Judge seeks info on Georgia investigations of counterfeit ballots

09/20/2021 — McDonough, Georgia — Superior Court Judge Brian Amero presents to the defendant and the plaintiffs attorneys during a hearing on the motion to dismiss the case of the review of Fulton County elections ballots to determine fraud at the Henry County Courthouse in McDonough, Monday, September 20, 2021.  Judge Amero asked Georgia election investigators and the GBI to provide an update about any investigations into allegations of counterfeit ballots in last year’s presidential election.  (Alyssa Pointer/Atlanta Journal Constitution)

Credit: Alyssa Pointer

Combined ShapeCaption
09/20/2021 — McDonough, Georgia — Superior Court Judge Brian Amero presents to the defendant and the plaintiffs attorneys during a hearing on the motion to dismiss the case of the review of Fulton County elections ballots to determine fraud at the Henry County Courthouse in McDonough, Monday, September 20, 2021. Judge Amero asked Georgia election investigators and the GBI to provide an update about any investigations into allegations of counterfeit ballots in last year’s presidential election. (Alyssa Pointer/Atlanta Journal Constitution)

Credit: Alyssa Pointer

McDONOUGH — A judge on Monday asked Georgia election investigators and the GBI to provide an update about any investigations into allegations involving the casting of counterfeit ballots in last year’s presidential election.

Superior Court Judge Brian Amero’s request came during a hearing on a lawsuit seeking to inspect about 147,000 absentee ballots cast in Fulton County in an effort to find fraud.

State election officials have said there’s no indication of fraud after three ballot counts and multiple investigations. Democrat Joe Biden defeated Republican incumbent Donald Trump in Georgia’s presidential election by about 12,000 votes.

“It is important to me that we know whether or not counterfeit ballots have been introduced into the mix,” Amero said in court.

The lawsuit is based on sworn statements by two Republican election auditors who alleged there were “pristine” ballots with perfectly filled-in ovals during an audit in November. Two other Republican ballot counters claimed some absentee ballots lacked creases from folding ballots into envelopes.

The secretary of state’s office has said that investigators reviewed those ballot batches but found no signs of counterfeits or irregularities. A monitor installed in the county before the election reported sloppy ballot handling procedures, but not fraud.

Amero put the lawsuit on hold for 20 days to give the secretary of state’s office and GBI time to respond.

Amero previously dismissed the case against Fulton’s elections board and the county itself, but he allowed the lawsuit to continue against individual members of the elections board.

Combined ShapeCaption
09/20/2021 — McDonough, Georgia — Garland Favorito, right, speaks with his attorney, Todd Harding, during a hearing Monday in McDonough weighing a motion to dismiss his lawsuit seeking to examine some 147,000 absentee ballots cast in Fulton County during November's presidential election. "We the people of Georgia want to see the ballots for our own selves in front of the cameras so everyone can decide: yes they’re counterfeit or no they’re not," Favorito said. (Alyssa Pointer/Atlanta Journal Constitution)

Credit: Alyssa Pointer

09/20/2021 — McDonough, Georgia —  Garland Favorito, right, speaks with his attorney, Todd Harding, during a hearing Monday in McDonough weighing a motion to dismiss his lawsuit seeking to examine some 147,000 absentee ballots cast in Fulton County during November's presidential election. "We the people of Georgia want to see the ballots for our own selves in front of the cameras so everyone can decide: yes they’re counterfeit or no they’re not," Favorito said. (Alyssa Pointer/Atlanta Journal Constitution)

Credit: Alyssa Pointer

Combined ShapeCaption
09/20/2021 — McDonough, Georgia — Garland Favorito, right, speaks with his attorney, Todd Harding, during a hearing Monday in McDonough weighing a motion to dismiss his lawsuit seeking to examine some 147,000 absentee ballots cast in Fulton County during November's presidential election. "We the people of Georgia want to see the ballots for our own selves in front of the cameras so everyone can decide: yes they’re counterfeit or no they’re not," Favorito said. (Alyssa Pointer/Atlanta Journal Constitution)

Credit: Alyssa Pointer

Credit: Alyssa Pointer

The lead plaintiff in the case, Garland Favorito of the organization Voter GA, said the judge’s request for more information stalls his effort to conduct a public inspection of absentee ballots cast in Fulton, where Biden won 73% of the vote over Trump.

“What we want to do is look at the ballots and see whether they’re counterfeit,” Favorito said after the court hearing. “We don’t want some organization, claiming election official authorities, to tell us what these ballots are. We the people of Georgia want to see the ballots for our own selves in front of the cameras so everyone can decide: yes they’re counterfeit or no they’re not.”

There are several reasons why absentee ballots might not have creases or appear to be filled in perfectly.

Election officials must duplicate ballots if they can’t be scanned, either because they were damaged in the mail or when opened by poll workers. Ballots printed by military and overseas voters, and then mailed back to Georgia, also need to be duplicated to be read by scanners.

Though Georgia law keeps original paper ballots under seal, the state’s new voting law requires that digital ballot images be made public.

No counterfeit ballots have been found, but the ballot images did show that some ballots were scanned twice during the initial ballot count. After a recount, official results showed that Trump gained a total of 121 absentee votes in Fulton.

Because state investigations of Fulton’s elections remain open, it’s unclear how much information Republican Secretary of State Brad Raffensperger’s office will be able to disclose until those inquiries are completed. An attorney for the state told the judge the secretary of state’s office has already looked into claims about ballot batches cited in the lawsuit.

Don Samuel, an attorney for three former and current Democrats on Fulton’s elections board, said the case should be dismissed, but he didn’t object to the judge seeking more information about investigations.