Maxwell Ratings: Colquitt County, Buford top programs in the South

Colquitt County has established its superiority over Georgia by winning the Class AAAAAA championship this past weekend, but how would the Packers do against other teams across the South?

Our resident computer ratings expect, Loren Maxwell, has an answer of his own and the computer validated what many AJC readers already knew - that Georgia plays some of the best high school football in perhaps the strongest high school football region in the nation.

Using data from MaxPreps, Maxwell crunched the numbers for all 2,425 state association teams in Alabama, Florida, Georgia, Mississippi, both of the Carolinas, and Tennessee.  It turns out not only does Georgia boast the best team in the South, but the best two, Colquitt County and Buford.  In fact, Georgia claims nearly a third of the top 150 slots, more than any other state.

Key games among the top teams that made a significant difference in the ratings were Colquitt County’s 35-14 defeat of Hoover, Alabama’s champion from its highest classification, and Buford's 17-0 downing of Trinity Christian Academy, the 3A champion from Florida that finished #16 in the ratings.

Maxwell's top 150 Southern US teams are below.  For comparison, the Freeman computer ratings, sponsored by MaxPreps, currently has Colquitt County as the third best team among the seven states while Buford is ranked 12th.

Maxwell Southern US High School Football Ratings

All data compiled from MaxPreps.

The Maxwell Ratings are a regular feature of Georgia High School Football Daily, a free e-mail newsletter. To join the mailing list, click here.

Visit the Maxwell Ratings for more ratings and information, including Maxwell's Georgia High School Football Archive.

