Skip to Main Content
SUFFER THE CHILDREN

Rights of kids, adults clash before the bar

DeKalb prosecutor J. Tom Morgan and psychotherapist Nancy C. Aldridge discuss a case in the room used to videotape testimony of children involved in sex abuse cases. (Nick Arroyo / AJC Photo Archive at GSU Library AJCP164-042k)
DeKalb prosecutor J. Tom Morgan and psychotherapist Nancy C. Aldridge discuss a case in the room used to videotape testimony of children involved in sex abuse cases. (Nick Arroyo / AJC Photo Archive at GSU Library AJCP164-042k)
AJC
By Jane O. Hansen

Note: This article originally ran on June 9, 1989 as part of the AJC’s award-winning “Suffer the Children” series.

In Atlanta Municipal Court, a 4-year-old boy was recently ordered to stand and tell a robed judge the fine points of how his uncle had sexually molested him. Because the child was so small, he had to be lifted onto a table, putting him eye to eye with the judge and within arm's length of the accused.

As he stood on the table and nervously tried to answer attorneys' questions, the boy clutched the hand of Lisa W. Wise, a victim-witness assistant.

» "SUFFER THE CHILDREN" SERIES: Full series | Part 1 | Part 2 | Part 3 | Part 4 | Part 5 | Part 6 | Part 7

PART 6 OF THE SERIES

"I am appalled by how children are treated in this court," Ms. Wise said. "The judge never should have allowed it. The public defender never should have called this child to testify."

In Georgia, the abuse of children often extends into the courtroom, where the rights of defendants run smack up against society's duty to protect its children. In the struggle, children often lose.

"Unless the Constitution is amended, children can't be treated any differently [than adults]," said J. Dunham McAllister, a Jonesboro lawyer who last year successfully defended a man accused of sexually molesting his young stepson.

But critics charge there is a fundamental flaw in the legal system when the victim is a child: the failure to acknowledge that children are inherently unequal to adults and therefore need to be treated differently.

"The system is really organized to protect the rights of defendants, not children," said Ms. Wise, who is on loan to the city from the Metropolitan Atlanta Crime Commission. "Children are special witnesses and special allowances must be made for them."

In fact, a number of allowances have been enacted into state and federal law in recent years. But around Georgia, judges and prosecutors often don't take advantage of them. Sometimes, they're not even aware of them.

Juvenile Court Judge Virgil Costley Jr. says the state should review its laws and procedures to see if they uphold society’s mandate to protect its children. “I think we’re going to find out that they don’t,” the Newton County jurist believes. (Walter Stricklin / AJC Photo Archive at GSU Library AJCP164-042l)
Juvenile Court Judge Virgil Costley Jr. says the state should review its laws and procedures to see if they uphold society’s mandate to protect its children. “I think we’re going to find out that they don’t,” the Newton County jurist believes. (Walter Stricklin / AJC Photo Archive at GSU Library AJCP164-042l)

'You're Talking About . . . Millions of Dollars' 

Since 1974, federal law has dictated that any state receiving federal child abuse and neglect funds must ensure that all alleged child victims are represented in court by a "guardian ad litem" - someone other than the prosecutor or child's family - whose sole purpose is to represent the best interests of the child. Last fiscal year, Georgia was awarded - and accepted - $354,622 in the special funds.

Yet an Atlanta Journal-Constitution telephone survey - conducted March 16-24 and covering 77 of Georgia's 137 Superior Court judges - revealed that fewer than a quarter of them were aware of the law.

"I don't handle federal law," said one Middle Georgia judge as an explanation.

While most of the judges surveyed (55) said they occasionally appointed representatives for children, the majority said they did not do so on a routine basis. "Where there are only allegations [of abuse], you're talking about spending millions of dollars," said one metro Atlanta judge.

To avoid the costly use of lawyers as guardians ad litem, all but three states rely to some degree on trained volunteer citizens - called court-appointed special advocates (CASAs) - to protect children whose interests in court are often pitted against their parents.' Georgia began a CASA program earlier this year, but so far only two Georgia judges - in Newton and Hall counties - use the volunteer advocates.

