The Georgia Supreme Court Tuesday reversed the murder conviction against Steven Lamar Scott, saying a DeKalb County judge improperly excluded evidence in the case.

Scott was convicted of fatally shooting Dan Smith in 2008 after, Scott said, his niece told him  Smith was molesting her. The high court said the trial judge should have allowed evidence of the alleged molestation to support a charge of voluntary manslaughter, which carries a lesser penalty than murder and is committed as a result of sudden, violent and irresistible passion.

About the Author

Featured

Fulton DA Fani Willis (center) with Nathan J. Wade (right), the special prosecutor she hired to manage the Trump case and had a romantic relationship with, at a news conference announcing charges against President-elect Donald Trump and others in Atlanta, Aug. 14, 2023. Georgia’s Supreme Court on Tuesday, Sept. 16, 2025, upheld an appeals court's decision to disqualify Willis from the election interference case against Trump and his allies. (Kenny Holston/New York Times)

Credit: NYT