Colquitt County has established its superiority over Georgia by winning the Class AAAAAA championship this past weekend, but how would the Packers do against other teams across the South?
Our resident computer ratings expect, Loren Maxwell, has an answer of his own and the computer validated what many AJC readers already knew - that Georgia plays some of the best high school football in perhaps the strongest high school football region in the nation.
Using data from MaxPreps, Maxwell crunched the numbers for all 2,425 state association teams in Alabama, Florida, Georgia, Mississippi, both of the Carolinas, and Tennessee. It turns out not only does Georgia boast the best team in the South, but the best two, Colquitt County and Buford. In fact, Georgia claims nearly a third of the top 150 slots, more than any other state.
Key games among the top teams that made a significant difference in the ratings were Colquitt County’s 35-14 defeat of Hoover, Alabama’s champion from its highest classification, and Buford's 17-0 downing of Trinity Christian Academy, the 3A champion from Florida that finished #16 in the ratings.
Maxwell's top 150 Southern US teams are below. For comparison, the Freeman computer ratings, sponsored by MaxPreps, currently has Colquitt County as the third best team among the seven states while Buford is ranked 12th.
Maxwell Southern US High School Football Ratings
All data compiled from MaxPreps.
The Maxwell Ratings are a regular feature of Georgia High School Football Daily, a free e-mail newsletter. To join the mailing list, click here.
Visit the Maxwell Ratings for more ratings and information, including Maxwell's Georgia High School Football Archive.
Rank | Team | City | State | Rank | Class | Rank | Record | Rating | Sch Str | Rank |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | Colquitt County | Moultrie | Ga. | 1 | GHSA-6A | 1 | 15-0 | 102.56 | 74.89 | 1 |
2 | Buford | Buford | Ga. | 2 | GHSA-4A | 1 | 15-0 | 100.61 | 54.72 | 260 |
3 | St. Thomas Aquinas | Fort Lauderdale | Fla. | 1 | FHSAA-7A | 1 | 15-1 | 100.48 | 58.35 | 151 |
4 | South Panola | Batesville | Miss. | 1 | MHSAA-6A | 1 | 15-0 | 96.48 | 67.74 | 23 |
5 | Maryville | Maryville | Tenn. | 1 | TSSAA-6A | 1 | 15-0 | 96.44 | 58.47 | 148 |
6 | Starkville | Starkville | Miss. | 2 | MHSAA-6A | 2 | 13-1 | 95.16 | 72.00 | 6 |
7 | Clay-Chalkville | Pinson | Ala. | 1 | AHSAA-6A | 1 | 15-0 | 92.49 | 60.72 | 111 |