Rank Team City State Rank Class Rank Record Rating Sch Str Rank
1 Colquitt County Moultrie Ga. 1 GHSA-6A 1 15-0 102.56 74.89 1
2 Buford Buford Ga. 2 GHSA-4A 1 15-0 100.61 54.72 260
3 St. Thomas Aquinas Fort Lauderdale Fla. 1 FHSAA-7A 1 15-1 100.48 58.35 151
4 South Panola Batesville Miss. 1 MHSAA-6A 1 15-0 96.48 67.74 23
5 Maryville Maryville Tenn. 1 TSSAA-6A 1 15-0 96.44 58.47 148
6 Starkville Starkville Miss. 2 MHSAA-6A 2 13-1 95.16 72.00 6
7 Clay-Chalkville Pinson Ala. 1 AHSAA-6A 1 15-0 92.49 60.72 111
8 Washington Miami Fla. 2 FHSAA-4A 1 14-0 90.68 55.43 245
9 Fulton Knoxville Tenn. 2 TSSAA-4A 1 15-0 90.65 41.96 832
10 Central Miami Fla. 3 FHSAA-6A 1 14-1 90.52 63.93 60
11 New Bern New Bern N.C. 1 NCHSAA-4A 1 17-0 90.50 57.65 173
12 Hoover Hoover Ala. 2 AHSAA-7A 1 12-2 89.97 66.54 35
13 Mallard Creek Charlotte N.C. 2 NCHSAA-4A 2 15-1 89.64 63.32 67
14 Hillcrest Simpsonville S.C. 1 SCHSL-4A 1 14-1 89.33 52.76 322
15 Archer Lawrenceville Ga. 3 GHSA-6A 2 11-4 88.76 72.49 3
16 Trinity Christian Academy Jacksonville Fla. 4 FHSAA-3A 1 11-2 88.32 50.18 431
17 West Knoxville Tenn. 3 TSSAA-5A 1 14-1 87.94 52.29 345
18 Dutch Fork Irmo S.C. 2 SCHSL-4A 2 12-3 86.43 62.28 80
19 Grayson Loganville Ga. 4 GHSA-6A 3 10-2 86.12 69.62 14
20 Dacula Dacula Ga. 5 GHSA-6A 4 10-2 85.91 71.04 9
21 Oak Grove Hattiesburg Miss. 3 MHSAA-6A 3 13-2 84.71 65.40 44
22 Crest Shelby N.C. 3 NCHSAA-3A 1 16-0 84.70 41.09 881
23 Oakland Murfreesboro Tenn. 4 TSSAA-6A 2 13-2 84.31 61.22 95
24 Calhoun Calhoun Ga. 6 GHSA-3A 1 15-0 84.09 40.66 913
25 Byrnes Duncan S.C. 3 SCHSL-4A 3 12-2 84.00 61.15 97
26 McEachern Powder Springs Ga. 7 GHSA-6A 5 10-4 83.98 72.33 4
27 Wake Forest Wake Forest N.C. 4 NCHSAA-4A 3 15-1 83.89 54.39 272
28 Brandon Brandon Miss. 4 MHSAA-6A 4 12-2 83.63 65.47 41
29 American Heritage Plantation Fla. 5 FHSAA-5A 1 12-3 82.74 63.59 64
30 Montgomery Bell Academy Nashville Tenn. 5 TSSAA-II-2A 1 11-2 82.73 66.26 37
31 American Heritage Delray Beach Fla. 6 FHSAA-3A 2 11-2 82.51 55.63 235
32 Milton Milton Ga. 8 GHSA-6A 6 11-2 82.15 63.91 61
33 Ensworth Nashville Tenn. 6 TSSAA-II-2A 2 10-2 82.15 63.73 63
34 Washington County Sandersville Ga. 9 GHSA-3A 2 14-1 82.05 42.43 813
35 Saraland Saraland Ala. 3 AHSAA-6A 2 13-2 82.01 57.07 189
36 Miramar Miramar Fla. 7 FHSAA-8A 1 8-3 81.96 63.38 65
37 Southaven Southaven Miss. 5 MHSAA-6A 5 10-3 81.92 65.74 39
38 Clinton Clinton Miss. 6 MHSAA-6A 6 10-3 81.80 68.81 17
39 Tucker Tucker Ga. 10 GHSA-6A 7 10-3 81.67 58.93 138
40 Lee County Leesburg Ga. 11 GHSA-6A 8 8-3 81.52 67.19 29
41 Mainland Daytona Beach Fla. 8 FHSAA-6A 2 13-1 81.41 50.63 415
42 Blackman Murfreesboro Tenn. 7 TSSAA-6A 3 11-2 81.40 61.54 90
43 Dorman Roebuck S.C. 4 SCHSL-4A 4 10-3 81.35 64.25 56
44 Spartanburg Spartanburg S.C. 5 SCHSL-4A 5 12-3 81.18 60.53 113
45 Mill Creek Hoschton Ga. 12 GHSA-6A 9 7-4 81.17 67.97 20
46 Independence Charlotte N.C. 5 NCHSAA-4A 4 12-1 81.01 52.27 346
47 Charlotte Catholic Charlotte N.C. 6 NCHSAA-4A 5 14-2 80.98 62.32 79
48 Ravenwood Brentwood Tenn. 8 TSSAA-6A 4 15-2 80.87 53.31 304
49 Northside Warner Robins Ga. 13 GHSA-5A 1 14-1 80.60 57.17 187
50 Blessed Trinity Roswell Ga. 14 GHSA-3A 3 13-1 80.50 50.00 438
