Atlanta United was stymied for at least the third time late Thursday night in its pursuit to sign a starting centerback.

Journalist CL Merlo reported Thursday night that Alan Franco will be sold by Independiente for $4 million to Sao Paulo in Brazil, instead of to Atlanta United, which reportedly agreed to purchase the 24-year-old for $2.8 million.

Losing Franco follows the missed acquisitions of Lautaro Giannetti, who failed a physical and returned to Velez Sarsfield, and Hector David Martinez, who moved to River Plate.

That Atlanta United couldn’t finalize the negotiations with Independiente isn’t surprising because the two clubs have had prolonged negotiations before. Ezequiel Barco, signed before the 2018 season, once said he had to force his move from Independiente to Atlanta United because the Argentinian club reportedly would agree to terms on the sale and then change the terms.

Atlanta United’s centerback pool includes Miles Robinson, one of the better centerbacks in MLS; Anton Walkes, who can play across the back line; Alex De John, signed for depth; and two Homegrowns in George Campbell and Efrain Morales.

The team will open its season April 6 at Alajuelense in the Champions League.

About the Author

Keep Reading

Atlanta United goalkeeper Brad Guzan announced his retirement on Tuesday. A team captain since 2019, Guzan has a franchise-high 303 appearances and 645 saves. (Curtis Compton/AJC)

Credit: ccompton@ajc.com

Featured

Mathew Palmer, a former Delta Air Lines employee, at his home in Atlanta on Thursday, Oct. 9, 2025.  Palmer was fired less than two weeks after writing a post on social media about the assassination of conservative activist Charlie Kirk. (Natrice Miller/AJC)