“This is a nightmare. It’s a complete nightmare,” Smith’s daughter, Lisa Stitley, said. “I can’t even begin to imagine. I keep thinking I’m going to wake up.”
Stitley said even though her father lived in Gwinnett County, he made the trip daily from his Lilburn home to see her and other family members in Cobb. From there, Smith would sometimes make the trip to Villa Rica to see his 39-year-old girlfriend, Stitley said.
“He was very young at heart,” Stitley said, “and was in extremely good health for his age.”
Stitley last saw her father last Thursday morning, she said. Smith said he planned to visit his grandson before driving to Villa Rica, but never made it out of Cobb. He had a cell phone, but it wasn’t working Thursday, possibly due to a late payment, Stitley said.
Outside the Mableton home where Collins and Cook lived, the two allegedly assaulted Smith as he sat inside his parked truck, warrants state.
“Cook stabbed Smith twice in the chest with a knife while Collins used a belt to choke Smith,” the warrants state. “After Smith was dead, Collins removed Smith’s wallet from Smith’s pocket.”
Investigators believe Collins and Cook then drove around metro Atlanta and went shopping, all while Smith’s body was concealed in his truck, according to police.
For several days, Smith’s family worried endlessly about him.
“They were upset,” said Tammy Smith Connor said, Casey Collins’ mother. “They acted just like they were worried, just like we were.”
On Sunday, Stitley reported to Cobb police that her father was missing. Two days later, police made the gruesome discovery of the man’s body inside his truck left in south Cobb.
Smith’s daughters said that other than stealing the older man’s money, they can’t imagine what motive the two would have had.
“My dad had been good to both of them,” Tammy Smith Connor said. “He always went the extra mile with family.”
Funeral arrangements for Smith have not yet been finalized.