Fani Willis wants back in Trump case. Judges aren’t so sure.

Fulton County District Attorney Fani Willis’ fight to get back in the criminal case she brought against President Donald Trump and others was scrutinized Tuesday by a panel of judges on the state appeals court that ended her involvement almost two years ago.
Willis was disqualified from the 2020 election interference case because of her personal relationship with former special prosecutor Nathan Wade, who she hired to work on the case.
After the case was subsequently dismissed in November 2025 by a replacement prosecutor, Trump and a dozen other defendants sought almost $17 million in attorney fees from Willis’ office. They did so under a new Georgia law written for that purpose.
Fulton County Superior Court Judge Scott McAfee ruled earlier this year that Willis can’t intervene in the case to oppose the defendants’ fee requests, which have yet to be decided.
Willis appealed that decision to the Georgia Court of Appeals, which heard arguments Tuesday in Atlanta.
Judges Elizabeth Gobeil, Kenneth Hodges III and Wade Padgett questioned Willis’ arguments, including that it’s unfair for her to be shut out of litigation that could saddle her office with such a massive bill. Padgett pointed out that the government doesn’t have the same due process rights in a criminal case as a defendant.
“I think that we have held repeatedly that government is not entitled to due process,” Padgett said to Fulton County Chief Senior Assistant District Attorney Donald Wakeford, who argued on Willis’ behalf. “So why is it that you think there is anybody that is to represent the district attorney or the county? Under what theory? What language of the statute?”
Wakeford said the situation Willis finds herself in is confusing, in large part because the new state law allowing Trump and other defendants to seek attorney fees is riddled with problems.
“This statute has created a mess, and that is no secret,” Wakeford said. “The statute provides no guidance whatsoever about how anybody is supposed to handle this.”
Trump and the other defendants seeking attorney fees, including former New York mayor Rudy Giuliani, opposed Willis’ attempt to intervene. They argued in part that the state’s interests are adequately represented by the replacement prosecutor assigned to the case, Prosecuting Attorneys’ Council of Georgia Executive Director Pete Skandalakis.
The fact that McAfee let Fulton County intervene in the attorney fees debate further protects the interests of taxpayers, the defendants argued.
“It’s not a confusing case,” said Chris Anulewicz, an attorney for defendant Robert Cheeley who argued Tuesday on behalf of all the defendants. “It’s an easy case. The trial court was correct in denying the intervention request by the Fulton County District Attorney for a number of reasons.”
Wakeford said it’s improper for Skandalakis to represent the interests of Willis’ office because his dismissal of the prosecution led to the financial risk the office now faces. Wakeford noted that Skandalakis has expressed doubt about his ability to represent the office.
“What we have now is a situation that is unprecedented, quite literally,” Wakeford told the judges.
Padgett and Hodges indicated that McAfee is the “gatekeeper” tasked with ensuring the fight is fair. They questioned why that’s not enough.
But Wakeford said the defendants’ bid for almost $17 million from Willis’ office calls for an adversary to challenge the reasonableness of the request.
“Otherwise, the interests of the taxpayers are completely disregarded,” he said.
Gobeil asked how the defendants would be prejudiced by Willis’ involvement in the attorney fees debate. And she questioned if the defendants’ fees request relies on a finding that the case was dismissed because of Willis’ misconduct and not some other reason.
“The trial judge is going to have to find that it was improper conduct,” Anulewicz responded. “I think the record supports that.”
The judges also asked whether the fees fight should be couched as part of the criminal case or a related civil matter, as different rules apply depending on the answer.
Wakeford acknowledged that he is unaware of any legal precedent allowing intervention in a criminal proceeding. He said civil rules do apply to the defendants’ attorney fees request, evidenced by the fact that the new law allowing such a request refers to the relevant criminal case in the past tense.
Padget said the “elephant in the room” is the fact that a panel of three other Court of Appeals judges already decided that Willis should be disqualified from the case.
To that point, Wakeford said the earlier panel’s ruling disqualified Willis from the prosecution, not from the associated matter over attorney fees. He said the two are distinct from one another.
Anulewicz disagreed, saying the request for attorney fees is a motion in a criminal case, not a separate civil case.
Gobeil said the case “has wide ranging implications for everyone in the criminal justice system.”
The panel is expected to issue a ruling in coming months.