Videotaping Used Infrequently in Georgia 

Georgia is probably not alone in its failure to abide by federal law on child witnesses, say legal experts. ''It's very unfortunate," said Howard A. Davidson, director of the American Bar Association's National Legal Resource Center for Child Advocacy and Protection in Washington, D.C., "because it was a clear intent of Congress that states should not receive any funding under the act unless every child in a judicial proceeding involving child abuse or neglect allegations was represented by a guardian ad litem."

Some critics blame the federal government for failing to enforce child welfare laws. Although the Children's Bureau of the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services is responsible for monitoring compliance, "we do not look at the guardian ad litem part," admitted one federal official who asked not to be named.

"They make it easy for the states to not fulfill the full intent of the law," said Kathryn M. Gannon, co-founder of the Georgia CASA program and a former Fulton County foster care worker.

Another reform used only sporadically in Georgia's court system is videotaping - initially hailed as a means for reducing the number of times a child needs to tell his story. Under a 1986 exception to the state's hearsay law, out-of-court statements by children under 14 describing alleged abuse are admissible as evidence, as long as the child is available to testify and the statement meets standards of reliability. Georgia is now one of 36 states whose laws allow videotaped testimony in criminal cases.

Again, the Journal-Constitution survey showed only occasional use of the tool, with 72 percent of the judges saying videotapes were seldom if ever used in their courtrooms or during pretrial proceedings, although several indicated they would allow them if prosecutors asked.

Family May Push Child to Retract Statements 

An exception is DeKalb County, where a videotape is made of all alleged child molestation victims almost immediately after they report abuse, then used throughout the proceedings. Not only is the child spared from having to repeat his story a number of times, but the videotape captures his statement as close in time to the incident as possible, prosecutors say.

Without that fresh account, children dragged through lengthy court proceedings are increasingly likely to forget the details and chronology of events - a developmental disadvantage that can provide fodder for defense attorneys at the trial.

Children also may be subjected to intense pressure by family members to retract their accusations. With a videotape of the original statement, "even if he recants the testimony, it doesn't mean you can't get a conviction," said Juvenile Court Judge Virgil Costley Jr. of Newton County.

Children must testify once the case gets to trial because of a defendant's constitutional right to confront his accuser. But at the preliminary hearing, where the goal is to determine whether there is enough evidence to prosecute further, defendants have no guaranteed right to confrontation.

With the help of videotapes, prosecutors say, children become better witnesses. J. Tom Morgan, assistant district attorney in DeKalb County and the state's first prosecutor assigned full time to child sex abuse cases, has his child witnesses view their videotapes to refresh their memories, just as adult witnesses prepare by reading their signed statements.

Sometimes the tapes aid in winning convictions before the case gets to trial. Mr. Morgan said that thanks largely to videotapes, his county now gets confessions in 30 percent of its sex abuse cases.

Critics Cite Lack of Training for Judges 

Perhaps no Georgia case has dramatized a child's plight in court as clearly as that of Ed R. Dickey of Gwinnett County, who was convicted last year of sexually molesting his two older daughters. The case jumped into the spotlight when the judge jailed one of the victims - an 18-year- old daughter - for refusing to testify against her father. The accused remained free on bond.

During the trial, the 16-year-old daughter's testimony prompted public outrage when she first collapsed on the stand and later was forced to undergo questioning by her father, who exercised his right to cross- examine her.

This case and others like it have raised what child advocates call yet another failure of the Georgia court system: the lack of training judges get in cases that deal with children.

Of the 12 hours of annual training mandated for Georgia Superior Court judges, none is devoted to issues pertaining to children, such as their developmental stages, their reliability as witnesses or - in the case of abused children - the conflicting love-hate relationship they often have with their abuser.

"Children will bond to pretty horrible people in pretty horrible relationships," said Dr. Leon A. Rosenberg, a child psychologist at Johns Hopkins University who specializes in child abuse. "They'll go out of their way to defend the parent."

The insensitivity of some Georgia judges to that kind of behavior leads to injustice, child advocates say. "Often the judge is living in a 1950s mentality, that homes are like Ward and June Cleaver, and that a kid should always be left with his mother or father," said David Lane, head of the Georgia Residential Child Care Association. "Too often they're sentencing children to an abysmal life."

The best response to untrained judges is to organize a court-watch group such as Mothers Against Drunk Driving, said Patricia A. Toth, director of the National Center for Prosecution of Child Abuse.