8 | Washington | Miami | Fla. | 2 | FHSAA-4A | 1 | 14-0 | 90.68 | 55.43 | 245 |
9 | Fulton | Knoxville | Tenn. | 2 | TSSAA-4A | 1 | 15-0 | 90.65 | 41.96 | 832 |
10 | Central | Miami | Fla. | 3 | FHSAA-6A | 1 | 14-1 | 90.52 | 63.93 | 60 |
11 | New Bern | New Bern | N.C. | 1 | NCHSAA-4A | 1 | 17-0 | 90.50 | 57.65 | 173 |
12 | Hoover | Hoover | Ala. | 2 | AHSAA-7A | 1 | 12-2 | 89.97 | 66.54 | 35 |
13 | Mallard Creek | Charlotte | N.C. | 2 | NCHSAA-4A | 2 | 15-1 | 89.64 | 63.32 | 67 |
14 | Hillcrest | Simpsonville | S.C. | 1 | SCHSL-4A | 1 | 14-1 | 89.33 | 52.76 | 322 |
15 | Archer | Lawrenceville | Ga. | 3 | GHSA-6A | 2 | 11-4 | 88.76 | 72.49 | 3 |
16 | Trinity Christian Academy | Jacksonville | Fla. | 4 | FHSAA-3A | 1 | 11-2 | 88.32 | 50.18 | 431 |
17 | West | Knoxville | Tenn. | 3 | TSSAA-5A | 1 | 14-1 | 87.94 | 52.29 | 345 |
18 | Dutch Fork | Irmo | S.C. | 2 | SCHSL-4A | 2 | 12-3 | 86.43 | 62.28 | 80 |
19 | Grayson | Loganville | Ga. | 4 | GHSA-6A | 3 | 10-2 | 86.12 | 69.62 | 14 |
20 | Dacula | Dacula | Ga. | 5 | GHSA-6A | 4 | 10-2 | 85.91 | 71.04 | 9 |
21 | Oak Grove | Hattiesburg | Miss. | 3 | MHSAA-6A | 3 | 13-2 | 84.71 | 65.40 | 44 |
22 | Crest | Shelby | N.C. | 3 | NCHSAA-3A | 1 | 16-0 | 84.70 | 41.09 | 881 |
23 | Oakland | Murfreesboro | Tenn. | 4 | TSSAA-6A | 2 | 13-2 | 84.31 | 61.22 | 95 |
24 | Calhoun | Calhoun | Ga. | 6 | GHSA-3A | 1 | 15-0 | 84.09 | 40.66 | 913 |
25 | Byrnes | Duncan | S.C. | 3 | SCHSL-4A | 3 | 12-2 | 84.00 | 61.15 | 97 |
26 | McEachern | Powder Springs | Ga. | 7 | GHSA-6A | 5 | 10-4 | 83.98 | 72.33 | 4 |
27 | Wake Forest | Wake Forest | N.C. | 4 | NCHSAA-4A | 3 | 15-1 | 83.89 | 54.39 | 272 |
28 | Brandon | Brandon | Miss. | 4 | MHSAA-6A | 4 | 12-2 | 83.63 | 65.47 | 41 |
29 | American Heritage | Plantation | Fla. | 5 | FHSAA-5A | 1 | 12-3 | 82.74 | 63.59 | 64 |
30 | Montgomery Bell Academy | Nashville | Tenn. | 5 | TSSAA-II-2A | 1 | 11-2 | 82.73 | 66.26 | 37 |
31 | American Heritage | Delray Beach | Fla. | 6 | FHSAA-3A | 2 | 11-2 | 82.51 | 55.63 | 235 |
32 | Milton | Milton | Ga. | 8 | GHSA-6A | 6 | 11-2 | 82.15 | 63.91 | 61 |
33 | Ensworth | Nashville | Tenn. | 6 | TSSAA-II-2A | 2 | 10-2 | 82.15 | 63.73 | 63 |
34 | Washington County | Sandersville | Ga. | 9 | GHSA-3A | 2 | 14-1 | 82.05 | 42.43 | 813 |
35 | Saraland | Saraland | Ala. | 3 | AHSAA-6A | 2 | 13-2 | 82.01 | 57.07 | 189 |
36 | Miramar | Miramar | Fla. | 7 | FHSAA-8A | 1 | 8-3 | 81.96 | 63.38 | 65 |
