In his written response, the judge described his past statements as insufficient to require recusal and said the request was not timely because it pertained to comments made several years ago.

Baxter wrote that his post-trial comment made during an interview, in which he acknowledged still getting “a little worked up” about the case, was a “simple innocuous statement.”

The judge also pointed out the complexity of the APS case, citing the 23,000 pages of trial transcripts.

“Customarily the trial judge considers the motion for new trial because the court’s familiarity with the case benefits all and provides continuity,” Baxter wrote.

Defense attorneys asked Baxter to allow the appeals court to review his decision not to recuse himself. Baxter agreed, but the appeals court said Thursday it won’t take up the issue.

The appeals court did not specify a reason for denying the request. Scarborough said he had no comment on the appeals court decision.

A deputy district attorney had asked the appeals court not to wade into the recusal issue, saying the matter has been “properly decided.” A spokesman for the district attorney’s office declined to comment.

The path to Baxter presiding over the ongoing APS case has been a twisty one.

After Baxter retired, his successor, Judge Paige Reese Whitaker, recused herself from the case because she previously served as Fulton County’s deputy district attorney for appeals. The case was randomly assigned to another judge, who requested assistance of a senior judge to handle it, according to Baxter’s order. In a November order, the court’s chief judge gave the case to Baxter, citing efficiency and continuity.

Nine of the 11 educators convicted of racketeering appealed. Two of those nine went directly to the appeals court, lost, and reported for prison in October.

Scarborough is representing six of the remaining defendants: Diane Buckner-Webb and Shani Robinson, both former Dunbar Elementary teachers; Sharon Davis-Williams and Michael Pitts, both former school reform team executive directors; Theresia Copeland, a former Benteen Elementary testing coordinator; and Tabeeka Jordan, a former Deerwood Academy assistant principal.

A seventh defendant, former Dobbs Elementary principal Dana Evans, is represented by a different attorney, who last month filed an updated and more detailed motion for a new trial.

In Other News