Do you believe in unlikelihoods? Coincidences?

It has become a well-covered Super Bowl prognosticator: how Nick Saban does in title games affects the fortunes of his mentor, Bill Belichick.

Saban was the defensive coordinator to Belichick’s Cleveland Browns teams from 1991-94.

Since Saban’s arrival in Tuscaloosa in 2007, whenever the Crimson Tide have played in a semifinal or national championship game AND LOST, the New England Patriots have won the Super Bowl a few weeks later.

As you may recall, Alabama was trounced by Clemson in the College Football Playoffs Championship Game earlier this month.

The Patriots face the Los Angeles Rams in Super Bowl 53 Feb. 3 at Atlanta's Mercedes-Benz Stadium.

This is how things have played out:

2009-10 

• Alabama: Wins BCS National Championship game, 37-21, vs. Texas Longhorns
• New England: Loses Wild Card game, 33-14, to the Baltimore Ravens

2011-12 

• Alabama: Wins BCS National Championship game, 21-0, vs. LSU Tigers 
• New England: Loses Super Bowl, 21-17, to the N.Y. Giants

2012-13 

• Alabama: Wins BCS National Championship game, 42-14,  vs. Notre Dame Fighting Irish
• New England: Loses the AFC championship game, 28-13, to the Ravens

2014-15 

• Alabama: Loses the College Football Playoff semifinal (Sugar Bowl), 42-35, to Ohio State Bukeyes
• New England: Wins the Super Bowl, 28-24, vs. the Seattle Seahawks

2015-16 

• Alabama: Wins the College Football Playoff National Championship game, 45-40, vs. Clemson 
• New England: Loses AFC championship game, 20-18, to the Denver Broncos

2016-17 

• Alabama: Loses the College Football Playoff National Championship game, 35-31, to Clemson 
• New England: Wins Super Bowl, 34-28, vs. the Atlanta Falcons

2017-18 

• Alabama: Wins College Football Playoff National Championship game, 26-23 (OT), vs. Georgia Bulldogs 
• New England: Loses Super Bowl, 41-33, to the Philadelphia Eagles

2018-19 

• Alabama: Loses College Football Playoff National Championship game, 44-16, to Clemson 
• New England: ???

About the Author

Keep Reading

Malachi Washington, who participated in Saturday’s High School Home Run Derby at Truist Park, jumped at the opportunity to participate in the event after receiving an email from MLB. (Jason Getz/AJC)

Credit: Jason Getz / Jason.Getz@ajc.com

Featured

Braves first baseman Matt Olson (left) is greeted by Ronald Acuña Jr. after batting during the MLB Home Run Derby as part of the All-Star Game festivities on Monday, July 14, 2025, at Truist Park in Atlanta. (Jason Getz/AJC)

Credit: Jason Getz/AJC