37 | Southaven | Southaven | Miss. | 5 | MHSAA-6A | 5 | 10-3 | 81.92 | 65.74 | 39 |
38 | Clinton | Clinton | Miss. | 6 | MHSAA-6A | 6 | 10-3 | 81.80 | 68.81 | 17 |
39 | Tucker | Tucker | Ga. | 10 | GHSA-6A | 7 | 10-3 | 81.67 | 58.93 | 138 |
40 | Lee County | Leesburg | Ga. | 11 | GHSA-6A | 8 | 8-3 | 81.52 | 67.19 | 29 |
41 | Mainland | Daytona Beach | Fla. | 8 | FHSAA-6A | 2 | 13-1 | 81.41 | 50.63 | 415 |
42 | Blackman | Murfreesboro | Tenn. | 7 | TSSAA-6A | 3 | 11-2 | 81.40 | 61.54 | 90 |
43 | Dorman | Roebuck | S.C. | 4 | SCHSL-4A | 4 | 10-3 | 81.35 | 64.25 | 56 |
44 | Spartanburg | Spartanburg | S.C. | 5 | SCHSL-4A | 5 | 12-3 | 81.18 | 60.53 | 113 |
45 | Mill Creek | Hoschton | Ga. | 12 | GHSA-6A | 9 | 7-4 | 81.17 | 67.97 | 20 |
46 | Independence | Charlotte | N.C. | 5 | NCHSAA-4A | 4 | 12-1 | 81.01 | 52.27 | 346 |
47 | Charlotte Catholic | Charlotte | N.C. | 6 | NCHSAA-4A | 5 | 14-2 | 80.98 | 62.32 | 79 |
48 | Ravenwood | Brentwood | Tenn. | 8 | TSSAA-6A | 4 | 15-2 | 80.87 | 53.31 | 304 |
49 | Northside | Warner Robins | Ga. | 13 | GHSA-5A | 1 | 14-1 | 80.60 | 57.17 | 187 |
50 | Blessed Trinity | Roswell | Ga. | 14 | GHSA-3A | 3 | 13-1 | 80.50 | 50.00 | 438 |
51 | St. Paul's Episcopal | Mobile | Ala. | 4 | AHSAA-5A | 1 | 16-0 | 80.43 | 49.38 | 462 |
52 | Armwood | Seffner | Fla. | 9 | FHSAA-6A | 3 | 15-1 | 80.28 | 47.61 | 532 |
53 | Oxford | Oxford | Miss. | 7 | MHSAA-5A | 1 | 13-2 | 79.87 | 54.68 | 264 |
54 | Havelock | Havelock | N.C. | 7 | NCHSAA-3A | 2 | 14-2 | 79.80 | 42.85 | 790 |
55 | Flanagan | Pembroke Pines | Fla. | 10 | FHSAA-8A | 2 | 12-1 | 79.76 | 47.92 | 514 |
56 | Christ Presbyterian Academy | Nashville | Tenn. | 9 | TSSAA-3A | 1 | 15-0 | 79.18 | 38.60 | 1013 |
57 | Allatoona | Acworth | Ga. | 15 | GHSA-5A | 2 | 14-1 | 79.03 | 58.31 | 152 |
58 | North Gwinnett | Suwanee | Ga. | 16 | GHSA-6A | 10 | 8-3 | 78.95 | 67.77 | 22 |
59 | Valdosta | Valdosta | Ga. | 17 | GHSA-6A | 11 | 9-2 | 78.79 | 64.73 | 48 |
60 | First Coast | Jacksonville | Fla. | 11 | FHSAA-8A | 3 | 12-1 | 78.69 | 58.51 | 147 |
61 | Opelika | Opelika | Ala. | 5 | AHSAA-6A | 3 | 9-2 | 78.66 | 60.79 | 108 |
62 | Goose Creek | Goose Creek | S.C. | 6 | SCHSL-4A | 6 | 10-2 | 78.65 | 60.26 | 115 |
63 | Brentwood Academy | Brentwood | Tenn. | 10 | TSSAA-II-2A | 3 | 8-3 | 78.28 | 69.84 | 12 |
64 | Union City | Union City | Tenn. | 11 | TSSAA-1A | 1 | 14-0 | 78.27 | 16.46 | 2010 |
65 | Central | Phenix City | Ala. | 6 | AHSAA-7A | 2 | 10-2 | 78.16 | 66.86 | 33 |
