The manager told police the woman, identified as Brandy Allen, started cursing and yelling when confronted.

Fayetteville police said the manager told them Allen rubbed her finger over the surface of the eye shadows to make them look used.

Allen, 31, was jailed Monday on shoplifting and disorderly conduct charges.

Featured

Fulton DA Fani Willis (center) with Nathan J. Wade (right), the special prosecutor she hired to manage the Trump case and had a romantic relationship with, at a news conference announcing charges against President-elect Donald Trump and others in Atlanta, Aug. 14, 2023. Georgia’s Supreme Court on Tuesday, Sept. 16, 2025, upheld an appeals court's decision to disqualify Willis from the election interference case against Trump and his allies. (Kenny Holston/New York Times)

Credit: NYT