How We Ranked
We take our responsibility to readers seriously. When we recommend a restaurant, we’re asking you to trust us with your time and money. Sometimes it’s a quick $20 dinner. Other times, it’s a special occasion you’ve been looking forward to for months, and you’re spending several hundred dollars.
Either way, you deserve good food, thoughtful service and a restaurant that genuinely cares about your experience.
I’ve worked in hospitality since the 1990s. My mother owned a restaurant in Roswell. I know firsthand how hard this business is, and I have enormous respect for the people who do it. But when we’re deciding which restaurants belong on the ATL50, our first responsibility is to the readers who trust us to get it right.
Here’s how we put together this year’s ATL50:
What makes a restaurant eligible for ATL50?
To be eligible, establishments must be places where food is the main reason people visit and where diners can have a complete meal. They don’t need table service, a permanent storefront or a bar to be considered.
Food trucks, counter-service restaurants, bars with substantial food menus, recurring chef-driven pop-ups and individual food hall vendors are all eligible, along with traditional full-service restaurants.
To qualify, a business has to operate at least three days a week. We didn’t include places focused primarily on drinks or desserts, food sold at supermarkets, or one-time food events.
Who judged ATL50?
This year, Henri Hollis and I expanded our judging panel from two people to 12. We brought in chefs, restaurant critics, journalists, and food experts who know Atlanta’s dining scene and who have different perspectives on what makes it great.
Learn more about them here.
Who nominated restaurants for ATL50?
We asked each expert panelist to nominate 20 eligible restaurants that they considered to be the best of the best. For the first time, we also asked readers to nominate restaurants, because nobody knows a neighborhood quite like the people who live there.
A nomination from readers or expert panelists didn’t guarantee a visit or a place on the list. But it helped us find places we might otherwise have missed. Nearly 300 restaurants were nominated.
How did we narrow the list of 300 restaurants?
Of the 300 nominated restaurants, only a little over 100 received multiple nominations.
We shared that list with our expert panel and asked them to look past reputations, social media buzz and awards to find the restaurants that were still delivering the best food in the city.
We refused to grade Atlanta on a curve. Could these restaurants hold their own in Chicago, New York or Los Angeles? Restaurants that were simply “good by Atlanta standards” were removed from consideration.
When more than three panelists reported disappointing experiences over more than one visit at a nominated restaurant, that establishment was also removed from consideration.
A restaurant needed at least three panelists to vote for it to make it into our top 75. Those 75 all received formal evaluations. Each restaurant got two anonymous visits from judges.
How did we evaluate restaurants?
We asked our judges to evaluate each restaurant on what it was trying to accomplish. A taqueria shouldn’t have to offer the same experience as a white-tablecloth restaurant to make it on the list. But both should deliver on the experience they promise.
Each visit was scored in four categories, using a weighted 100-point scale.
Food: 50% of the score
We looked at flavor, ingredient quality, technique and consistency in food preparation.
Service: 30% of the score
Was the staff welcoming and knowledgeable? Were orders correct and did they arrive in a timely manner? When something went wrong, how did the restaurant handle it?
Menu: 10% of the score
We looked for a focused menu with a clear point of view. We tried as many dishes as our budget allowed to get a good sense of what each kitchen was doing. When they also offered a beverage menu, we ordered cocktails and other drinks to see how well they complemented the food.
Value: 10% of the score
A cheap meal isn’t necessarily a good value, and an expensive one isn’t necessarily a bad value. We asked a simple question: Would we happily come back and spend that money again?
Judges scored only on what happened during their visits. We asked them to put aside a restaurant’s reputation, awards, press coverage, social media following and their own previous experiences. What mattered was the meal in front of them and how they were treated.
How did beverages factor into the judging?
This year, we stopped scoring beverages as a separate category, since a restaurant shouldn’t need a liquor license, an extensive wine list or a cocktail program to be considered one of Atlanta’s best. But that doesn’t mean we stopped evaluating beverages.
At restaurants with dedicated beverage programs, we had wine, cocktails and non-alcoholic drinks as part of our evaluations. A thoughtful cocktail program could strengthen a restaurant’s scores. But a restaurant without one wasn’t at a disadvantage.
How did we choose the final 50?
We averaged the scores from the expert panelists to determine which restaurants made ATL50 and where they ranked.
Surprisingly, some of Atlanta’s top restaurants did not deliver the same quality experience from one visit to the next. Their scores reflected that and they didn’t average high enough to make the list.
The competition was fierce. Fewer than 10 points separated restaurant No. 1 from No. 50. The highest average was 95.175, and the lowest was 86.06.
Every restaurant on this list earned its place through the incredibly high scores it received from multiple judges over multiple visits. We hope that when you sit down at one of their tables, you’ll be as blown away as we were.
What does the pricing code mean?
- $$$$ - $176+ per person
- $$$ - $76-$175 per person
- $$ - $26-$75 per person
- $ - less than $25 per person
Cost excludes drink, tax and tip