51 St. Paul's Episcopal Mobile Ala. 4 AHSAA-5A 1 16-0 80.43 49.38 462
52 Armwood Seffner Fla. 9 FHSAA-6A 3 15-1 80.28 47.61 532
53 Oxford Oxford Miss. 7 MHSAA-5A 1 13-2 79.87 54.68 264
54 Havelock Havelock N.C. 7 NCHSAA-3A 2 14-2 79.80 42.85 790
55 Flanagan Pembroke Pines Fla. 10 FHSAA-8A 2 12-1 79.76 47.92 514
56 Christ Presbyterian Academy Nashville Tenn. 9 TSSAA-3A 1 15-0 79.18 38.60 1013
57 Allatoona Acworth Ga. 15 GHSA-5A 2 14-1 79.03 58.31 152
58 North Gwinnett Suwanee Ga. 16 GHSA-6A 10 8-3 78.95 67.77 22
59 Valdosta Valdosta Ga. 17 GHSA-6A 11 9-2 78.79 64.73 48
60 First Coast Jacksonville Fla. 11 FHSAA-8A 3 12-1 78.69 58.51 147
61 Opelika Opelika Ala. 5 AHSAA-6A 3 9-2 78.66 60.79 108
62 Goose Creek Goose Creek S.C. 6 SCHSL-4A 6 10-2 78.65 60.26 115
63 Brentwood Academy Brentwood Tenn. 10 TSSAA-II-2A 3 8-3 78.28 69.84 12
64 Union City Union City Tenn. 11 TSSAA-1A 1 14-0 78.27 16.46 2010
65 Central Phenix City Ala. 6 AHSAA-7A 2 10-2 78.16 66.86 33
66 Marist Atlanta Ga. 18 GHSA-4A 2 11-2 77.84 53.29 305
67 Apopka Apopka Fla. 12 FHSAA-8A 4 11-4 77.78 61.34 94
68 Dillon Dillon S.C. 7 SCHSL-2A 1 16-0 77.65 40.76 904
69 Spanish Fort Spanish Fort Ala. 7 AHSAA-6A 4 12-2 77.62 57.82 170
70 Peachtree Ridge Suwanee Ga. 19 GHSA-6A 12 7-4 77.57 69.56 15
71 Florence Florence Ala. 8 AHSAA-6A 5 11-3 77.55 62.33 78
72 Niceville Niceville Fla. 13 FHSAA-7A 2 11-3 77.54 61.10 99
73 Lake Norman Mooresville N.C. 8 NCHSAA-4A 6 13-2 77.16 49.39 459
74 Fairhope Fairhope Ala. 9 AHSAA-7A 3 11-1 77.12 59.38 131
75 Ware County Waycross Ga. 20 GHSA-5A 3 11-1 77.04 51.48 377
76 Prattville Prattville Ala. 10 AHSAA-7A 4 11-3 77.03 64.09 58
77 Benedictine Savannah Ga. 21 GHSA-2A 1 13-2 77.00 44.33 693
78 Hillsboro Nashville Tenn. 12 TSSAA-5A 2 14-1 76.91 43.71 732
79 Columbus Miami Fla. 14 FHSAA-8A 5 13-2 76.72 52.85 320
80 Tift County Tifton Ga. 22 GHSA-6A 13 7-4 76.61 65.44 43
81 Butler Matthews N.C. 9 NCHSAA-4A 7 10-3 76.59 56.93 192
82 Hough Cornelius N.C. 10 NCHSAA-4A 8 10-4 76.37 64.40 52
83 Wayne County Waynesboro Miss. 8 MHSAA-5A 2 11-3 76.24 57.06 190
84 Osceola Kissimmee Fla. 15 FHSAA-7A 3 13-2 76.17 42.53 809
85 Warren Central Vicksburg Miss. 9 MHSAA-6A 7 9-3 76.02 57.86 168
86 McCallie Chattanooga Tenn. 13 TSSAA-II-2A 4 9-3 76.00 64.11 57
87 Lowndes Valdosta Ga. 23 GHSA-6A 14 6-4 75.97 72.33 5
88 Science Hill Johnson City Tenn. 14 TSSAA-6A 5 11-2 75.95 52.48 334
89 Cartersville Cartersville Ga. 24 GHSA-4A 3 12-2 75.89 47.44 545
90 Northwestern Rock Hill S.C. 8 SCHSL-4A 7 9-4 75.87 66.40 36
91 Scotland Laurinburg N.C. 11 NCHSAA-4A 9 12-2 75.79 54.29 275
92 Etowah Woodstock Ga. 25 GHSA-6A 15 12-3 75.64 61.12 98
93 Hillgrove Powder Springs Ga. 26 GHSA-6A 16 9-4 75.62 65.30 46
94 Bolles Jacksonville Fla. 16 FHSAA-4A 2 11-3 75.52 51.33 386
95 Rhea County Evensville Tenn. 15 TSSAA-5A 3 13-1 75.50 37.48 1078
96 Mays Atlanta Ga. 27 GHSA-5A 4 12-3 75.45 60.06 120
97 Northern Guilford Greensboro N.C. 12 NCHSAA-3A 3 15-1 75.41 48.41 498
98 Greater Atlanta Christian Norcross Ga. 28 GHSA-2A 2 14-1 75.26 50.67 412
99 Godby Tallahassee Fla. 17 FHSAA-5A 2 12-3 75.17 56.22 215
100 Trezevant Memphis Tenn. 16 TSSAA-4A 2 13-2 74.89 25.20 1698
101 Laurel Laurel Miss. 10 MHSAA-5A 3 13-2 74.88 51.49 376
