An Atlanta man has come forward with allegations that he survived a 1976 encounter with Wayne Williams, the man convicted in connection with one of the most horrific serial murder cases in U.S. history.
Tim Thomas told WSB-TV’s Aaron Diamant that he’d put his harrowing experience out of his mind -- until Atlanta city and police officials announced last week they are taking a fresh look at Williams’ case and retesting any evidence that remains to determine, once and for all, if Williams truly was the man responsible for killing more than two dozen men and boys between the ages of 6 and 28.
Thomas told the news station he was a senior at Harper High School in Atlanta when he was walking home one day. A man driving a white station wagon pulled up beside him and offered him a ride.
Thomas climbed in, but said he almost immediately knew something was not right.
“I said, ‘You’re driving so slow,’ I said, ‘Why don’t you just let me out and I can walk?’” Thomas said. “He said, ‘I can’t do that.’
“I said, ‘Oh boy.’”
Thomas said the man offered him cash for sex and, when he declined the offer, the driver refused to let him out of the vehicle.
“You run across a lot of stuff like that when you don’t have transportation,” Thomas told the news station. “There’s all kinds of weirdos gonna pick you up.”
A frightened Thomas said he was ready to fight and protect himself. At the intersection of Fairburn and Cascade roads, he made his move to escape. The driver grabbed his shirt.
Thomas said he managed to get out of the station wagon, dragging the driver behind him.
“By that time, he had some kind of rag he kept throwing in front of my face,” he said.
Thomas escaped with his life. He said he put the close call out of his mind until 2010, when he saw footage of Williams on television and immediately recognized the accused murderer’s thick glasses and Afro.
“I said, ‘Dang. That’s that guy that picked me up that night,’” Thomas said.
By that point, Williams had been in a Georgia prison for 26 years, convicted of murdering Nathaniel Cater, 27, and Jimmy Ray Payne, 21. Cater and Payne were both grown men, but the majority of the homicide victims Williams is suspected of killing were children.
Though Williams was tried for just two killings, the Atlanta Police Department attributed at least 22 of the other 29 known homicides to Williams and closed those cases. He is also a potential suspect in the case of a black child who went missing but was never found.
Now 60, Williams has maintained his innocence in the homicides. Others, including former investigators and parents of some of the victims, also doubt Williams’ guilt.
Thomas told WSB-TV last week’s announcement by Atlanta Mayor Kiesha Lance Bottoms and Police Chief Erika Shields made him decide to tell his story. He gave a sardonic smile as he talked of listening to news reports of Williams denying his guilt.
“This guy’s saying that he didn’t do it, and I’m saying, ‘No, man, no,” Thomas said. “This guy, he’s dangerous.”
Former FBI Special Agent in Charge Greg Jones told WSB-TV Thomas’ story is credible.
“I think the story he is telling, it didn’t seem rehearsed,” Jones told the news station. “It seemed credible to me.”
It could also be invaluable to investigators involved in the new probe of the slayings. They could use Thomas’ story to comb records for similar crimes that may have been missed.
They could also potentially gain additional insight into how Williams got close to his alleged victims. Williams, then a 23-year-old freelance cameraman and wannabe record producer, may also have used the promise of a potential music career to lure some of his young victims.
Atlanta police officials have created a hotline for tips in the case, The Atlanta Journal-Constitution reported. Anyone with information on the slayings can call 404-546-2603.
Regardless of the outcome of the new probe, Thomas told WSB-TV he is grateful to be alive.
“It could have went the other way, (from) what I know now,” he said.
Support real journalism. Support local journalism. Subscribe to The Atlanta Journal-Constitution today. See offers.
Your subscription to the Atlanta Journal-Constitution funds in-depth reporting and investigations that keep you informed. Thank you for supporting real journalism.