Norman Rockwell may have been the illustrator of all things Americana, but even he could feel the sting of rejection.

In the early 1930s, Coca-Cola, which many credit with creating our modern vision of Santa, was working with then-little known artist Haddon Sundblom on a series of paintings of Old Saint Nick for advertisements. Then in 1935 Rockwell, widely regarded for capturing a slice of America on canvas, pitched his version of Old Saint Nick as a possible alternative.

It didn’t make the cut.

“No one knows why Coke chose not to use Rockwell’s Santa,” said Ted Ryan, manager of Coca-Cola Archives. “It’s a mystery masked in an enigma.”

Rockwell actually did three paintings for Coca-Cola during that period that are missing today.

Last year, the company last year went on “Antiques Roadshow” in hopes of finding the missing artwork, valued at about $500,000 a piece, but had no luck finding them. Ryan said the company received several responses about the pieces, but each was a calendar or in-store display made from the paintings and not the original work.

Ryan declined to disclose the value of the Rockwell Santa, but said Coca-Cola acquired it from a private collector in New York City.

Rockwell’s Santa, as well as several other pieces the illustrator did for the company between 1928 and 1935, are on display in a new year-long exhibit at the World of Coca-Cola in downtown Atlanta.

The exhibit also features advertisements created from the three paintings Rockwell did for Coca-Cola.

About the Author

Keep Reading

Foo Fighters closed out Shaky Knees 2024 at Central Park with extended versions of their biggest hits. The indie rock festival has moved to Piedmont Park for this weekend's event. (Ryan Fleisher for the AJC)

Credit: Ryan Fleisher

Featured

In this file photo from October 2024, Atlanta Braves outfielder Jorge Soler and teammates react after losing to the San Diego Padres 5-4 in San Diego. The Braves and Soler, who now plays for the Los Angeles Angels, face a lawsuit by a fan injured at a 2021 World Series game at Truist Park in Atlanta. (Jason Getz/AJC)

Credit: Jason.Getz@ajc.com