102 West Orange Winter Garden Fla. 18 FHSAA-8A 6 11-1 74.77 43.81 726
103 Fyffe Fyffe Ala. 11 AHSAA-2A 1 16-0 74.72 21.37 1841
104 Fort Dorchester North Charleston S.C. 9 SCHSL-4A 8 11-3 74.72 62.41 75
105 Lake Mary Lake Mary Fla. 19 FHSAA-8A 7 11-1 74.63 55.80 228
106 Langston Hughes Fairburn Ga. 29 GHSA-6A 17 9-4 74.27 63.33 66
107 Jefferson Jefferson Ga. 30 GHSA-3A 4 12-1 74.10 42.76 792
108 Richmond Rockingham N.C. 13 NCHSAA-4A 10 11-2 73.89 56.67 201
109 Hoggard Wilmington N.C. 14 NCHSAA-4A 11 13-2 73.45 42.95 787
110 Westlake Atlanta Ga. 31 GHSA-6A 18 10-2 73.45 50.50 418
111 Leeds Leeds Ala. 12 AHSAA-4A 1 16-1 73.35 47.18 558
112 East Lake Tarpon Springs Fla. 20 FHSAA-7A 4 13-1 73.27 44.70 677
113 Lovejoy Lovejoy Ga. 32 GHSA-6A 19 7-4 73.23 64.35 55
114 Vance Charlotte N.C. 15 NCHSAA-4A 12 11-4 73.17 56.61 204
115 Noxubee County Macon Miss. 11 MHSAA-4A 1 14-2 73.05 49.31 464
116 North Cobb Kennesaw Ga. 33 GHSA-6A 20 7-4 73.00 67.61 26
117 Cocoa Cocoa Fla. 21 FHSAA-4A 3 11-2 72.96 31.94 1375
118 Alcoa Alcoa Tenn. 17 TSSAA-3A 2 13-2 72.92 44.57 684
119 St. Pius X Catholic Atlanta Ga. 34 GHSA-4A 4 12-3 72.92 52.86 319
120 Westminster Atlanta Ga. 35 GHSA-3A 5 12-2 72.85 48.62 490
121 Garner Magnet Garner N.C. 16 NCHSAA-4A 13 13-2 72.78 47.70 529
122 Ocean Springs Ocean Springs Miss. 12 MHSAA-6A 8 11-2 72.70 60.78 109
123 Southern Durham N.C. 17 NCHSAA-3A 4 13-1 72.69 51.41 381
124 Camden County Kingsland Ga. 36 GHSA-6A 21 5-5 72.57 69.12 16
125 Knoxville Catholic Knoxville Tenn. 18 TSSAA-4A 3 10-2 72.49 52.18 347
126 Norcross Norcross Ga. 37 GHSA-6A 22 7-4 72.45 68.75 18
127 Sandy Creek Tyrone Ga. 38 GHSA-4A 5 10-2 72.44 59.41 130
128 Dr. Phillips Orlando Fla. 22 FHSAA-8A 8 12-1 72.40 47.79 523
129 Greenwood Greenwood S.C. 10 SCHSL-4A 9 9-5 72.39 64.71 49
130 Baylor Chattanooga Tenn. 19 TSSAA-II-2A 5 8-5 72.28 66.69 34
131 York York S.C. 11 SCHSL-4A 10 12-3 72.18 61.01 103
132 Dudley Greensboro N.C. 18 NCHSAA-4A 14 9-0 71.96 38.40 1021
133 Vidalia Vidalia Ga. 39 GHSA-2A 3 12-1 71.88 33.17 1307
134 Hallandale Hallandale Fla. 23 FHSAA-6A 4 10-2 71.85 49.91 440
135 Meridian Meridian Miss. 13 MHSAA-6A 9 7-5 71.55 63.83 62
136 Choctawhatchee Fort Walton Beach Fla. 24 FHSAA-6A 5 11-3 71.46 54.79 257
137 South-Doyle Knoxville Tenn. 20 TSSAA-5A 4 12-1 71.45 42.93 788
138 Central Gwinnett Lawrenceville Ga. 40 GHSA-6A 23 7-5 71.42 67.80 21
139 Baker Mobile Ala. 13 AHSAA-7A 5 9-2 71.38 57.65 174
140 West Point West Point Miss. 14 MHSAA-5A 4 9-5 71.30 63.25 69
141 Riverdale Murfreesboro Tenn. 21 TSSAA-6A 6 9-3 71.18 58.72 142
142 Benjamin Russell Alexander City Ala. 14 AHSAA-6A 6 10-2 71.09 55.16 248
143 Oak Mountain Birmingham Ala. 15 AHSAA-7A 6 10-2 71.06 60.06 121
144 Mooresville Mooresville N.C. 19 NCHSAA-4A 15 10-2 71.04 45.37 634
145 Westwood Blythewood S.C. 12 SCHSL-4A 11 12-2 70.96 52.35 343
146 Woodward Academy College Park Ga. 41 GHSA-4A 6 11-3 70.93 55.75 231
147 Reagan Pfafftown N.C. 20 NCHSAA-4A 16 12-2 70.86 52.38 341
148 Gadsden City Gadsden Ala. 16 AHSAA-7A 7 10-3 70.82 59.02 137
149 Stockbridge Stockbridge Ga. 42 GHSA-5A 5 11-3 70.81 53.28 306
150 Mount Paran Christian Kennesaw Ga. 43 GHSA-1A 1 14-0 70.64 34.51 1232