A wanted man started to turn himself in at the Gwinnett County Sheriff’s Office on Monday, but suddenly had second thoughts.

Aaron Botteicher, charged with probation violation, theft by deception and shoplifting, had come to the lobby of the Gwinnett County jail to turn himself in. While doing so, he changed his mind and ran out the door.

The desk deputy shouted for assistance chasing down the suspect just as Chief Mike Boyd and three other sheriff’s deputies were exiting an elevator. The four men chased down and caught the suspect, who was then taken into custody.

“We hope that the suspect continues his newly formed habit of making wiser choices,” the Sheriff’s Office wrote in a Facebook post.

Botteicher was charged with shoplifting after he took a ring from a Norcross pawn shop and sold it at another pawn shop on the same street. The Gwinnett County Police Department could not find a record of the theft by deception charge, though the sheriff’s office said the theft by deception charge had originated with the police department.

Botteicher is currently being held on $8,650 combined bond — $5,700 for the shoplifting charge and $2,950 for the theft by deception charge.

Like Gwinnett County News on Facebook | Follow us on Twitter and Instagram

About the Author

Keep Reading

Sandy Springs officers responded to a police shooting in the area of Roswell Road and Dunwoody Place on Thursday. (Ben Hendren for the AJC)

Credit: Ben Hendren

Featured

Managing Partner at Atlantica Properties, Darion Dunn (center) talks with Atlanta Mayor Andre Dickens during a tour following the ribbon cutting of Waterworks Village as part of the third phase of the city’s Rapid Housing Initiative on Wednesday, Dec. 3, 2025.
(Miguel Martinez/AJC)

Credit: Miguel Martinez-Jimenez