Now for the top three.
» RELATED: 7 places to try soft serve ice cream in metro Atlanta
Jeni's Splendid Ice Cream, which has multiple locations and sells pints in Publix stores, came in third after garnering 12% of votes. Butter & Cream, which has locations on the Atlanta Beltline and in Decatur, landed just shy of the top spot it held last year. It came in second place after receiving 21% of votes.
So which shop earned the title as the best ice cream in metro Atlanta?
That goes to Berens Frozen Custard in Grayson. The spot has been an Atlanta staple for more than 40 years and it garnered 41% of votes to become the winner.