66 | Marist | Atlanta | Ga. | 18 | GHSA-4A | 2 | 11-2 | 77.84 | 53.29 | 305 |
67 | Apopka | Apopka | Fla. | 12 | FHSAA-8A | 4 | 11-4 | 77.78 | 61.34 | 94 |
68 | Dillon | Dillon | S.C. | 7 | SCHSL-2A | 1 | 16-0 | 77.65 | 40.76 | 904 |
69 | Spanish Fort | Spanish Fort | Ala. | 7 | AHSAA-6A | 4 | 12-2 | 77.62 | 57.82 | 170 |
70 | Peachtree Ridge | Suwanee | Ga. | 19 | GHSA-6A | 12 | 7-4 | 77.57 | 69.56 | 15 |
71 | Florence | Florence | Ala. | 8 | AHSAA-6A | 5 | 11-3 | 77.55 | 62.33 | 78 |
72 | Niceville | Niceville | Fla. | 13 | FHSAA-7A | 2 | 11-3 | 77.54 | 61.10 | 99 |
73 | Lake Norman | Mooresville | N.C. | 8 | NCHSAA-4A | 6 | 13-2 | 77.16 | 49.39 | 459 |
74 | Fairhope | Fairhope | Ala. | 9 | AHSAA-7A | 3 | 11-1 | 77.12 | 59.38 | 131 |
75 | Ware County | Waycross | Ga. | 20 | GHSA-5A | 3 | 11-1 | 77.04 | 51.48 | 377 |
76 | Prattville | Prattville | Ala. | 10 | AHSAA-7A | 4 | 11-3 | 77.03 | 64.09 | 58 |
77 | Benedictine | Savannah | Ga. | 21 | GHSA-2A | 1 | 13-2 | 77.00 | 44.33 | 693 |
78 | Hillsboro | Nashville | Tenn. | 12 | TSSAA-5A | 2 | 14-1 | 76.91 | 43.71 | 732 |
79 | Columbus | Miami | Fla. | 14 | FHSAA-8A | 5 | 13-2 | 76.72 | 52.85 | 320 |
80 | Tift County | Tifton | Ga. | 22 | GHSA-6A | 13 | 7-4 | 76.61 | 65.44 | 43 |
81 | Butler | Matthews | N.C. | 9 | NCHSAA-4A | 7 | 10-3 | 76.59 | 56.93 | 192 |
82 | Hough | Cornelius | N.C. | 10 | NCHSAA-4A | 8 | 10-4 | 76.37 | 64.40 | 52 |
83 | Wayne County | Waynesboro | Miss. | 8 | MHSAA-5A | 2 | 11-3 | 76.24 | 57.06 | 190 |
84 | Osceola | Kissimmee | Fla. | 15 | FHSAA-7A | 3 | 13-2 | 76.17 | 42.53 | 809 |
85 | Warren Central | Vicksburg | Miss. | 9 | MHSAA-6A | 7 | 9-3 | 76.02 | 57.86 | 168 |
86 | McCallie | Chattanooga | Tenn. | 13 | TSSAA-II-2A | 4 | 9-3 | 76.00 | 64.11 | 57 |
87 | Lowndes | Valdosta | Ga. | 23 | GHSA-6A | 14 | 6-4 | 75.97 | 72.33 | 5 |
88 | Science Hill | Johnson City | Tenn. | 14 | TSSAA-6A | 5 | 11-2 | 75.95 | 52.48 | 334 |
89 | Cartersville | Cartersville | Ga. | 24 | GHSA-4A | 3 | 12-2 | 75.89 | 47.44 | 545 |
90 | Northwestern | Rock Hill | S.C. | 8 | SCHSL-4A | 7 | 9-4 | 75.87 | 66.40 | 36 |
91 | Scotland | Laurinburg | N.C. | 11 | NCHSAA-4A | 9 | 12-2 | 75.79 | 54.29 | 275 |
92 | Etowah | Woodstock | Ga. | 25 | GHSA-6A | 15 | 12-3 | 75.64 | 61.12 | 98 |
93 | Hillgrove | Powder Springs | Ga. | 26 | GHSA-6A | 16 | 9-4 | 75.62 | 65.30 | 46 |
94 | Bolles | Jacksonville | Fla. | 16 | FHSAA-4A | 2 | 11-3 | 75.52 | 51.33 | 386 |
