The board of Atlanta’s economic development agency approved more than $17 million in tax incentives for several developers on Thursday, but tax breaks for a pair of projects at the former Turner Field caused a clash among board members, with one saying the agency needs to re-think its public investment strategy.
The board of Invest Atlanta narrowly approved a nearly $2.6 million tax break for a 680-bed, $69 million student housing project called Aspen Atlanta. It will rise in a parking lot on Ralph David Abernathy Boulevard, across from what is now called Georgia State Stadium.
The board also approved a separate, nearly $2 million tax incentive for a $50 million project nearby that will include a small office building, retail, restaurants and 129 apartments along Georgia Avenue.
The votes spurred a broader conversation among board members after the meeting about whether the city is seeing enough bang for the taxpayers’ bucks.
Board member Julian Bene said the city is seeing impressive job growth and development, fueled in part by the city’s tax incentives. But overall, the property tax digest has largely stagnated since 2010, and he suggested the city might be giving away too much.
“That is not the kind of thing we should be seeing with the economic growth we’ve had,” Bene said. “We need to grapple with this.”
Bene, often a lone critical voice on the Invest Atlanta board, said just starting development at the former home of the Atlanta Braves isn’t a good enough public benefit. The combined abatements only reserve at total of 18 units in the 129-unit apartment project as affordable for residents making 80 percent of the area median income. In that light, the tax breaks for the two projects come to about $277,000 per affordable unit over 10 years.
“The public benefit I’m hearing is new development in areas south of I-20,” Bene said. “I don’t think that is enough on its own.”
Others on the board disagreed, saying denying the tax breaks put the project at risk.
A recent investigation by The Atlanta Journal-Constitution found that the city of Atlanta and county governments in Fulton, Cobb, Gwinnett and DeKalb doled out $30.7 million in property tax incentives in 2016 to major projects and marquee companies in the name of economic development.
Those firms owed $72.6 million in local taxes after the tax breaks were taken into account. But some critics have questioned the need for incentives amid the economic boom.
The board also approved an estimated $5 million tax incentive for a new office tower by developer Portman in Midtown and a $7.6 million tax break for the redevelopment of Colony Square.
Though arguably the city’s hottest neighborhood, neither Midtown project attracted the sort of debate over incentives during the meeting as the two projects south of I-20.
Vice Chairwoman Constance Barkley-Lewis said the tax breaks are necessary to kick off the Turner Field redevelopment.
Banks, she said, “are not lining up to lend” money to the development team led by Atlanta-based Carter.
Georgia State University acquired the stadium and certain parcels earlier this year, with a development team led by Carter obtaining other land, including a number of key parking lots in the area for a mixed-use project.
Two Carter principals signed personal loan guarantees to secure financing – a not uncommon practice in real estate finance – to help kickstart development.
“The first money going into these neighborhoods is very, very difficult to get,” she said.
“It seems like a no-brainer we would develop these neighborhoods,” she said of private sector interest in the project. But the neighborhoods aren’t affluent as other parts of the city, making development there a bigger risk in the eyes of lenders.
“This is not a no-brainer at all,” she said.
After the vote, Carter President Scott Taylor said the tax deal “sets the stage for the first phase of the Summerhill project to begin.”
“We are in a very challenging lending environment and projects like Georgia Avenue might not be financially feasible but for programs like the bond for title,” Taylor said, referring to the lease-purchase bond mechanism Invest Atlanta and other such authorities uses to grant tax breaks.
Mayor Kasim Reed, who chairs the body, said the debate over affordability is “necessary and appropriate.” But, he said, members need to keep in mind promises for revitalization after the 1996 Summer Olympic Games were never fulfilled.
A no vote, he said, “puts this entire project at risk,” and would further hamper ability to recruit additional investment there.
The private development around Georgia State Stadium has been seen as one of several potential sites that state and local leaders could pitch for Amazon’s second North American headquarters project.
A number of residents in the surrounding neighborhoods complained they were not notified of the Invest Atlanta meeting until the last minute and that they haven’t been included in planning for development in the area. Public comment also was held after the votes and after Reed left the meeting.
“Low income residents who have kept these communities alive for 50 years aren’t invited to the table,” said Avery Jackson, of Peoplestown.
Others said development continues to bring the real risk of displacement for long-term residents, who could be pushed out because of rising property values.
“How are we going to remain in the city of Atlanta?” asked Peoplestown resident Alison Johnson. “Where is our return on investment?”
In April, Georgia State and developers reached a community benefits deal with neighborhood associations to address systemic flooding, provide jobs and education programs, and set aside at least 10 percent of new housing for low-income Atlantans. But a separate group of neighbors that sought a community deal hasn’t been satisfied.
MYAJC.COM: REAL JOURNALISM. REAL LOCAL IMPACT.
AJC Business reporter J. Scott Trubey keeps you updated on the latest news about economic development and commercial real estate in metro Atlanta and beyond. You'll find more on myAJC.com, including these stories:
- Atlanta-based Equifax hit with massive data breach
- Atlantic Station owners planning for next phase
- Will Falcons' new stadium drive more development to downtown Atlanta?
Never miss a minute of what's happening in local business news. Subscribe to myAJC.com.
In other development news:
Support real journalism. Support local journalism. Subscribe to The Atlanta Journal-Constitution today. See offers.
Your subscription to the Atlanta Journal-Constitution funds in-depth reporting and investigations that keep you informed. Thank you for supporting real journalism.