“Every acquaintance, employer and past lover should be located and interviewed,” Palladino wrote. “She is now a shining icon — telling lies that so far have proved all benefit and no cost — for any other opportunist who may be considering making Clinton a target.”
‘Sometimes you use deception’
In other cases, Palladino said that he and his wife, Sandra Sutherland, who was also his business partner and survives him, had claimed to be journalists.
“We all much prefer being who we are, but sometimes you use a deception because nothing else will produce the truth,” he told The New York Times in 1999. “You know if you stated honestly to this person that you were a private investigator, they would lie to you.”
»THIS WEEK: Grammy-nominated pop music star SOPHIE dies in tragic fall
Weinstein, the once-powerful movie mogul who was sentenced last March to 23 years in prison for sex crimes, had hired Palladino’s firm to defend him against accusations of sexual assault, journalist Ronan Farrow reported in The New Yorker in 2019.
As a part of its work for Weinstein, Palladino’s firm “created dossiers on both journalists and accusers,” Farrow reported.
According to The New Yorker, Palladino also worked for singer R. Kelly, who was arrested in 2019 on federal child pornography and obstruction charges.
The New Yorker reported that Kelly had been sued in 2002 by Charles Freeman, a man from Kansas City who said that Palladino had hired him to track down any videotapes related to Kelly that might be “on the streets.”
Jonestown mass suicide
The San Francisco Chronicle reported that Palladino had also spent seven years investigating the deaths at Jonestown, Guyana, where more than 900 people died by suicide or were murdered in 1978 at the behest of cult leader Jim Jones.
Palladino and Sutherland worked out of their home, a Victorian house in Haight-Ashbury, The Chronicle reported in 2000.
»2020: Body of kidnapped LA firefighter found in Mexico
They charged $300 an hour at the time, according to The Chronicle, and had worked for clients that included the Hell’s Angels, the Black Panthers and the Teamsters, as well as celebrities like Kevin Costner and Don Johnson. Other clients included musician Courtney Love and auto executive John DeLorean. In the 1990s Palladino ran an investigation to protect the credibility of Jeffrey Wigand, a whistleblower who helped prosecutors in a case against major tobacco companies.
The Clinton campaign
In his work for the Clinton campaign, Palladino’s staff scoured Arkansas and beyond, collecting disparaging accounts from Flowers’ ex-boyfriends, employers and others who claimed to know her, accounts that the campaign then disseminated to the news media.
By the time Clinton finally admitted to “sexual relations” with Flowers, years later, Clinton aides had used stories collected by Palladino to brand her as a “bimbo” and a “pathological liar.”
John Arthur Palladino was born on July 9, 1944. He graduated from Boston Latin School in 1962. He graduated from the University of California, Berkeley, with a degree in political science in 1968, and received his law degree from the university in 1975. Three years later, he was admitted to the California state bar and received his private investigator’s license, records show.
Palladino had already been recruited to work as a private eye by another well-known San Francisco sleuth, Hal Lipset, who enlisted Palladino to pose as a fur thief and work undercover in a prison in Queens in 1972 as part of an investigation into drug dealing and prisoner abuse, according to The Chronicle.
Palladino told The Chronicle that, as a result of his investigation and grand jury testimony, about 23 guards, undersheriffs and others were eventually indicted.
It was “absolutely legal” for private investigators to mislead, Palladino told The Chronicle, as long as they didn’t present themselves as law enforcement officials or as representatives of the target of an investigation.
However, as an ethical issue, he said it was “more dicey.”
Kim Green, the editor of Pursuit, a trade magazine for private detectives, said Palladino didn’t evoke feelings of neutrality, “especially in a profession that values privacy and behind-the-scenes maneuvering — some folks in the investigative community can be pretty skeptical of PIs who become celebrities in their own right.”
She added, “Still, there’s no question he made his mark on the field, as part of that tradition of myth-busting Bay Area sleuths who rejected the trench coat stereotype and modernized the profession.”
Despite his reputation for aggressive tactics, Palladino said that his methods had to be legal and that he most often presented himself, truthfully and simply, as a private investigator.
“I have to be concerned with how it will be perceived by a judge or jury,” Palladino told The Chronicle in 2000. “If it looks scummy, it may be discounted.”