95 | Rhea County | Evensville | Tenn. | 15 | TSSAA-5A | 3 | 13-1 | 75.50 | 37.48 | 1078 |
96 | Mays | Atlanta | Ga. | 27 | GHSA-5A | 4 | 12-3 | 75.45 | 60.06 | 120 |
97 | Northern Guilford | Greensboro | N.C. | 12 | NCHSAA-3A | 3 | 15-1 | 75.41 | 48.41 | 498 |
98 | Greater Atlanta Christian | Norcross | Ga. | 28 | GHSA-2A | 2 | 14-1 | 75.26 | 50.67 | 412 |
99 | Godby | Tallahassee | Fla. | 17 | FHSAA-5A | 2 | 12-3 | 75.17 | 56.22 | 215 |
100 | Trezevant | Memphis | Tenn. | 16 | TSSAA-4A | 2 | 13-2 | 74.89 | 25.20 | 1698 |
101 | Laurel | Laurel | Miss. | 10 | MHSAA-5A | 3 | 13-2 | 74.88 | 51.49 | 376 |
102 | West Orange | Winter Garden | Fla. | 18 | FHSAA-8A | 6 | 11-1 | 74.77 | 43.81 | 726 |
103 | Fyffe | Fyffe | Ala. | 11 | AHSAA-2A | 1 | 16-0 | 74.72 | 21.37 | 1841 |
104 | Fort Dorchester | North Charleston | S.C. | 9 | SCHSL-4A | 8 | 11-3 | 74.72 | 62.41 | 75 |
105 | Lake Mary | Lake Mary | Fla. | 19 | FHSAA-8A | 7 | 11-1 | 74.63 | 55.80 | 228 |
106 | Langston Hughes | Fairburn | Ga. | 29 | GHSA-6A | 17 | 9-4 | 74.27 | 63.33 | 66 |
107 | Jefferson | Jefferson | Ga. | 30 | GHSA-3A | 4 | 12-1 | 74.10 | 42.76 | 792 |
108 | Richmond | Rockingham | N.C. | 13 | NCHSAA-4A | 10 | 11-2 | 73.89 | 56.67 | 201 |
109 | Hoggard | Wilmington | N.C. | 14 | NCHSAA-4A | 11 | 13-2 | 73.45 | 42.95 | 787 |
110 | Westlake | Atlanta | Ga. | 31 | GHSA-6A | 18 | 10-2 | 73.45 | 50.50 | 418 |
111 | Leeds | Leeds | Ala. | 12 | AHSAA-4A | 1 | 16-1 | 73.35 | 47.18 | 558 |
112 | East Lake | Tarpon Springs | Fla. | 20 | FHSAA-7A | 4 | 13-1 | 73.27 | 44.70 | 677 |
113 | Lovejoy | Lovejoy | Ga. | 32 | GHSA-6A | 19 | 7-4 | 73.23 | 64.35 | 55 |
114 | Vance | Charlotte | N.C. | 15 | NCHSAA-4A | 12 | 11-4 | 73.17 | 56.61 | 204 |
115 | Noxubee County | Macon | Miss. | 11 | MHSAA-4A | 1 | 14-2 | 73.05 | 49.31 | 464 |
116 | North Cobb | Kennesaw | Ga. | 33 | GHSA-6A | 20 | 7-4 | 73.00 | 67.61 | 26 |
117 | Cocoa | Cocoa | Fla. | 21 | FHSAA-4A | 3 | 11-2 | 72.96 | 31.94 | 1375 |
118 | Alcoa | Alcoa | Tenn. | 17 | TSSAA-3A | 2 | 13-2 | 72.92 | 44.57 | 684 |
119 | St. Pius X Catholic | Atlanta | Ga. | 34 | GHSA-4A | 4 | 12-3 | 72.92 | 52.86 | 319 |
120 | Westminster | Atlanta | Ga. | 35 | GHSA-3A | 5 | 12-2 | 72.85 | 48.62 | 490 |
121 | Garner Magnet | Garner | N.C. | 16 | NCHSAA-4A | 13 | 13-2 | 72.78 | 47.70 | 529 |
122 | Ocean Springs | Ocean Springs | Miss. | 12 | MHSAA-6A | 8 | 11-2 | 72.70 | 60.78 | 109 |
