The 2010 fatal shooting of Rusty Sneiderman, a 36-year-old father who had just dropped off his toddler at a Dunwoody day care center, shocked those who followed the investigation and the ensuing court battle, which dragged on for years.

Sneiderman was an unlikely victim: A certified public accountant with an MBA from Harvard University.

His wife, Andrea Sneiderman, was initially accused of arranging the entrepreneur’s killing, but murder charges against her were eventually dropped. She was later convicted on charges for impeding the investigation. Hemy Neuman, her former boss and alleged affair partner, got life without parole in prison for the killing after a retrial.

Friday’s new “20/20″ episode, called “Fatal Disguise,” will feature the case and will air at 9 p.m. on ABC.

The investigation included stunning revelations as more evidence came to light: Neuman had apparently worn a fake beard when he shot Rusty Sneiderman outside of the child care center. And although police believed from the start that Rusty Sneiderman had been specifically targeted because of the brazen manner in which he was killed, many speculated that the murder was a professional hit.

Andrea Sneiderman, who later legally changed her name, has denied any involvement in her husband’s death. She was convicted of lying to investigators about the affair with Neuman and spent nine months in prison.

Andrea and Rusty Sneiderman shown in an undated photo released by Andrea on Tuesday following the conviction of Hemy Neuman in the retrial on Rusty's death.
icon to expand image

Neuman admitted to killing Rusty Sneiderman but claimed he was delusional, motivated by his longing for Andrea Sneiderman. The first jury found Neuman guilty but mentally ill. In a second trial, the jury rejected the claim that mental illness drove him to commit murder.

Neuman’s initial conviction was overturned by the Georgia Supreme Court in 2015, due to an attorney-client privilege issue.

Neuman immigrated to the U.S. in 1980, and graduated with honors from Georgia Tech in 1984. He had been Andrea Sneiderman’s boss at GE Energy.

About the Author

Keep Reading

Grady Memorial Hospital is accused of negligence by the family of a 73-year-old patient who told police she was sexually assaulted in her hospital bed by a male nurse in October 2024. (Natrice Miller / AJC)

Credit: Natrice Miller / Natrice.Miller@ajc.com

Featured

Healthcare at College Park, a nursing home in Fulton County, GA, stands shuttered with its door chained on July 26, 2025, having closed in recent months.  Researchers at Brown University developed a list of U.S. nursing homes they predicted were at risk of closing based on 2023 data, and would be at elevated risk of closing due to the One Big, Beautiful Bill Act's cuts to Medicaid. Healthcare at College Park was on their list.  It survived past its last federal inspection in August of 2024 but has now closed down. The bill's biggest provisions will roll out over years starting Jan. 1. (Ariel Hart/AJC)

Credit: Ariel Hart