Sports

Braves' deal for Trevor Cahill illustrates concerns about rotation

Arizona Diamondbacks starting pitcher Trevor Cahill, right, throws to Milwaukee Brewers' Scooter Gennett during the second inning of a spring training baseball exhibition game in Phoenix, on Friday, March 20, 2015. (AP Photo/Chris Carlson) Trevor Cahill gives Braves a right-handed starter but he struggled with Arizona. (AP photo)
Arizona Diamondbacks starting pitcher Trevor Cahill, right, throws to Milwaukee Brewers' Scooter Gennett during the second inning of a spring training baseball exhibition game in Phoenix, on Friday, March 20, 2015. (AP Photo/Chris Carlson) Trevor Cahill gives Braves a right-handed starter but he struggled with Arizona. (AP photo)
By Jeff Schultz
April 2, 2015

The narrative for the Braves going into this season is that their pitching will be fine and their offense will be challenged -- and there's no reason to believe that won't be the case.

But it says something that the Braves just made a trade for a starting pitcher who went 3-13 with a 5.61 ERA last season and the team views it as a gain. President of baseball operations John Hart acquired the struggling Trevor Cahill from Arizona for minor league outfielder Josh Elander.

The Diamondbacks were so eager to get rid of Cahill that they will pay $6.5 million of Cahill's $12 million salary.

The Braves were so eager to add Cahill that they were willing to pay $5.5 million for a pitcher who has a career ERA of 4.07, struggled with a hip injury last season and didn't make it through five innings in seven of his 17 starts.

But assistant general manager John Coppolella told our David O'Brien , "

Bottom line: They needed help, especially with Mike Minor starting the season on the disabled list with inflammation in his shoulder (again). They also needed a right-hander. For as much as pitching is this team's strength, things fall apart pretty quickly in the starting rotation after the top three. That assumes No. 3 Shelby Miller will have a solid year after some control issues last year in St. Louis.

Here's the likely rotation:

No. 1: Julio Teheran (24 years old, RH): He eased any concerns that may have existed before last season that he was ready to make the leap to staff ace, with a career-low 2.89 ERA and a 186 strikeouts (51 walks) in 221 1/3 innings, and an All-Star Game appearance.

No. 2: Alex Wood (24, LH): He exceeded expectations in his first full season, with a 2.78 ERA and 170 strikeouts (45 walks) in 171 2/3 innings. There's no reason to think he'll take a step back but he wouldn't be the first young pitcher to go through some early struggles.

No. 3: Shelby Miller (24, RH): He came to the Braves in the Jason Heyward trade and could be a solid third man. But he struggled with his control last season, particularly in the first three months.

No. 4 or 5: Wandy Rodriguez (36, LH) or Eric Stults (35, LH): Both were non-roster invitees. The bar is low.

No. 4 or 5: Cahill (27, RH): He consumed a lot of innings in his last two years in Oakland (196 2/3, 207 2/3) and his first in Arizona (200). But that hasn't been the case the last two seasons (146 2/3, 110 2/3).

The starting pitching needs to be there because there's a good chance the run-scoring won't be.

•

Some recent ramblings from the digital jukebox
-- MyAJC: Real news would be Tiger Woods making shots
-- AJC: Tiger Woods' plane in Augusta but status for Masters still uncertain
-- AJC: Are Braves really second-worst team in majors (thank you, Philly)?
-- AJC: Falcons will pay appropriate penalties for dumb decision
-- MyAJC: Paul Millsap: The 6-8 kid who couldn't dunk now leading Hawks
-- AJC: Hawks clinch East, act like it's no big deal (which is probably good)
-- MyAJC: NBA needs to curtail resting of players
-- AJC: Will Falcons, others avoid losing draft picks this year?
-- MyAJC: Basketball is where Georgia State's focus should be
-- AJC: New reality at Georgia State: What Ron Hunter wants, he gets
-- MyAJC: Hawks get drilled, and concerns may be growing
-- MyAJC: Georgia better but still not where it needs to be
-- AJC: Mark Fox returns subtle fire at Brian Gregory before tournament
-- MyAJC: Gregory knows he needs to make most of his extended lifeline
-- AJC: Gregory says he gave Izzo 'everything' he has on Georgia
-- AJC: Timing is everything, as Tech keeps Gregory
-- AJC: Tech expected to keep Gregory, but former coach (Hewitt) fired again
-- MyAJC: Column on Quinn, Dimitroff defending moves, philosophy
-- AJC: Exclusive: Q&A with Quinn, Dimitroff on Falcons' moves
-- MyAJC: Tech's candidate pool may be thin if Gregory fired
-- AJC: Tech's decision on Brian Gregory tougher than you might think
-- MyAJC: Georgia erratic but ceiling high in tournament
-- AJC: NCAA tourney: Dogs should be in, Panthers must do a little more
-- MyAJC: Georgia State at center of state's hoops' rebirth

About the Author

Jeff Schultz

More Stories