Skip to Main Content
Metro Atlanta

$164M verdict awarded to Georgia couple in birth injury trial

The couple’s attorneys say they believe it’s the largest medical malpractice verdict in Georgia and the fourth largest verdict of its kind in the country.
A Thomas County jury awarded over $164 million Wednesday to the parents of Grayson Lirette, 9, in their medical malpractice case against doctor Joseph Novak and his employer, Shaw Center for Women’s Health. (Courtesy Charis Lirette)
A Thomas County jury awarded over $164 million Wednesday to the parents of Grayson Lirette, 9, in their medical malpractice case against doctor Joseph Novak and his employer, Shaw Center for Women’s Health. (Courtesy Charis Lirette)
Rosie Manins

Jurors in South Georgia awarded over $164 million this week to a couple who alleged their child’s severe and permanent birth injuries were the result of negligence by a doctor.

The $164,586,856 verdict against Thomas County obstetrician-gynecologist Joseph Novak and his employer, Shaw Center for Women’s Health, came Wednesday in the third trial in the case, filed in 2018 by Ben and Charis Lirette.

South Georgia doctor Joseph Novak and his employer, Shaw Center for Women’s Health, were hit with a $164 million verdict in a medical malpractice case Wednesday. They denied liability. (Photo: Shaw Center for Women’s Health)
South Georgia doctor Joseph Novak and his employer, Shaw Center for Women’s Health, were hit with a $164 million verdict in a medical malpractice case Wednesday. They denied liability. (Photo: Shaw Center for Women’s Health)

Novak and the Thomasville health center denied wrongdoing. Their lawyers did not respond Thursday to questions about the case.

Charis Lirette told The Atlanta Journal-Constitution that she and her husband have relied on their faith in God to get through the yearslong legal battle on behalf of their son, Grayson, who turns 10 in January.

“Justice was finally served for our son,” she said Thursday. “We can’t heal his damaged brain, but now we have the resources to provide the absolute best life for him, and that’s a huge relief for us as his parents.”

The Thomas County couple have five children, between the ages of 21 and 6. Grayson needs round-the-clock care and will for the rest of his life after being starved of oxygen just before birth, case filings show.

Nelson Tyrone and Adam Malone, co-lead counsel for the Lirettes, told the AJC that they believe the verdict is the largest in any medical malpractice case in Georgia’s history and the fourth-largest verdict in any birth injury case in the country. And it’s believed to be the first time a Thomas County jury has found a doctor liable in a medical malpractice case, they said.

Thomas County couple Ben and Charis Lirette, front left, won a $164 million verdict Wednesday in their medical malpractice case. Afterward, they posed for a photograph in court with their lawyers (back from left) Robert Howell, Leighton Moore, Adam Malone, Nelson Tyrone and Cindy Poe. (Courtesy Tyrone Law Firm)
Thomas County couple Ben and Charis Lirette, front left, won a $164 million verdict Wednesday in their medical malpractice case. Afterward, they posed for a photograph in court with their lawyers (back from left) Robert Howell, Leighton Moore, Adam Malone, Nelson Tyrone and Cindy Poe. (Courtesy Tyrone Law Firm)

The Lirettes alleged that Novak failed to properly treat Charis Lirette’s placental abruption, in which her placenta separated from the inner wall of her uterus before delivery. Novak ordered Charis Lirette to be sedated when he should have increased monitoring of her and the baby, and he failed to properly communicate her worsening condition to others involved in her care, according to the couple’s case.

“By the time it became an emergency, there was a lot of confusion and chaos and a lot of mistakes were made,” Tyrone said. “They all started with (Novak), the captain of the team.”

Novak argued that the care he provided Charis Lirette was reasonable and met industry standards, pointing blame at nurses involved. In case filings, he and the Shaw Center said Grayson would have been fine if it weren’t for the nurses’ failures.

Claims against other defendants were resolved before the first trial, court records show.

On Tuesday, the jurors found in favor of the Lirettes. On Wednesday, they awarded $150 million in damages for Grayson’s pain and suffering, $13.4 million for his medical expenses and $1.1 million for his lost earning capacity.

The trial, which began Nov. 9, was held according to the new laws implemented last year by Gov. Brian Kemp in an effort to limit lawsuits and large verdicts against companies.

Malone said it was impossible to find jurors without some connection to Novak and the Shaw Center, given they are prominent healthcare providers for Thomas County’s approximately 45,000 residents. He said one of the jurors was delivered as a baby by Novak and other jurors were patients of the Shaw Center or the husbands of patients.

Despite that, Malone said he’s confident the trial complied with all applicable rules. He said the verdict is a significant achievement because Thomas County is fairly conservative, adding he grew up about 45 minutes north of there.

“A verdict like this in a county with a history like this one certainly shows everybody that justice is available,” he said.

Tyrone said the verdict was validating for the Lirettes, who were told since Grayson’s birth that nobody did anything wrong. He said the parents testified at trial and felt the jurors believed them and understood the lifelong needs that Grayson will have because of his injuries.

“These people are my heroes,” Tyrone said of the Lirettes. “They’re grateful every day because when Grayson was born there was no expectation that he would survive.”

Grayson is expected to have a normal life span, providing he continues to get the recommended level of care and support, Tyrone said.

Both Malone and Tyrone, who specialize in medical malpractice and birth injury cases, respectively, said they’ve never had a case go to trial as many as three times.

The first trial in the case, in 2023, ended in a mistrial because the jurors were deadlocked, court records show. The second trial, in 2025, had a different judge who declared a mistrial before the jurors were able to deliberate, based on what was said during closing arguments.

That second mistrial ruling was recently found to be improper and was set aside by Thomas County Superior Court Judge Gregory Voyles, who presided over the first and third trials.

Cindy Poe, another attorney for the Lirettes, said they’re grateful for the time, attention and consideration the jurors gave the case.