"What seems to make the biggest difference is if the local community in which that judge sits becomes more involved in the whole problem," Ms. Toth said.

Judge Costley says he wishes citizens would hold him as accountable for what he does with children's lives as they do for how much of their tax money he spends on a new typewriter. He too advocates better training, not only for judges but also for prosecutors and other lawyers involved in abuse and neglect cases.

"I think most of them feel very uncomfortable in these situations," he said. "Think about it. A child is very difficult to examine. And if you're going to talk about very intimate situations, such as in a sex abuse case, a lot of folks are very uncomfortable talking about such intimacy."

Judge Costley is one who goes out of his way to lessen a child's trauma in court. Whenever possible, he holds hearings involving children in his chambers, where he takes off his robe and sits in his shirt sleeves. "I might turn on some music," he said. "And my office looks like a disaster so it looks like a child's room." In the waiting room, he keeps dolls, stuffed animals and other toys for children to play with.

According to the newspaper survey, a number of Georgia judges (35) believe changes should be made to alleviate the pressure on child witnesses, including a broader use of videotapes and closed-circuit TV and more informal court procedures when children are involved.

But almost as many judges (32) said there was no need for change. "I am satisfied children are not being oppressed by the way the system is," said a central Georgia judge. (The remaining judges surveyed did not respond to the question.)

That divergence of opinion, said Judge Costley, is one reason the state needs to take a comprehensive look at its laws and procedures to see if they uphold society's mandate to protect its children.

"I think we're going to find out that they don't," he said.

'Still a Feeling Children Don't Tell the Truth' 

One statute that was examined this year and tossed out was the competency requirement, an archaic rule that said all children under 14 had to prove to the court their competency as a witness before their case could go to trial. The change was prompted by a case involving a DeKalb County 4-year-old girl who was raped so brutally that she required seven hours of reconstructive surgery. Because she froze during the competency hearing, her case never went before a jury. And the man accused of the crime walked free.

The new legislation, passed by this year's General Assembly, leaves the decision of a child's credibility to the jury.

But even if judges were trained, reforms passed and children given the legal protections already allowed, they would remain at a distinct disadvantage in the courtroom, experts say.

"I think there still is a feeling among adults that children don't tell the truth," said Mr. Morgan. "That's always been the feeling, and these cases are very difficult to prosecute."

Yet, national studies show that deliberately false allegations of sexual abuse range between 2 percent and 10 percent of the reports. A 1983 study by the C. Henry Kempe Center in Denver, Colo., showed that when the allegations were broken down, 6 percent were fictitious reports made by adults while only 2 percent were false allegations made by children.

"In other words, you don't have a lot of kids who are deliberately lying about having been abused," Ms. Toth said.

Physical abuse cases are even tougher to prosecute because of "this prevailing attitude in our society that while it is wrong for a neighbor to beat the hell out of another neighbor, it is OK for an adult to beat the hell out of his child," Mr. Morgan said.

Georgia's prison population seems to bear out the premise that prosecutors are probably more willing and able to convict adults who abuse children sexually than adults who abuse children physically. Between 1985 and 1988, 1,266 people spent at least some time in a Georgia prison for a crime related to sexual abuse of a child. That compares with 230 who were sentenced to prison under the state's cruelty to children felony statute, according to an analysis of Department of Corrections records.

"Everybody on the jury who's ever had children can imagine whipping a child to the point that someone else would think they're abusing them," said David E. Perry, district attorney for the Tifton Judicial Circuit. "But there's no way they can ever imagine having sex with a child."

Prosecutors say they often must go to extremes to convince a jury of the depravity of some adults. In Albany, N.Y., an assistant district attorney recently staged a dramatic demonstration to win a murder conviction against a man charged with killing his 3-month-old son. Under most state laws, people who beat their children to death are not charged with murder, which requires proof of intent to kill, but rather with the less serious felony of manslaughter.

To prove intent, the prosecutor asked the pathologist who had autopsied the child to show the jury what the man had done to kill his son.

Holding a baby doll by its ankles, the pathologist stood before the jury and began swinging it back and forth, violently smashing its head against the edge of a table.

The jury was convinced. The defendant, Dennis Shattell, was convicted of second-degree murder.