Early last week, Braves general manager responded to an emailed question by writing: "We're searching for catching every day." By week's end, we were reminded why. The Braves lost their first two games after the All-Star break on nights that saw them deliver eight wild pitches (with a passed ball interspersed) and Saturday's winning run arrive via a bounced Erick Aybar throw that A.J. Pierzynski, yet again, couldn't handle.

Which, you’ll recall, is how this forlorn season began: Aybar being awful, Pierzynski being awful, too. Difference is, the Braves have a shortstop replacement en route. For Pierzynski, there’s nada.

We stipulate that Pierzynski was never viewed as anything more than a stopgap in case Christian Bethancourt didn't pan out, about which more later. The Braves got an acceptable season from the retread in 2015 (1.6 WAR value); they've gotten an abomination (minus-1.8 WAR) this time. When Tyler Flowers was lost for a month to a broken hand, it became A.J. or bust. Bust it is.

About the Author

Keep Reading

The Atlanta Braves pitcher declined the club option on reliever Pierce Johnson along with reliever Tyler Kinley. (Arvin Temkar/AJC)

Credit: arvin.temkar@ajc.com

Featured

Travelers walk around the baggage claim in the South Terminal at Hartsfield-Jackson Atlanta International Airport on Thursday, Nov. 6, 2025. Atlanta is among the airports where the FAA will reduce flights due to the shutdown, and airports are facing a shortage of air traffic controllers. 
(Miguel Martinez/ AJC)

Credit: Miguel Martinez-Jimenez