123 | Southern | Durham | N.C. | 17 | NCHSAA-3A | 4 | 13-1 | 72.69 | 51.41 | 381 |
124 | Camden County | Kingsland | Ga. | 36 | GHSA-6A | 21 | 5-5 | 72.57 | 69.12 | 16 |
125 | Knoxville Catholic | Knoxville | Tenn. | 18 | TSSAA-4A | 3 | 10-2 | 72.49 | 52.18 | 347 |
126 | Norcross | Norcross | Ga. | 37 | GHSA-6A | 22 | 7-4 | 72.45 | 68.75 | 18 |
127 | Sandy Creek | Tyrone | Ga. | 38 | GHSA-4A | 5 | 10-2 | 72.44 | 59.41 | 130 |
128 | Dr. Phillips | Orlando | Fla. | 22 | FHSAA-8A | 8 | 12-1 | 72.40 | 47.79 | 523 |
129 | Greenwood | Greenwood | S.C. | 10 | SCHSL-4A | 9 | 9-5 | 72.39 | 64.71 | 49 |
130 | Baylor | Chattanooga | Tenn. | 19 | TSSAA-II-2A | 5 | 8-5 | 72.28 | 66.69 | 34 |
131 | York | York | S.C. | 11 | SCHSL-4A | 10 | 12-3 | 72.18 | 61.01 | 103 |
132 | Dudley | Greensboro | N.C. | 18 | NCHSAA-4A | 14 | 9-0 | 71.96 | 38.40 | 1021 |
133 | Vidalia | Vidalia | Ga. | 39 | GHSA-2A | 3 | 12-1 | 71.88 | 33.17 | 1307 |
134 | Hallandale | Hallandale | Fla. | 23 | FHSAA-6A | 4 | 10-2 | 71.85 | 49.91 | 440 |
135 | Meridian | Meridian | Miss. | 13 | MHSAA-6A | 9 | 7-5 | 71.55 | 63.83 | 62 |
136 | Choctawhatchee | Fort Walton Beach | Fla. | 24 | FHSAA-6A | 5 | 11-3 | 71.46 | 54.79 | 257 |
137 | South-Doyle | Knoxville | Tenn. | 20 | TSSAA-5A | 4 | 12-1 | 71.45 | 42.93 | 788 |
138 | Central Gwinnett | Lawrenceville | Ga. | 40 | GHSA-6A | 23 | 7-5 | 71.42 | 67.80 | 21 |
139 | Baker | Mobile | Ala. | 13 | AHSAA-7A | 5 | 9-2 | 71.38 | 57.65 | 174 |
140 | West Point | West Point | Miss. | 14 | MHSAA-5A | 4 | 9-5 | 71.30 | 63.25 | 69 |
141 | Riverdale | Murfreesboro | Tenn. | 21 | TSSAA-6A | 6 | 9-3 | 71.18 | 58.72 | 142 |
142 | Benjamin Russell | Alexander City | Ala. | 14 | AHSAA-6A | 6 | 10-2 | 71.09 | 55.16 | 248 |
143 | Oak Mountain | Birmingham | Ala. | 15 | AHSAA-7A | 6 | 10-2 | 71.06 | 60.06 | 121 |
144 | Mooresville | Mooresville | N.C. | 19 | NCHSAA-4A | 15 | 10-2 | 71.04 | 45.37 | 634 |
145 | Westwood | Blythewood | S.C. | 12 | SCHSL-4A | 11 | 12-2 | 70.96 | 52.35 | 343 |
146 | Woodward Academy | College Park | Ga. | 41 | GHSA-4A | 6 | 11-3 | 70.93 | 55.75 | 231 |
147 | Reagan | Pfafftown | N.C. | 20 | NCHSAA-4A | 16 | 12-2 | 70.86 | 52.38 | 341 |
148 | Gadsden City | Gadsden | Ala. | 16 | AHSAA-7A | 7 | 10-3 | 70.82 | 59.02 | 137 |
149 | Stockbridge | Stockbridge | Ga. | 42 | GHSA-5A | 5 | 11-3 | 70.81 | 53.28 | 306 |
150 | Mount Paran Christian | Kennesaw | Ga. | 43 | GHSA-1A | 1 | 14-0 | 70.64 | 34.51 | 1232 |
About the Author