“Unfortunately, APS has rejected this partnership to date. I remain hopeful that the City and APS will be able to work together to promote equity and economic inclusivity.”
The affordable housing restriction wasn’t acceptable to the school district, said APS general counsel Glenn Brock.
“You have no right to put restrictions on our property,” he said.
The city’s possession of the deeds is a relic of the era before the city’s independent school system and has been part of a long-running dispute between the city and APS.
At one point, the deeds were part of negotiations between the city and the school district over payments the city owed the district in connection with the Beltline.
When Carstarphen pressed the city last last February to release the deeds, Reed brushed off her comments as “an unfortunate political stunt” and said she “doesn’t know what she’s talking about.”
The next month, the school district began a court case seeking title to four properties: the Adair School, Arkwright Elementary School, Milton Avenue Elementary School, and Wright Elementary School.
In response, the city said the school district had no claim to the titles.
“Anxious to receive a windfall from private developers, APS seeks to jettison the political negotiation process that has resolved issues regarding the school properties for the last four decades and unlawfully sell property held by ‘the City of Atlanta,’ ” the city claimed in a court filing last year.
But this February, shortly after Reed, Carstarphen and school board chairman Courtney English posed together for photos commemorating the resolution of the Beltline dispute, Reed promised he would ask the City Council to transfer 10 deeds.
Carstarphen said, so far, the school district has not received them.
Her relationship with the mayor, she said, is “a work in progress.”