After performances that resulted in him being subbed out of the past two home games, Pity Martinez played very well on offense and defense in Atlanta United's 2-0 win against St. Louis in the quarterfinals of the U.S. Open Cup.

In addition to the deciding goal with a curling shot in the 52nd minute, Martinez worked hard on defense. Though he wasn't credited with any tackles, he attempted several and was involved in numerous duels. That hesitation was why he was pulled out of last week's draw with New York Red Bulls.

“I think he played a really good game,” Atlanta United manager Frank de Boer said. “I was really happy of course for him. He knows he wants to see his level going up. Today he did a good step for that.”

Martinez declined to speak following the game.

Martinez’s goal came after Emerson Hyndman dispossessed a St. Louis defender in the penalty box. Hyndman quickly passed to Martinez, who didn’t hesitate to bury his shot.

“Great goal, great finish,” Hyndman said. “I did the easy bit. He did the hard bit.”

De Boer said the goal might give Martinez a boost of confidence. The former River Plate standout has just two goals and four assists in league play this season.

“Today he responded how you want a player to respond,” de Boer said. “That’s good for him, good for me, good for the team, good for the club and so hopefully he can stay on that level. He has to understand this is what we want to see from him: not just scoring goals but making tackles.

“We expect he will never be an Eric Remedi or Darlington Nagbe. But he can do what he showed today. It makes a difference not only for him but for his teammates.”

About the Author

Keep Reading

One of Gerardo Martino's (center) challenges in his return as Atlanta United manager will be to help Miguel Almirón (center left), who he managed in Atlanta in 2017-18, rediscover his form after a disappointing 2025 season. Almirón had six goals and seven assists in 31 games after returning to the Five Stripes. (Miguel Martinez/AJC 2017)

Credit: Miguel Martinez

Featured

Travelers walk around the baggage claim in the South Terminal at Hartsfield-Jackson Atlanta International Airport on Thursday, Nov. 6, 2025. Atlanta is among the airports where the FAA will reduce flights due to the shutdown, and airports are facing a shortage of air traffic controllers. 
(Miguel Martinez/ AJC)

Credit: Miguel Martinez-Jimenez