Confidentiality laws throw cloak of secrecy over abuse
Note: This article originally ran on June 4, 1989 as part of the AJC’s award-winning “Suffer the Children” series.
Among the Georgia children who died last year while under the state's protection were a little girl who was raped and found floating dead in a pond, a 14-month-old baby girl found dead on her parents' trailer floor from an apparent bathtub drowning, and a 13-month-old baby girl who was placed in a steaming hot tub of water after she removed her own diaper and soiled the bed sheets.
All three children were well-known to the county child welfare departments. But they died in relative anonymity.
» "SUFFER THE CHILDREN" SERIES: Full series | Part 1 | Part 2 | Part 3 | Part 4 | Part 5 | Part 6 | Part 7
PART 1 OF THE SERIES:
Georgia's child welfare system is shielded by a cloak of confidentiality that makes it nearly impossible for the public to scrutinize its activities. When an abused or neglected child dies in Georgia, almost no one is held accountable.
Georgia child welfare workers say the assurance of confidentiality is critical in convincing citizens to report abuse. Besides, they say, state and federal law clearly dictates that records involving children must remain private. Not only could they be sued or prosecuted if they broke that law, but they could lose their jobs, they say.
Yet a computer search of Georgia Supreme Court decisions, federal appellate cases and U.S. Supreme Court decisions turned up no successful lawsuit or criminal prosecution of a caseworker for violating confidentiality statutes in Georgia - or anywhere else in the country.
Furthermore, no child welfare worker in Georgia has ever been fired strictly for a breach in confidentiality as far as state officials can determine, said Joyce Goldberg, a spokeswoman for the Department of Human Resources.
"Confidentiality is a smoke screen that hides the abuses and failures of the system," said Richard L. McDevitt, president of the Georgia Alliance for Children. "Confidentiality laws were enacted to protect children from exploitation. But they have taken on a life of their own."
In some Georgia counties, child welfare officials are so loyal to confidentiality codes that they refuse to share information with local law enforcement officers. District Attorney Robert E. Keller of Clayton County said he finally was forced to sit down with the local child welfare director and talk about the fact that they were on the same side.
Many caseworkers believe they would be better off if they could tell their side of the story. New Jersey child welfare officials recently asked the federal government to loosen up confidentiality regulations so they could more effectively defend their decisions.
"We end up looking like such fools because we can't defend ourselves," said Carol Campbell, director of the Forsyth County Department of Family and Children Services.
It was Ms. Campbell's workers who investigated several child abuse complaints involving Charles Aaron Frix, who pleaded guilty to murdering his two sons, 2 and 3, last October.
Initially, Ms. Campbell declined to discuss the case because of confidentiality restrictions. But a document obtained by The Atlanta Journal-Constitution shows that her department had known of the family's problems for at least eight months.
Among the complaints filed was a report that the 2-year-old had cigarette burns on his body. Frix's 7-year-old daughter had told caseworkers that her father had threatened her with a butcher knife.
"The father, in front of the caseworker, stuck a pocketknife in the coffee table to show what the 7-year-old had described," the report says. "Caseworker explained that even this would frighten a small child."
Despite visits to the Frix home, Ms. Campbell said, the caseworkers were unable to substantiate any of the allegations. If they had had the facts, she said, they never would have left the children at home.
"You cannot go to court on your gut-level feeling," she said. "If you cannot see the cigarette burns, and there are no marks on the child, you just don't have a case."
Sheriff Wesley Walraven of Forsyth County, who first charged Frix with murdering his sons, also defended the department's handling of the case.
"I probably would have done the same thing they did," he said. "[The abuse of a child] needs to be out there overt before government interferes in a family's activities."
Ultimately, he said, the decision to remove a child is a judgment call.
It's those critical judgment calls - and the caliber of the people who make them - that critics say provide a compelling reason to crack open the system. "Sunlight is the best disinfectant," said Nat Hentoff, a writer for The Village Voice who has written extensively about New York's child welfare system.
Without a complete account of what happened in Forsyth County, there is no way of knowing whether Ms. Campbell's assessment of her agency's actions is an accurate one, said state Sen. Pierre Howard, chairman of the Senate Human Resources Committee. And the state's own internal review is not enough, he added.
"The whole purpose of [confidentiality] is to protect the children," said Mr. Howard, "and if the rules work against that, then the rules need to be changed. It's obvious that this is an area that needs to be examined."
Ms. Campbell agrees that a more open system might benefit from public concern.
"I think it would muster community support if they knew what our caseworkers are up against," she said.